Public case page for the admiralty action filed by Starboard Yacht Group LLC against M/V Octopussy and Contessa Marine Research LLC. 287 docket entries on CourtListener RECAP. This is the longest-running case in the portfolio (3+ years).
Key docket entries
Source: CourtListener RECAP · 339+ documents
DE 1 — Verified Complaint (in rem + in personam)
Filed 9/1/23 · 7 pages
Admiralty complaint against M/V Octopussy (in rem) and CMR (in personam).
DE 25 — Certificate of Interested Parties
Filed 9/18/23 · 3 pages
CMR identified affiliates: Kevin Burke, Jake Stratmann, Canan LLC d/b/a HTEC Marine, Steven Ivankovich, Anthony Ivankovich, Safe Harbor Lauderdale Marine Center.
DE 31 — Answer + Counterclaim + $4.6M funding exhibit
Filed 10/31/23 · 31 pages + 5 exhibits
CMR's answer with affirmative defenses and counterclaim. Exhibit 2 (DE 31-2) documents $4,604,641.18 in funding from CMR to SYG across 13 wire transfers (4/8/22 - 3/31/23).
public court filing · Verified · not a charge
DE 106 — Mediation Report
Filed 7/5/24 · 3 pages
Joint notice of mediation report and response to order to show cause.
DE 230-1 / DE 237 — CFO-Certified Repair Order Accounting (151 pages)
Filed 4/15/25 · 151 pages
Certified accounting across 156 repair orders ($0.00 unaccounted) docketed prior to trial and referenced at the February 23, 2026 bench trial (DE 312 Tr. 62).
public court filing · Verified · not a charge
DE 197 — Amended Answer + Counterclaim
Filed 5/9/25 · 28 pages + 5 exhibits
CMR's amended answer with funding exhibits and email correspondence.
DE 306–312 — Bench Trial Minute Entry, Trial Exhibits D-1/D-7/D-8 & Trial Transcript
Filed 2/23/26 · DE 306 minute entry; DE 308/309 exhibits; DE 312 155-page transcript
One-day bench trial. CMR e-filed trial exhibits D-1, D-7, and D-8 on the morning of trial (DE 309); Exhibit D-8 includes the April 6, 2023 written fund-allocation directive.
public court filing · Verified · not a charge
DE 314-3 (D-82) — Subpoena Production Identifying Three Gyro Unit Serials
Filed 3/18/26 · July 16, 2024 General Counsel subpoena correspondence
Subpoena production from manufacturer General Counsel to CMR counsel identifies the three M/V Octopussy stabilizer unit serial numbers as 212-0428, 212-0432, and 212-0433 (confirming two factory returns for credit and unit 35-212-0428 installed).
public court filing · Verified · not a charge
DE 319 & DE 328 — Notice of Appeal & Eleventh Circuit Reinstatement (No. 26-10941-C)
Filed 3/24/26 · Reinstated 5/19/26 (DE 328)
Appeal docketed in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (No. 26-10941-C) and reinstated May 19, 2026.
court order · appeal reinstated · Verified · not a charge
DE 331–334 — Unseal motion + Rule 60(d)(3)/(b)(4)/(b)(6) relief motion; both denied
Filed & denied 6/5/26 (paperless orders DE 333, DE 334) · full text now mirrored via RECAP
Stratmann moved to unseal DE 315 (his proposed findings + exhibits DE 315-1–315-4), arguing the seal accomplishes by indirection what DE 310 forbade directly (“contradictory exhibits… should be used to illustrate lack of credibility”), and moved for relief from the DE 299–300 default judgment under Rule 60(d)(3) fraud-on-the-court, 60(b)(4) void judgment, and 60(b)(6) — citing the DE 310/317 seal inconsistency, the IFP denial's LLC misidentification, and trial-day service/evidence issues. Both motions denied by paperless order the same day; no stated reasons on the docket.
party filing + court order · Verified · not a charge
DE 337 & DE 338 — Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law & Final Judgment
Entered 9/15/26 (DE 337) & 9/18/26 (DE 338) · full text now mirrored via RECAP
40-page findings order + final judgment. The court pierced SYG's corporate veil (Stratmann = alter ego), held him jointly and severally liable as a joint tortfeasor for fraud, conversion, negligent misrepresentation, and breach of fiduciary duty, and applied general maritime law. CMR wired $4,504,641.18 for the refit (4/8/22–3/31/23); forensic accountant Burell traced $3,027,994.72 that could not be substantiated (objections overruled). Documented double-payments: $1,016,242.50 to FDDA (engines) + $346,500 to Voith (jets, $251,500 misapplication evidence). Seakeeper units: $827,699.42 wired, none installed; Stratmann personally netted $362,072.20 (refund + sale proceeds per DE 288-1). LMC chargebacks $226,502.19 pocketed. Documented subset $2,141,951.61 + $886,043.11 unaccounted gap = $3,027,994.72. Repair Orders found not credible (Invoice 40590/40539 same-technician double-billing). Adverse inference on missing records (Mag. Valle DE 233). Footnote 22 expressly rejects the combined-exposure theory: “Stratmann does not owe $9,674,154.35.”
court order · Verified · not a charge
DE 339 — Rule 59(e) Motion to Alter or Amend Judgment (Clerk-Stamped Filed 10/16/26)
Filed 10/16/26 (Clerk intake stamp) · Entered 10/19/26
Timely pro se Rule 59(e) motion to alter or amend the September 18, 2026 final judgment (DE 338), bearing the Clerk's October 16, 2026 intake stamp (28th day under Rule 59(e), tolling the appellate clock under FRAP 4(a)(4)(A)(iv)), with supplemental exhibit appendix (Exhibits A–J, including DE 237 151p accounting, 13-wire Fedwire origination records, and DE 314-3 three-unit serial production).
party filing · Alleged · not a charge
DE 340 — Response in Opposition to DE 339
Filed 10/30/26 · Contessa Marine Research LLC
CMR's response in opposition to the Rule 59(e) motion.
party filing · public court filing · Verified (document) · not a charge
DE 341 — Order Denying Rule 59(e) Motion
Entered 11/3/26 · S.D. Fla. 0:23-cv-61696-AHS, DE 341 · full text now mirrored
DE 339 motion DENIED on relitigation grounds: the 59(e) arguments “relate to challenging the relevant accounting, his individual liability, and the damages awarded, all of which were presented at trial, in post-trial filings, or were arguments available… prior to judgment” (citing Linet, 408 F.3d 757; Watkins, 2021 WL 1838902). Judgment stands; payment due 3/1/2027 with statutory interest (DE 338).
court order · Verified · not a charge
Fraud pattern pins — public-record flags
Each pin cites a hosted public docket entry, exhibit, or sworn filing. A pin is a pointer to a source document — it is not a charge and not a finding of criminal liability. Labels: Verified = the cited document exists as described; Alleged = a party’s pleading; Analysis = our characterization of a documented sequence.
Intervenor billing-structure exhibits — DE 61 / DE 94
CMR docket · DE 61 verified intervenor complaint · DE 94 amended complaint · Ex. 2 = SYG 6/10/22 email · chargeback exhibits ≈ $226,501.19–$226,502.19
Sworn pleadings filed by SHM LMC (Lauderdale Marine Center) through Stroup & Martin, P.A. attach SYG’s June 10, 2022 email directing billing through SYG’s resale certificate and tax cap, plus chargeback exhibits. DE 94 signature block: /s/ Farris J. Martin III and James W. Stroup — Stroup & Martin, P.A., not Akerman. The billing-through-SYG structure is documented in the filers’ own pleadings; total billed/damage dollar figures remain REPORTED pending invoice-level verification.
public court filing · Verified (document) / Alleged (characterization) · not a charge
SK35 warehouse testimony + serial audit
DE 312 trial transcript Tr. 86:4–7 (2/23/26) · Linda serial audit · DE 314-3 serial production
At Tr. 86:4-7, Ivankovich testified a third unit was “sitting in a Fort Lauderdale warehouse”. DE 314-3 records Octopussy serials 35-212-0428, 35-212-0432 and 35-212-0433. The separately cited inventory identifier 221-0589 must not be equated with those serials without custody and transaction evidence. The excerpt does not identify the warehouse unit by serial number. The testimony is a witness allegation, not an adjudication of theft or an established serial-number match.
Verified (testimony/document) / Alleged (underlying conduct) / serial identity unresolved / not a charge
Florida DOR tax-violation referral — measured sent event
Resale certificate 16-8014975102-2 · DOR report sent 4/13–14/26 to the Florida DOR tax-violations inbox (address redacted) · Bates SKR-MD-006827..006837 · §§ 212.12/212.15/213.30 + Form DR-55
A Florida Department of Revenue tax-violation report documenting resale-certificate routing on CMR charges was transmitted in April 2026 — a measured sent event, not an allegation. The referenced ledger (SYG-101265) shows $0.00 tax on $479,105.67. Aggregate dollar figures in the report remain REPORTED pending invoice-level pins.
agency referral · Verified (transmission) / Alleged (underlying claim) · not a charge
Counsel-conflict — Akerman LLP (DE 293 / DE 313)
A disqualification motion targeting Akerman was denied without merits review — one front of a three-front conflict pattern (Seacoast counsel, Ivankovich debtor counsel, CMR-side). Rulings Verified; motive Alleged.
docket entries · Verified / Alleged · not a charge
Judicial credibility findings — DE 337 Findings of Fact
S.D. Fla. 0:23-cv-61696-AHS · DE 337 (entered 9/15/26) · Judge Raag Singhal · bench trial DE 306–312
The court’s findings include: Stratmann’s “reliance on excuses and his refusal to take accountability diminishes his credibility”; the court considered his “voluntarily absent[ing]” from trial in evaluating credibility; “an excellent independent example of his inability to be truthful” (tardiness account vs. sheriff’s return at 2:07 p.m.); Repair Orders “are not credible” and “SYG was submitting fraudulent Repair Orders” (Invoice 40590 double-billing); and “Stratmann cannot credibly account for the disposition of the funds” — an additional $886,043.11 unaccounted on top of $2,141,951.61. Counterweight: the court found Mr. Burell’s credibility preserved “especially in regard to unsubstantiated funds.” These are judicial findings — the court’s own credibility determinations, not our characterization.
court findings · Verified (judicial findings) · not a charge
SK35 warehouse allegation - sworn trial testimony
DE 312 trial transcript Tr. 86:2–10 (2/23/26); speaker sworn Tr. 63–64: Steven Ivankovich, manager of Contessa Marine Research · witness index: “investigator” Tr. 25:19, 86:5 · DE 337 § Seakeeper Units
Under oath as Contessa Marine Research’s manager, Steven Ivankovich testified: “A second Seakeeper was sold. And a third one was essentially stolen and based on the work of our investigator is sitting in a Fort Lauderdale warehouse where Mr. Stratmann and a former employee, Mr. Seinitz, are actively trying to sell.” The same testimony states Contessa Marine was never reimbursed the $793,000 and that Seakeeper “were threatened with litigation by Mr. Stratmann if they talked to us about it.” The passage is Verified testimony; the theft characterization is Alleged conduct, not itself a judicial finding. DE 337 separately found none of the three units were installed. The defendant disputed the account in Rule 59(e) materials citing DE 314-3; DE 341 denied the motion. DE 314-3’s qualified July 2024 statement that 35-212-0428 was still installed uses “As far as we know”. Different dates and serial chains require custody evidence before asserting a contradiction or perjury; 221-0589 is a separate identifier. The excerpt does not identify who the investigator was, whether a licensed private investigator was retained, or what the investigation comprised — the basis-of-knowledge question (how the declarant learned the unit’s location) is flagged as an open source question, not an established fact.
sworn testimony · Verified (testimony) / Alleged (theft) · not a charge
Audit and professionals testimony - Tr. 91
DE 312 trial transcript Tr. 91:10-17 (2/23/26); Steven Ivankovich, under oath.
At Tr. 91:10-17, Ivankovich testified that CMR tried to commence a physical and financial audit and “hired professionals to review the work of the vessels”. He said CMR was “provided with documents that were either irrelevant or fabricated after the fact” and “We never got any information.” These are the witness’s statements. This excerpt does not identify the professionals or establish that they were the investigator mentioned at Tr. 86. The fabrication characterization remains an allegation, not a judicial finding from this excerpt.
sworn testimony · Verified (testimony) / Alleged (fabrication claim) · not a charge
Engine custody testimony - Tr. 106
DE 312 trial transcript Tr. 106 (2/23/26) · Ivankovich cross-examination
The transcript records Ivankovich’s answer that engines were at the storage facility of Florida Detroit Diesel-Allison and his description of “newly fabricated engines”. Later on the same page, when asked about “$500,000”, he answers “They’re still in the boat” and says the boat is in Dubai. He also accuses Stratmann of not removing and selling engines as promised. These are contextualized witness statements, not independent confirmation of the vessel’s current location or a judicial finding about engine custody.
sworn testimony · Verified (testimony) / Alleged (claims) · not a charge
Court intervenes on “fabricated” / “You lied” exchange — Tr. 121
DE 312 trial transcript Tr. 121 (2/23/26)
Pressed to specify how a document was fabricated, Ivankovich answered “completely inaccurate, unsubstantiated, and fabricated” and, when asked “in which way,” replied “You lied.” The Court intervened: “Ask a question that’s relevant to the case. You’re literally leading him down a path where he is showing fraud on your part. Try to focus on helping yourself, not hurting yourself.” The exchange is Verified as transcript text, including the Court’s bench observation during questioning. The court’s later written findings and final judgment are summarized separately above.
court record · Verified (transcript incl. court observation) · not a charge