Good morning, all. This trial is in the matter of CFI 091 2024 and CFI 068 2024 is being held by way of video conferencing before His Excellency Justice Michael Black with the sitting of the hearing taking place in Dubai. Any orders or directions made during the course of or after this hearing will be issued by the registry in Dubai on the judge's instructions. The claimant is represented by Charles Russell and Hanlins. Lead counsel is Mr. Matthew Watson. The defendant is represented by Pinsent Masons and lead counsel is Mr. Lawrence Page. Thank you, Your Honor. >> Thank you very much. Uh could we just deal with some housekeeping first of all? Uh Mr. Watson, could you just map out what's been agreed between you and Mr. Page over the next couple of days? >> So, today, um unless Milan time estimate has changed, is the evidence of Mr. Alankovich for the entirety of the day. Um I don't know whether um Mr. Page is ever able to update his his time estimate, but that's certainly what's allocated. And then uh tomorrow would be the defendant's witnesses. So, that's Mr. Al Jaziri and Mr. Haider Abadwala. >> Yes. Um Mr. Al Jaziri is now going to give evidence in Arabic. Is that right? >> He He is. And um I think uh it was communicated both to the court and the um the defendants that I I sort of put down a marker about whether my time estimate would remain the same given that cuz obviously with the involvement of an interpreter, it can it can sometimes slow things down. But But I suggest we sort of see how we go. >> Yes. When were we first told that an interpreter was necessary? >> Uh I think it was about Friday evening. >> Okay. Uh Mr. Al Jaziri has always conducted business in English and all his interactions have been in English. >> Um well, Mr. um Ivankovich doesn't speak Arabic. So, >> No, well, all all the documents all the documents are in English. >> They they are. >> Yes, okay. Right, well, it's his right. Uh anything else then by way of housekeeping? >> There's nothing from me. >> Uh Mr. Page, anything by way of housekeeping? >> Uh no, Your Honor, just in terms of Mr. uh Al Jaziri, uh and he he will explain for himself in due course. But as I understand it, his practice has been to use the auto-translate function uh in his recent communications. And you you will you you may well have noticed from his emails that they are very well written in English. But as I understand it, that that isn't that I I met Mr. Al Jaziri last week and it became obvious to me that uh he needs an interpreter. >> Yes, well, he's he's entitled to an interpreter, certainly. Good. Okay. Um shall we then proceed with Mr. Ivankovich's >> Yes, in which case yes, I I call Mr. Ivankovich. >> Okay. Uh could we swear Mr. Ivankovich in, please? >> [clears throat] >> Yes, thank you, Your Honor. Please, can the witness confirm whether they would prefer to swear on oath or by affirming? >> Uh I by affirming, please. >> Thank you. Can you please confirm your name and occupation for the court's record? >> Uh Steve Ivankovich. My occupation is that of investor. >> Please repeat after me. I affirm >> I affirm >> that I will say nothing. >> that I will say nothing >> but the truth. >> but the truth. >> Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Good morning, um, Mr. Ivankovich. I'm conscious it really is morning for you. Um >> Indeed. >> Could we please go to page 74 in the bundle? Is that your first statement in the claim brought by Contessa? >> Yes. >> And if we go to page 83 is that your signature at the bottom there? >> It is. >> And if we go to page 105 is that your second witness statement in the claim brought by Contessa? >> Yes, it is. >> And if you go to page 111 is that your signature? >> Yes, it is. >> And if we go to page 640 is that your first witness statement in the claim brought by you personally? >> Yes, it is. >> And if you go to page 667 is that your signature? >> Correct. Yes, it is. >> And if you go to page 690 is that the second the witness statement in the claim brought by you personally? Sorry, Mr. Ivankovich, can you hear me? >> I I can't hear you. >> He seems to have gone on mute. >> Yep. >> He has that Yeah, yes, it is. >> And could we go to page 706? Is that your signature at the bottom? >> Yes, it is. >> And are the contents of these four witness statements true to the best of your knowledge and belief? >> Yes, they are. >> Thank you. Please wait there. You'll have some questions from Mr. Page. >> [clears throat] >> Mr. Ivankovich, good morning. Uh you're not on camera for me, but I understand you are for others. So, I'm just going to >> Yes. Yes. Yes. >> The name's Lynch. The name. So, I just checked, Mr. Ivankovich. Does the name for you show up as Daniel Lynch on your computer? >> I I'm on two screens. Uh one is showing I Daniel Lynch, who's my attorney here in Chicago, whose office is I'm testifying from. And the second screen, um it is showing no name. >> I I think I've now found you. Um Sorry about that. Um had a nice to to see you. And hopefully you can hear me okay. Um Mr. Ivankovich, we're going to go through a number of different documents today and I'll ask you listen to the question carefully and then answer if you can. If you need any any further information from me, please let me know. Um Let's start with the Contessa claim. Do you recall that the first payment was made on the 26th of May 2023? >> That sounds about right. >> And that was before the contract was signed with KJM. >> Um I don't specifically recall, but I I think I testified that to my witness statement. Yes. >> Yes, so the the contract signed the >> in in about middle of June 2023. So, when the payment was made, there were no written terms agreed. Do you Do you Do you accept that? >> Yes. >> Uh in terms of the information available to you at that time about the yacht, uh as I understand it, the only document you'd seen was the uh Volvo Penta sea trial report. Is that right? >> Uh Well, no. The I was given a general brochure from the manufacturer in addition to the to that report. >> Well, we haven't seen that in disclosure, but we What we have seen is the sea trial report. This is at page 857 of the uh bundle. Can you turn that up, please? And if you see that at the top, this was uh sent through uh to your lawyers originally, uh Casey Fleetman at Moore & Co. on the 24th March 2023. See that? >> I do. >> And then over the page, what we learn from this is we have a uh one photograph of the uh uh of the vessel, and at the bottom of that page, you can see that the survey was taken uh or the sea trial conducted of about 4 months before this email was sent. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And the uh the document focuses on the mechanical condition of the vessel only. You agree with that? >> Yes. >> Uh and you were happy to proceed with the purchase based on that one document about this particular vessel. Do you accept that? >> Not exclusively, but the document was part of my decision-making to proceed. >> Well, the brochure was that a general brochure or or brochure for this actual vessel? >> I I recall being shown a general brochure by Mr. Al Jassmi. Uh what what also convinced me to move it was I would categorize as very uh persistent and insistent um pushing by Mr. Al Jassmi to to get involved in this transaction. >> Well, salesmanship, we we might call that. Um >> I I wouldn't categorize it that way, but you certainly can. >> Okay. Uh So, you had seen enough um to know you wanted to you were prepared to put money up for the vessel and your purpose buying that was to earn a profit from it. Is that right? >> That's correct. Yes. >> Uh So, it wasn't the idea ever that you would own the purchase this to use it yourself. >> Um that wasn't the intention. >> Uh and to the best of your knowledge at the time you put the money in, it was sitting in Silent Eagle's yard, yes? >> Um that's what I was told. >> Uh that it was fully complete. >> That's what I was told. >> Uh and that uh uh It um uh Turning on then, do you did you did you have a price agreed at the time you made the original transfer? >> I'm sorry, did you Can you please repeat that? >> Had you agreed a final price for the vessel when you made the first transfer? >> Um I I do recall that there there was a final purchase price mentioned to me. >> Mentioned to you, but was it Had it been agreed or not? >> Uh there there wasn't a formal agreement. There was certainly an oral understanding among the parties. >> So, as at the 26th of May 2023, how much did you think you would be paying for the vessel? >> Uh in in total uh approximately $4 million. dollars. >> Um the reason you moved quickly was because this was going to be a bit of a bargain. Do you accept that? >> Uh I do not. I I I moved quickly because there was constant badgering by Mr. Al Jasmi. I I really did not want to engage in this transaction. But because this was a a new relationship uh I wanted to be a good partner and I and I thought the ultimate profitability of this venture would be good for the business uh because we were delayed in delivering the product which was just construction of of vessels at KJI. So, I made a commercial decision which I thought would be in the best interest of the partnership in the long-term relationship. >> And part of this commercial decision was that uh KJM had negotiated the $1 million price reduction. Um do you recall that? >> Well, I recall that was told to me. Uh I had no independent knowledge that was true or not. >> But you you told it and you trusted and accepted that information. >> I I I accepted it only in that with the final price what purchase price would be. >> And you had no reason to particularly to doubt that unless they were lying to you. >> Well, that is certainly a possibility. >> Well, at the time did you think they were lying to you or at the time did you trust them? >> Uh at the time I did not believe I had no reason to believe they were they were lying to me. >> So, let's have a look at page 918 of the bundle. >> Uh before you do, I'm very loath to uh interrupt cross-examination, uh Mr. Page, but uh can I just ask uh Mr. Vankovich to clarify an answer uh he gave a moment ago. Um it it uh for the transcript, it's page eight. Uh the answer begins at line four. Uh I really uh I really did not wish to engage in this transaction, but because this was a new relationship, I wanted to be a good partner. I thought the ultimate profitability of this venture would be good for the business because we were delayed in delivering the product, which was just construction of vessels at KGI. Uh KGI wasn't actually constructing any vessels at uh in in in May 2023, was it? >> Uh your your honor, we had began we had begun with a a small vessel whose project name was the Arrow. Um at the time, I believe we had purchased molds and were refining them. Uh there there was some prototype boats built at the time, I recall. >> Okay, thank you very much. Sorry to interrupt, Mr. Page. >> Of course. >> So, Mr. Vankovich, we're just going to have a look at page 918 uh in the bundle. And if we zoom in there on the first bullet point in the purple text, uh if you read that to yourself, please. >> That is the bullet point that begins with as you are aware? >> Yes. >> I'm finished. >> Uh you have no reason to doubt the accuracy of that bullet point, do you? >> Uh at the time I didn't. >> Let's move on to the survey itself. Do you accept that the survey was carried out uh between the 6th and the 10th of July, 2023? >> I accept that's what the document said. >> And that followed a 5-day inspection uh of the uh of the vessel, yes? >> Uh that's what was portrayed in the document, correct. >> If you'd been shown that survey in July 2023, would you have said that the vessel was in a condition to be delivered? >> No. >> Uh and is that that's due, as I understand it, to some of the defects uh in the vessel and the snag list, is that right? >> No. A a document is simply a document. We We Americans have many colloquialisms, and one of my favorite from Texas is you can't really explain a horse to a man until he rides it. A a typical process of a survey and inspection of a boat it would be a physical inspection either by yourself or a trusted representative. So, while that survey would have been a a a good road map or guideline uh to to establish a baseline third-party review, it always is followed up by a physical inspection to to check what is in that report as accurate and perceived correctly. >> So, the the easy all throws um uh the the riding of the horse, that would have to be done by you or one or one of your employees. Is that right? And not a surveyor. >> Well, no. A trusted representative and generally it would be with a surveyor. >> Uh what Well, let's look at what happened here. Uh Uh so, first of all, just in terms of the the vest the the the survey and then we'll come on to some of the surrounding story. Um Uh You you make no mention in your answer to me there about the defects. So, that that actually wasn't an issue then for you. >> Well, it wasn't an issue because I wasn't given the survey in July of 2023. >> Well, my my question to you is slightly different that that if you had been shown the survey in July 2023, would you have said that the yacht was in a condition to be delivered? >> Co- Counsel, I'm sorry. I'm getting a terrible echo. Let me see if if I can if it changes if I take off the headphones. Can you try that again, sir? >> Yes. Um my my question to you My my question to you is that if you had been shown the survey in July 2023, would you have said that the yacht was in a condition to be delivered? >> Uh I based on the survey alone, no. >> And that was because of the defects. Is that right? >> Uh in part. Ag- again, um every single vessel we've purchased, invested, or financed in is followed by a physical inspection with a surveyor to go through the report, at least one. >> Uh Do you accept that this was a trade sale? It was a purchase from a manufacturer to a effectively another manufacturer or a trade buyer. >> If you could please clarify that question, I'm not really sure what you mean by the trade buyer. >> Well, KJM KJM are not an end user, correct? >> No. >> No. And KJM have its own facilities and can carry out maintenance works on vessels, yes? >> No, that is incorrect. The KJM facility was in fact the KJI facility. >> Well, KJM is able to arrange for maintenance of vessels and repairs, yes? >> Definitely not a vessel of this size and this nature. And as a matter of fact, one of the reasons we went into partnership with KJM and KJI was that they were a good maker of what I would say rudimentary finish of vessels. And they had only had experience selling in the Gulf. They were by no means ready to sell vessels based on their fit and finish in a market such as the US or Europe. So, I I would disagree that they had either the capability, the facilities. The KJI facility was landlocked. So, you couldn't bring a 70-ft vessel to this facility. There would have to be a a a third-party wet dock or a dock with a a huge crane rented to be able to service this kind of vessel, but I had no indication that there was that level of technology or expertise with KJM to to be able to service this vessel. >> You accept they could carry out polishing of the stainless steel. >> You know, I'm I'm sorry. Can you please speak up? >> Do Do you accept that they could carry out polishing of the stainless steel? >> Um there there were there were staff on site that were qualified to do that, correct? >> And other general maintenance like keeping it clean and tidy. >> Not only could the staff of KJM or KJA do that, I I certainly was qualified to do that. >> Okay. What was the retail estimate for the for the vessel when you purchased it? >> Uh the the the range the range that I recall would be a net profit in the million-dollar range. >> So, let's let's work on the end-user price. As at May 2023, what did you think the end-user price would be? >> Um it would have been in excess of $5 million. That was the target. >> And by the time that this transaction was happening, you had already been involved in more than 100 boat purchases. Is Is that correct? >> Uh that sounds like an accurate number. I I've been involved in boats since I was 12 years old, so we've quite extensive. I couldn't give you an exact number. >> So, you tell us in your witness statement paragraph six. This is just a page 75. We will turn this up briefly. So, you tell us there it's uh 15 years in the yacht sales and charter business and approximately 100 boats. So, I think actually you're saying to us it's Um forgive me, but I I I think you're probably more than 37 years old as of as of today. So, rather more than 15 years experience. >> Yes, correct. >> Um So, but otherwise, that statement is accurate, sir? >> Yes, it is accurate. >> Um And when purchasing boats, um snagging uh and dealing with snag lists on new builds entirely routine. Do you accept that? >> Yes. >> Um Do you agree that the surveyor's conclusion about the vessel, that it was satisfactory to good, was appropriate? >> You know, those are very subjective terms, which is again common practice, almost religious practice, when purchasing a boat, is you start with a surveyor's report. You take that surveyor's report and often with the surveyor and review the specific list on the vessel. Uh those are subjective terms. I've never worked with this surveyor. Obviously, with surveyors that you work with in the past, that you're familiar with what they do, uh you you develop a common language and you tend to have an understanding of what is meant by satisfactory or good. Tho- Those were simply words until we had the ability to corroborate the document with the physical vessel. >> Mr. Van Winkle, I think to put this formally to you, I suggest to you that there's nothing in the report which justifies refusing delivery of the vessel. Do you accept that? >> I don't accept it. >> Uh and I suggest to you that any genuine trade buyer would have proceeded on the basis of the Admiral Marine survey. Do you accept that? >> Uh that is a preposterous statement. No No No buyer of a boat of this size, complexity, or price would accept it sight unseen with a surveyor that they've never used before that wasn't contracted by them. >> Uh and I suggest to you that KGM could have resolved all of the snagging points even if Sun Eagle did not do so. Do you accept that? >> Absolutely not. They They've never worked on a boat of this size. Number one. Number two, that would have been ridiculous to do since these would have been warranty items to be snagged, and it would have ate into the ultimate profitability of the venture, which would have affected us. So, all of those defects are common practice to be done at the yard under warranty work. There There is a constant fight between the end user or the dealer and the manufacturer on what is covered under warranty. Uh that that It's It's bad enough with American or British manufacturers, but to to collect warranty repairs and monies from a Chinese manufacturer would have even been more problematic and complex. So, number one, I don't accept that KGM had either the skills or the facilities to cure those defects. And if they did, it would have been at a cost that would have eaten into the profitability, and that would have been just silly. >> Uh in terms of the warranties, do you consider it likely that the air conditioning units had a warranty attached to them? >> Do I consider it likely? >> Yes. >> Well, they they should have, but since I've never actually seen the contract of the purchase of this vessel, despite asking for it numerous times, it's impossible to tell what the manufacturer would have warranted or not warranted. So, it's it's a it's an impossible speculation because all of that would have been in the contract. >> Let's move on to the story about what happened in in 2023, and the arrangement of the survey, and the events after that. Um Um Mr. Oliver Hand, uh it Tell me his job title. >> Uh he is a director of maritime of of our maritime operations within the family office. And when I say that, I to clarify, the Ivankovich family office in general. >> Uh If someone were to go on to his LinkedIn profile, there's no indication there that he's a qualified surveyor. Is that right? >> I I've never seen his LinkedIn profile. >> So, do you know whether he is Do you know whether he is a qualified surveyor? >> Uh I do not, no. >> Um Certainly, >> [clears throat] >> when when you ask him to inspect yachts, it's not to do so as a surveyor. >> Um No, we we often bring a surveyor with us when he when he goes. >> And Mr. Hand was the person who oversaw the purchase in 2023, is that right? >> Um If you when you he was involved in it with me, um I I overseeing is a broad term, but in the general sense he was assisting in the purchase. So I I I guess that would be a yes. >> Well, let's just follow through the story here. So, we've already had a look at the email at the page 857. If you can bring that back up, please. So, what what seems to have happened here is that Perush has sent an email to Casey Fleischman, and she's sending that on to Mr. Hand and CC'ing yourself and Mr. Moore. Is that right? >> That is correct. >> Um then the original plan was for Mr. Hand to review the vessel himself. Is that right? >> Uh By that, do you mean the original plan was him for him to travel to China to inspect the vessel? >> Correct. >> Uh it wasn't him alone. There was a qualified surveyor and maritime architect named Jan Thore Vassen that was to travel with him as well. >> Well, let's have a look at the document, page 900. So, we have here this is a a WhatsApp exchange between Mr. Hand and I believe Mr. Al Jazzmi. Uh and you see that on the left-hand side there is a uh Mr. Al Jazzmi sends through an invitation to Mr. Hand. >> Can Can you please uh scroll that up so I can see the title? I'm sorry, down down. Um Yeah, I I see that this seems to be a text message from Mr. Hand. Uh where do you see Mr. Aljasmi's name? >> Well, it it's You see the text is in Arabic. >> Uh at the at the very bottom, I do see some Arabic text, yes. >> Also, in the middle, uh it's been it's now been superimposed with an English translation of 23rd of May 2023. But, you can tell the user here is uh that has a phone set to Arabic uh the Arabic language. >> Uh okay. I I >> Um >> So, let me There's definitely There's definitely Arabic on the page, yes. >> Okay. Uh and let's just have a look at that letter itself. That's on page 899. And this is an invitation from the manufacturer uh for Mr. Hand to visit uh the the premises. >> Yes? Correct. >> Um now, we haven't seen any other letters of invitation to uh uh uh any other uh any surveyor. So, you've just given me a couple of names, but there's no reference to those names in the documents. >> Uh in in this particular document, correct, but I it it would be safe to assume that Mr. Thorvaldsen would have gotten his own document. Uh my my testimony is in I and I believe it's in my witness statement that Mr. Oliver Hand and Mr. Jan Thorvaldsen were scheduled to travel or planning to travel to inspect the boat in China. >> Uh Well, I suggest that that it was Mr. Hand who was going to be going to see the vessel. Uh and that uh he was not qualified to carry out his own survey. >> [snorts] >> Do you accept that? >> Well, Mr. Hand is a sea captain with decades of experience on boats. He certainly could have corroborated the aspects of the survey with the physical condition of the boat. He was not asked to do to to be a surveyor. >> And let's just have a look at your witness statement. You're saying you've already given testimony about Mr. Vavason. Uh I think the relevant section of your witness statement is at page 78. If you read that paragraph 18. >> I'm finished. >> There's no suggestion there that Mr. Hand was going to be accompanied by another person. Is that >> In that paragraph, there is not. >> Uh I would suggest to you that the original plan was for him to travel alone uh to inspect the the yacht. >> Uh your suggestion would be incorrect. >> Uh and that the absence of uh any formal survey was acceptable to you. >> Uh it was not. >> Uh now uh Mr. Hand um attempted to get a visa and discovered that he he couldn't get one in time. Do you recall that? >> Uh, that is a inaccurate description of what happened. >> Well, let's just go back to the chronology of this matter. So, page 899 So, we see here the letter of invitation and then page 900 Uh. A statement, "Tomorrow I will go to the embassy and see what happens." >> This is an audio test. Please remain silent for the best results. This test is >> Sorry, there seems to be a test going on of the fire alarm system. Hold on 1 minute. >> Sure. Shall I just wait? >> Yep. Uh. Uh, there's a It seems to be good. Go ahead. Let's see if it hopefully won't interrupt us again. I apologize. Uh. So, on the 23rd of May, the discussion about going to the embassy on 24th of May Uh. Uh, we don't know precisely when the embassy visit happened, but it looks to have been around the 24th of May. Do you accept that? >> Uh, it seems to be an I I a it's an acceptable date. Uh. >> And it's around that time it was discovered that Mr. Hand wouldn't be able to get a visa in time to visit the vessel. >> Well, it it wasn't a question of in in at in time, it's at all. And from what I do recall the visa the Chinese visa authorities required more information and a precise address from the shipyard. Which Mr. Hyderabadwala refused to give him and nobody from the shipyard refused to give him. So, that to both of us sounded very, very strange. So, it's not that he didn't get it in time. He was not able to because he wasn't provided necessary information from either the shipyard or facilitated by Mr. Hyderabadwala. From what I recall, despite numerous requests to be able to obtain an a visa to travel there with Mr. Thorbjornsson. >> Well, I stressed to you that KJM was happy for Mr. Hanse to visit the vessel. Do you accept that? >> I I don't know if they were happy or not happy, but they certainly did not help or allow him to obtain a Chinese visa. >> Well, they facilitated that visit by getting a letter of invitation from Sino Eagle. Who said that? >> Well, there there was a letter from Sino Eagle, but to my understanding and according to the communication with the Chinese Embassy, the information was incomplete and inadequate for him to attain the visa. So, it seemed to me a a a a half measure to go through the motions, but not actually complete the ability to travel and inspect the vessel. >> So, and all of this happened on the 23rd and 24th of May 2023. Is that right? >> I No, I think that's an inaccurate characterization. It happened over the span of of a month. I recall that there was email and text communications to that extent. >> Uh Well, what know is that the payment of 1.6 million happened on the 26th of May 2023. So, do you accept that by that point it was still at at best uncertain whether Mr. Hand would ever be able to visit the vessel? >> That that is correct. >> And perhaps the worst it was already known that Mr. Hand would not be able to visit the vessel. >> Well, that's precisely why we made sure that that deposit was refundable for those unknowns. >> And at that time there as we've already seen there was no written agreement. >> That is correct. >> So, you said you made sure it was refundable, but in fact that there were no assurances in place were there at that time. >> There there are no assurances in many things, but that was my oral agreement with Mr. Al Jassmi. >> That isn't stated anywhere. Uh let's have a look at the at Admiral Marine process page 910. So, we have here the Admiral Marine quotation and and this was obtained by KJM. Uh can you help us with who Mr. Paul is? Do you see there at the top? >> I I'm I'm I'm afraid I can't specifically. I know that in in the past um Paul has been a a pseudonym that Perush Hyderabadwala had gone by. It is possible that this could be addressed to Perush, but I it's it's very difficult to say from this document. >> Okay. Uh and that said that quotation was sent through to you on the 13th of June. We can see this at page 918. And this is the email we've looked at a number of times. My version of it. Uh Is there a specific >> uh paragraph you'd like me to focus on in this document? >> Yes, it's the one one two fourth bullet point down. >> That begins with hence? >> Hence, yes. Uh and if you see towards the end of that paragraph, there's reference there to the uh that the uh Mr. if enter home as the surveyor. >> I have completed reading that paragraph. >> Okay. So you accept that that it was KJM who found the surveyor? >> Yes. Um well, it seems that Mr. Al Jasmi found the surveyor. Um again, when you say KJM, he I I believe he was acting on behalf of KJI because that was the venture we had together. But I think we can agree that it's Mr. Al Jasmi who wrote this email regarding the surveyor. >> Uh yes, and and can see that he uses the word we. And we don't need to break down what he means by we, but it's someone on the Mr. Al Jassimi side of the fence who found the surveyor. Do you accept that? >> I I I don't know it, but this was the surveyor that was found, so it was the the group found the surveyor. >> And if we look toward the top of this page now, we have a reply from Mr. Hand. Uh and uh if you see there the second paragraph, he says, "I will keep on pressing on my visa, but in the meantime you should move on with the survey together with the surveyor that you are recommending." So, he there is approving Mr. Hand. You see that? >> Yes. >> Uh and then next paragraph, "I also agree that time is of importance." I think he meant mean to say uh if the boat uh as the boat needs to get to Dubai as quickly as possible. Do you accept that's what broadly what he's saying there? >> Um Uh it it It it it does seem to imply that it's it's it there's clearly quite a bit of uh spelling errors in that paragraph, but yes, that seems what it says. >> Yeah. And the the general point being made is let's get the boat to Dubai as quickly as possible. Um the reason for that is that uh you couldn't sell the vessel until after delivery. Do you accept that? >> Well, that's what I was told to me. Yes. No. >> And uh um one of the other issues was that the more there was a delay, the more there might be other Aquila vessels in the market being sold and so competition for this one. Do you accept that? >> Well, no, that doesn't make any sense since Mohammed represented that they were the exclusive dealer of Aquila. >> Well, let's have >> So So No, please let me finish, sir. >> Yeah, of course. I'm so sorry. I I thought you had. You carry on. >> Thank you. Uh that's kind of a strange statement because if any Aquilas entering the market would have come through our organization and Mr. Al Jassmi. So I I I would say that the speed and that the time is of the essence is the the the longer the boat sits in a shipyard the more potential for defects and damage. So uh that that is the reason and well, why we wanted to get the boat delivered quickly and under our what I would say jurisdiction. I Not There There were no other Aquilas in the market. Mr. Al Jassmi, KJM and KGI were the exclusive importers and dealers as I was led to believe. >> Mr. Engebretson, I suggest you that's wrong. Let's go back to uh Mr. Al Jassmi's email bottom of this page. The final bullet point. Mr. Al Jassmi there is saying time's of the essence and you'll see why when you read on that bullet point. >> Okay, well, it's fine. It's unclear, but similar odds to be completed by Aquila. >> Well, what I suggest to you is the answer you've just given is wrong, and that in fact this dialogue is all about getting delivery so that the the Aquila vessel can be marketed and sold without any competition. There's no reference anywhere to defects of developing on the yacht. >> Well, that's Mr. Al Jasmi's view. That's not my view. >> And it's also not Mr. Hans' view, is it? >> I I don't know what Mr. Hans' view is, and but I if he was here, I think he would agree with me. >> Well, he doesn't express any view about defects, does he, in that email? >> I he doesn't express any views on sales and competition, either. >> So, I suggest you that what we learned from this little exchange is that everyone is anticipating a quick completion and delivery of the vessel. >> Yes. Well, time is money, so of course you you >> Let's turn to >> want to get the boat purchased and sold as quickly as possible. >> Let's turn over to page 920. And before we leave that page, >> Yes. >> really just to flag up for myself when I reread the the transcript, I do note that Mr. Hand refers to the problems with the address of the factory. Thank you. Mr. Vanquish, we turn through page, please, to page 920. >> Yes, it's down up on the bottom of the front of us. So, if we see here at the bottom of this page, this then is the email which attaches the quotation from the surveyor. Do you accept that? >> It seems to be so, yes, correct. >> And although it's addressed to you, Robert, if we look at the top of the email, it looks like that email made its way through to you as well. If you look at the top of the page, you see you are copied in two different email addresses there. >> I am copied on this email, correct. >> And do you agree you didn't respond to the 13th email with the surveyor's proposal? >> Do I agree that I did not respond to this email? >> Correct. >> Uh I don't see a response, no. >> I'm very sorry, Mr. Bankovich. I just lost you what you said there. >> I I don't see a response from myself, no, I do not. >> Thank you. And then there's a further email on the 17th of June, where again Mr. Al Jazzmi is chasing for uh everyone's views on the surveyor. Do you see that? >> Are you referring to the bottom of the email dated 13th of June, 2023? >> I'm now looking at the 17th of June, which is at the top of the page. >> Okay. >> And this is a a further email, and again, you don't reply to that, do you? >> I do not. >> So, these exchanges happened mid-June. We now know that the contract is signed on the 18th of June. I don't to show you that document or you have to take it from me. >> I I you don't have to show it to me. I I I take it that it was that's an accurate statement. >> Uh Now it from page 921, it looks like there was an a video call between uh Mr. Hand and Mr. Al Jazzme. Uh on the 19th of June. Now just to explain 19th of June here, the uh the the date isn't on this document, but if you see at the top, there's some Arabic text there >> [clears throat] >> in the middle just underneath the words Ollie Hand. >> Um If if the screen operator could please zoom that for me, I would appreciate that. >> Just towards the top of the page, please. There we are. Do you see it? Now I'm no Arabic reader either, Mr. Rabinovich, but in the bundle trial bundle index, we're all told that this this exchange happened on the 19th of June 2023. And that just for the the transcribers reference is page eight, the Roman numerals eight in the index. So as we understand this exchange happened on the 19th of June, so the day after the contract was signed. Uh and we can see here there was a call towards the bottom of the page. Do you see that? >> Yes, I do. >> [clears throat] >> Um Do you agree that it's likely that the parties were discussing the uh the inspection of the vessel in that call? >> I I I don't know what they were discussing, but there certainly seems to have been a video call. >> Yes, and we can see in this whole exchange at the top of the page uh there's the Equuleus address is passed on. And it looks like they are trying to have a discussion about the Equuleus vessel. We obviously don't know, but we have to draw an inference. Do you think that's a fair inference to draw? >> I I don't draw any inference from this text message other than they had a call on that date. >> On the 20th of June uh Mr. Hung's appointment was confirmed. Uh let's have a look at that at page 922. If we start at the bottom of the page, please. In fact, we'll we'll start at 923 and read up the email chain. >> [clears throat] >> So, just if we go down towards the bottom of that page, please. Thank you very much. So, we see here there's actually an email chain that starts on the 8th of June. So, this is Mr. Hung uh saying and then in the penultimate paragraph in that email, "According to my schedule, I'll be available 26th to 30th of June." You see that? >> Um Yes, I do. >> Uh and after that window, my next available day will be after 3rd of July. You see that? >> I I I do. May May I please ask a question, sir? >> Uh yes, you may. Uh well, I'll I'll see whether or not we can help you, but it may be that you come back later. >> Well, I I just want to confirm that this email is between Enzo Hung and Perush Hyderabadwala. >> Uh that's correct. So, we're going to go through the email chain and you'll see that it's forwarded on to you. So, I'm just setting out the history here for you. So, that was a >> a private email between Mr. Hung and Mr. um Mr. Perush. Then further up the email, the next email if we just cross through the page 92. So, again, uh uh this is an a communication between KJM and Mr. Hung. Uh this is now the 20th of June 2023. Uh and uh if we go again to what is the bottom of this email, please. Just after KJM provides its address. Um they're now locking in the survey date of July the 4th to the 7th. You see that? Or they're suggesting a survey date of between those dates. >> Uh can can you scroll down so I can see after the best regards, please? Okay. Yeah, this letter is from Wasim. Uh yes, that's what it says. Correct. >> Yes. Then let's now go up to the top of the email on page 92. And the whole chain is then forwarded through to Mr. Hand and you on the 20th of June. You see that? >> I do. >> Uh and uh there it's been there we take action with survey to visit the Equila factory. Yes? >> Uh correct. >> So, from this date onwards, you knew that uh the survey was going to happen between the or likely happen between the 4th and the 7th of July. You accept that? >> That's what it says in the emails, correct. >> Uh Do you accept that uh you had had a you were given a proper opportunity to comment on Mr. Hand's appointment? >> Um I I I I accept that I was copied on the emails, yes. >> Uh and that uh that Mr. Hand did take up that opportunity and he approved Mr. Hand's appointment. >> That is correct. >> Uh but you did not take up that opportunity and you didn't comment on Mr. Hand's appointment. >> That is also correct. >> Uh Thank you. Um Now, the After the survey was carried out, you must have wanted to see the report. You Do you accept that? >> Yes. >> Because you had paid up 1.6 million dollars already and this would be the first time there'd be a systematic review of the report itself. You accept that? >> Uh can you please repeat the question? >> So, you had paid up 1.6 million dollars by this point. Yes? By July 2023. Yes. >> Well, not not me personally, but I'd arranged the payment to be made from our family office, correct. >> Uh And you you knew that the survey had happened in early July, correct? >> Well, I I based on this correspondence, I I knew that it was planned to happen or it was discussed to happen. >> Now, what we don't see in the emails is any any chaser by you, Mr. Hand, for the report itself. Do you accept that? >> Uh in this email chain, we do not see that, correct. >> Well, anywhere in the bundle during this period of time, summer 2023, there is no email that I can identify um from you, Mr. Hand, saying, uh "Where is the survey? Please send me the survey." >> Uh The bundle is vast and I haven't committed to memory, but if you can't find it, then you can't find it. >> Now, by contrast, you were in Dubai personally throughout on a number of occasions in July, is that right? >> Uh yes, I did indeed travel to Dubai frequently. >> And my understanding is that you had three meetings with Mr. Al Jasmi in July on the 23rd, the 27th, and the 29th of July 2023. Do you recall those? >> I I I don't recall those meetings specifically, but I had every time I go to Dubai, I I I'm met with I wouldn't say every time, but it was a custom of mine to meet with Mr. Al Jasmi and visit the factory. Yes. >> Well, let's just have a look at Mr. Al Jasmi's witness statement, page 96 of the bundle. Paragraph 45, second line. He's had a look at his diary and messaging apps and he can he can see that he met with you on those three dates and also the 1st of August. Do you accept this accurate or >> I have no reason to believe it's not accurate. I don't recall those specific dates. >> Uh and so all these meetings happened a short time after the report had been prepared. [clears throat] >> Um I don't know when the report was prepared or not, but those meetings probably did happen. >> Well, have you looked at the report as part of your preparation for this trial? >> I have. >> Uh and let's just have a look at it briefly together again, page 936. It's the first page and turn through to page 942. Uh second paragraph, this report has been prepared specifically for KJM Marine on 10th of July 2023. See that? >> I do see that, correct. >> So it looks like this report was prepared uh um on 10th of July and then two or three weeks later you are meeting with Mr. Al Jasmi. You accept that chronology? >> Um I I accept that that is what it says that when the report was prepared and I accept that it is very likely that I met with Mr. Al Jasmi in Dubai on those dates. >> And you must have discussed the yacht on those dates. Is that right? >> Uh not necessarily, no. Not this specific vessel. >> Uh and also the survey. Yes. >> When you say we must have no, that's I actually don't recall that. We we had plenty of other business to discuss. >> Well, in terms of the money you had committed to the relationship by this point, this was by far the biggest investment you had already made. Accept that? >> Oh, no. That is not correct. I had in the relationship, I I had purchased a uh, a 100-ft Sunseeker also at the urging of Mr. Al Jasmi and and that that was uh, an 11 or 12 million-dollar purchase that I had already purchased at the time and we were in the process taking a delivery on. So, that is an inaccurate statement, sir. >> So, this 1.6 million dollars was of no consequence to you. Is that Is that your evidence? >> That's not what I said. You You specifically asked me if it was the largest investment of the relationship and I simply clarified that it was not the largest investment of the relationship. The largest relationship investment of the relationship in addition to the investment of the factory was the purchase of a 100-ft Sunseeker. Also at the instance of Mr. Al Jasmi and Mr. Haiderbhai Wala. >> Mr. Hankish, what I'm just trying to explore with you is is whether or not you are correct or incorrect in uh, your evidence that that you did not discuss this yacht in any of those four meetings. I suggest that you did discuss the yacht in those meetings because you had paid over a large sum of money to KJM. >> Uh, again at that time since the This was probably third or fourth on the priority list in my recollections. The first priority in those discussions was getting the factory up and running, getting productions of vessels going, establishing quality controls and and designs of the boat we did. We were trying to manufacture the Arrow. The the the second, because this was a a much more sizable investment, would be the sale and delivery and inspection of the Sunseeker. Um so, this this would have been This would have been down the list. >> And do you recall having a further meeting in person with Mr. with Mr. Al Jaziri uh uh on the 23rd of August, 2023? >> Again, I I couldn't tell you specific dates. It was my custom to try to make it to the office in the factory every day while I was in Dubai for at least a couple hours. >> Uh and what will it let's English don't remember the dates. Do you remember having a uh a big set piece meeting with Mr. Al Jaziri in late August, 2023? >> Uh again, I don't remember these meetings specifically, but I frequently met with Mr. Al Jaziri. We were we were we were partners in a startup business, so I made it a point to spend as much time with him as I could. >> And just to clarify, is it your evidence that that um you can or you cannot recall discussing the yachts uh in these meetings in July and August, 2023? >> My my recollection was there was a lot of discussion around the Aquila to get me to commit to the purchase, but after the initial deposit was made, it it went quiet for a while. So, uh the the as I testified before, the the Aquila was, I would say, at that time third or fourth on the priority list. >> Well, let's have a look at some mi- minutes of a meeting in late August. These are at page 1095. Uh If we look towards the top of the page there, we can see present at the meeting was you, Mr. Al Qassimi, uh Ollie Hand, Perush, and Nathan Greenwood. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> Uh and uh as I understand it, these these um minutes were prepared by Mr. Hand. Um is that right? >> Um fro- From what I recall, minutes of meetings were prepared by Mr. Hand, yes. >> Uh so, we can see here that the uh item one on the minutes is reference to the Sunseeker Yacht, and that's one I think you've just referred to. Yes? >> Correct. >> Uh and then items two and two, three, and four relate to the Aquila. Uh is that right? >> Um I can't comment on number four without specifically relating to, but number two and three uh relate to a lease program that we were going to uh implement around the sale of the Aquila yacht. >> So, we have that So, you said that two and three relate to the Aquila yacht. >> Uh two and three relate to the lease program of financing the Aquila lot yacht to a potential buyer. >> Okay. I will see that for item three talking about um potential renters of the yacht. And then four talked about talked about the service and maintenance plan to ensure the yacht is well maintained during rentals. So, it looks to me like two, three, and four are all connected. Is that a fair assumption? >> Um two and three certainly are. Um number four could be connected to the Aquila as well as the Sunseeker. But, we were you could certainly include the Aquila in number four. >> Okay. So, here you're discussing a pricing strategy for the uh Aquila yacht. Is that right? >> A pricing strategy for a leasing program specifically. >> Uh and this is all premised on taking delivery of the yacht itself. Yes? >> Uh it is. Well, and more specifically on the sale of it to an end user that would require a financing package to purchase it. >> And the only reason for having this type of discussion is you must have all been satisfied that the yacht will be delivered fairly soon. Is that right? >> No, that that's a stretch. I think what you have we were planning on creating a leasing company within the KJI um environment and um yacht leasing programs and finance programs were quite novel in the region. So, we were going to use the Aquila and Sunseekers as um test basis for a a customer [clears throat] finance and leasing program. >> And with item four, it's um Muhammad who's going to be preparing a service and maintenance plan to keep the yacht well maintained. You accept that? >> Uh yeah, and and again, since we were planning on selling the Sunseeker and the Aquila as well as the other other boats, part of our business model was to introduce a a service sector as a profit center to the business. Um also hand-in-hand when you are a a retail financier of vessels, uh you you generally will attach a a mandatory service plan to those vessels to make sure the collateral is well maintained. And and that logically was going to be run out of out of our KJI venture. >> And you trusted Muhammad to put together that whole plan. >> Well, whether I trusted him or not, I certainly asked him to. >> Uh so, it it's it's fair to say that if he was able to put together that type of service and maintenance plan, um he would have also been able to arrange for the resolution of the 24 snagging items if it came to it. >> No, you're you're conflating two different items. A ongoing service plan of preventative maintenance is is a very different skillset than corrective actions and structural actions on a on a large yacht. >> Let's turn over the page, page 1096. Just at the top there. See that deliverables. What has been delivered and what is missing from your point of view? Uh there's no mention here that the survey is missing. Is that right? >> Uh on this document there is not. >> And the reason uh is that the survey had already been provided to you, Mr. Hand. That's right, isn't it? >> No, I I I believe the reason is because the survey wasn't completed. Certainly not to my knowledge. >> Mr. Page, I think in fairness the premise of that question um it is not entirely fair. Uh if you look at the bottom of page 1095, Ollie will have a meeting with Mulder and Louise uh in Monaco next week and we'll discuss the following. What has been produced for Octopusy up till now? What are the next steps? And etc. So, deliverables relates to Octopusy. >> You know, what I've got to do is important I I just put my case to Mr. Vankevich but in a different way, Mr. Vankevich, without locking it into any particular comment here. Do you accept there's nothing in this uh in these minutes of meeting recording a request by you and Mr. Hand uh for uh um for a copy of the survey? >> Uh Correct. There is nothing in the minutes of the meeting requesting a the survey to be acquired. >> And I suggest to you that the reason why it's not being called for in this document is that you and Mr. Hand had already been provided with a copy. >> I actually think your suggestion is incorrect. The reason it wasn't brought up is because it was our understanding that the survey wasn't completed and we didn't have a copy. Or else I think it's safe to assume that a discussion of that survey would have been included in the minutes of the meeting by your logic. >> Uh let's have a Before we move on from this document, item one. In fact, sorry, before I get to that, Mr. Just a follow-up question on on the comment you've just made or the the evidence you've just given. Um the reason there is no discussion about the survey is that everyone was happy with the survey. That That's the answer, isn't it? >> We were certainly happy that the survey had been engaged was in process. But I hadn't seen a copy of that of the survey until July 2024. So, it's hard to be happy or not happy with something that you've believe is in process that is unfinished and that you've never seen. >> Let's now just look at item number one. There's a mention here um to payments from Farhad. Is Farhad the uh uh the buyer of the Sunseeker? >> Um I I would characterize Mr. Farhad as the manufactured and imaginary buyer that Muhammad and Perush created to induce me to purchase the Sunseeker. >> Well, we don't have time to explore all of that uh today, Mr. Ankovich, but from your understanding, was it Farhad uh was the purchaser of the vessel? You You said that? >> I There was a person that I now believe was fictitious presented to me to buy this vessel. He never put up a deposit, never signed a contract, never returned our calls either to ourselves or the lawyers. So, I will say it again, I believe Fahad is a fictitious person that Mohammed and Perush invented to induce me to purchase the Sunseeker. >> What was the Sunseeker ever sold on? >> Uh no, no. We we we we your honor we we still own it. Um interestingly enough, we are still working with the factory on uh corrective actions for warranty work. Um but um the the market turned and um we we did get offers to to make a profit on the Sunseeker. Um this was just at the time when interest rates were spiking and the yacht market was softening. So, we made the business decision to hold on to the yacht for the market to to change. So, we still do own it. Um and it is um it will be actively marketed when we we believe the market will turn to to maximize profitability. >> Thank you. The the price paid for Sunseeker 100, was that 11.5 million dollars, Mr. Vankevich? >> Uh that is the price paid to the factory when you include uh shipping and duties and other things, the total cost was somewhere over 12 million. >> Now, let's just >> including that's not including carrying costs to this point. >> We're going to take a break shortly. You're I'm in your hands here. You can tell me to carry on for 10 minutes or not at all right now. >> So, I was planning to carry on until 25 past the >> Thank you then Mr. Rankovic. If I can just detain you for a little longer then we'll have our our mid-morning break or for you it's your early morning break. >> I'm happy to carry on all the way through. No breaks necessary here. >> We have to take a break every 90 minutes or so for the court reporter. Otherwise, they will get repetitive strain injury. >> [laughter] >> Fair Fair enough, Your Honor. Noted. Thank you. >> So, [snorts] let's just have a look then at an email chain relating to the Sunseeker. This starts at page 1103. And the usual way we'll read upwards. So, bottom of page 1103. This is an exchange between Casey Fleetman and Matt Folks who was a surveyor. And You see there, "Dear Matt, we represent Mr. Rankovic. We've received word from OWYG. That's One World Yacht Group. OWYG." >> To to correct you just for proper nomenclature, it's One Water Yacht Group. >> Excuse me, One [clears throat] Water Yacht Group. That the boat is ready and that's a reference here to the Sunseeker. Is that right? >> Yes, that is correct. >> And we understand there's a snag list with items outstanding. And they're asking for a copy of the snag list. You see that? >> That is correct. >> Then we have Mr. Folks' reply Um, the 7th of September. just starts on page 102. Uh He says, "Yes, it's now completed to a satisfactory standard. Um, there are a few points which are not yet signed off, but I've been told but I've been told have been completed." Then final paragraph, "If you need me to revisit the vessel or need anything from my side, please do not hesitate to contact me. See you." You [clears throat] see that? >> I do. >> Um, so Mr. Folk is saying it's ready for delivery, but he's happy to revisit the vessel if requested. Yes? >> Yes. >> Uh, and then we have a Mr. Sorry, uh, Casey's reply on the 7th of February. I forgot the page. Uh, they're trying to clarify who Mr. Folk is appointed by. >> [snorts] >> Uh And, uh, and being with Ollie Hand about when to go back on board. Uh, the the vessel. You see that? >> I do. >> Uh, and uh and then Mr. Folk replies to the top of that page, um, on a point of detail about the teak. You see that? >> I do. >> Um So, what we can see here already is that as at September 2023, your your group of companies or your family's group of companies had cash out on two vessels already or perhaps more than that. >> W- W- When you say cashed out, what does that mean? >> Well, not cashed out, but excuse me, they they they had paid money out for two vessels. You you'd invested 1.6 million in the Equila and, uh, just over 12 million dollars for the Sunseeker. Um, is that right? >> Um Th- That sounds about right, yes. >> Uh, now >> And and I would say more more vessels than that. I I believed we also um uh we we probably purchased uh with Mr. Al Jassmi and another three or four uh vessels ranging from 28 ft to 54 ft. >> So, we can see in this email chain that uh for this valuable vessel your lawyers are taking the initiative and they are chasing up on details of the snag list. You accept that characterization? >> I do. >> Uh and uh I suggest it to you already that we don't see any email um seeking the report or chasing up on details uh of the survey uh in the autumn of 2023 Aquila. Um you said there's a contrast there. >> Are are you asking me if a email chain specific to the purchased and surveying of the Sunseeker doesn't re- have any references to the Aquila? Is that your question? >> No. Uh I I we can all see from this document it's not talking about the Aquila. Uh Uh what I have put to you is that that this shows this exchange shows what happens when um your family group of companies uh and your lawyers are concerned about snag lists and the level of detail they go into. Uh and that we don't see that uh for the Aquila. >> Well, I'm I'm really happy you bring up that point, Your Honor, because I would categorize the activity in the purchase of the Sunseeker as the normal and customary activity to purchase a yacht of this price and size. Um and that would be a contract with the factory, a initial survey and review of the boat. Um corrective actions taken. So, on the Sunseeker, there were at least two, and I would call potentially four visits with Mr. Hand. I know on at least two of those, Mr. Barile was there on the boat with the Sunseeker. There were several sea trials with the boat. Again, this back and forth of review, physically inspect the review, make recommendations to correct for corrective actions, come back, inspect, sea trial. Um and this is in Poole, England, which is much more accessible uh to to Europeans and Americans, unlike China. I'm I'm very happy, Your Honor, this was brought up. This is the perfect example and the normal way that a vessel of this size and cost would be inspected and accepted from the manufacturer. So, this is the way to do it, Your Honor, and and this is the way it was done. >> And the reason for the contrast is because that there were no concerns about the condition of the vessel. That's right, isn't it? >> What would I think concerns is a very dramatic word. There was problems with the vessel. There were Those problems were identified, they were in person discussed and reviewed, corrective action was taken. The corrective action was again reviewed and inspected in person and either agreed that it was done correctly or not. So >> I think you're I think you're at cross purposes. I was going to clarify. Mr. Mr. Vankevich, you're talking about the Sunseeker >> Yes. >> and Mr. Page is talking about the Aquila. So Mr. Page's question is the reason he's saying the reason why the procedure that you just outlined in some detail was not followed in relation to the Aquila was because it was known that the Aquila was a new vessel and there were no issues with it. That's That's the purport of his question. If I've misphrased it, Mr. Page, correct me. >> You're You're You're honor, I apologize. I in fact did not understand Mr. Page's correctly. I'm No, I At this point, Your Honor, there was no concerns with the Aquila because we had not gotten the report yet to be able to to understand if there were issues with the vessel or not. >> Let's move on just before the break, Mr. Vankevich, to the end of September, page 1106. This is an exchange between you and Parrish. And he's asking there for the payment schedule for the 70 Aquila followed by a wink. Do you know what you mean Do you see that? >> I do. >> And [clears throat] your response is that you will send when I'm back. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And uh as I understand it, if we then scroll through the 1109, That is the uh uh the payment schedule that you then ultimately sent. >> That is correct. >> We can see that uh if we go back to 110 uh Let's go back to 1106 again and we'll go through the the chronology. And so the bottom of the page, you see when I land and then on plane and on the next page 1107 in response there to a dialogue Well, let's try and liquidate this empty container. Then you send the uh the payment check. Do you see that? >> I do. >> Uh and then uh Perish responds to that uh on the next page 1108. And you again you're discussing pricing strategy uh for the vessel, yes? >> Yes. >> And your reply is exactly 3 million. That's a residential on the lease and the bets we are making. You see that? >> I do. >> Uh the word residential there, is that an autocorrect error or what do you mean by that word? >> Yeah, it seems to be an autocorrect. I I believe the word that should be there is residual. >> So what what you and Perishad are discussing is about structuring of a long words sale of the vessel or leasing of the vessel. Yes? >> No, we we as discussed before um Perush and especially Muhammad were very interested at the concept of creating a leasing or finance company within KJI and this was me uh walking them through and explaining to them how a lease would work um it's my understanding that they were talking to members of the Emirati royal family or other buyers that were interested in purchasing the Aquila with a a staple lease program to it. So, I was walking them through uh how a leasing program would work uh to to a potential end buyer. >> Um let's just look again at the uh the payment schedule 1109. And we see there um it is clearly about the Aquila 70. It says so both in the title of the document and on the top left-hand corner of the spreadsheet. Cost of boat 5.45 million and then setting out the structure of the payments. So, down payment of 2.2 million. I'm assuming dollars, is that right? >> Uh yes. >> Uh and then residual value 3 million dollars at end uh and uh then uh an interest rate of 10% or perhaps uh up up to 16%. You see that? >> Correct. Yes. >> Um so, the premise of these discussions must mean that the delivery of the Aquila was also being discussed. And you accept that? >> Uh this was hypothetical on a sale and a a lease program. >> And if we go back to the uh first message in this chain 1106, you see there the emoji. What does that emoji mean to you? >> Can Can you please the the >> We zoom in up here. >> the the winking >> Yes, what does that mean to you? >> I A a a winking emoji, I I don't know. He perhaps Mr. Hydroponics being coy. I I can't imagine he was flirting with me. >> Well, I I I agree he was being coy because really what he was saying to you here is he was chasing you for payment, wasn't he? But he was too polite to say so. >> You You You Your Honor, I I did notice in Counsel's I opening statement he suggested this. This is clearly the payment schedule for the lease. It's It's noted down at the end of this chain. This is how a buyer That's what they were focused on. What is the monthly payment a buyer they could represent to a buyer for the Aquila. >> Yes, I mean I see I see that there are at least two documents attached to this uh WhatsApp exchange. There is uh an Excel spreadsheet for lease calculation and there's also uh a Word document of four pages, CA agreement. I don't know what that is. And do we have those documents on the record? >> The Excel spreadsheet I've taken the witness to you and I have to 1109. I I definitely >> Sorry, you you you said you've taken them to the spreadsheet there. I don't know whether that's the whole spreadsheet or not. >> Your Honor, yes, that that is I I recall preparing that. It's simply just a indicative high-level >> Okay, so 1109 1109 is a whole spreadsheet. >> Yes, I would call it >> But we don't have the word document. Not to my knowledge or no. >> Okay. [clears throat] Now, your Mr. Your response here will send to our land. I I accept that that you now are talking about the payment schedule and that's what you do then send a week later on the lease calculation. But you you don't make any mention here in your exchange about the survey, do you? >> I I I do not. >> And there's no suggestion that in your exchange with with Parish that it's now been 3 months I still haven't seen the survey. No comments like that. >> There is not, correct. >> Again, it's the same point when you're doing the work a few days later on the 5th of October if you turn over to page 1107 in response to Parish's email or message saying let's turn liquid at the 70 quid a you don't respond saying well, nothing's going to happen until we get the survey. There's no comment like that, is there? >> You you are correct, uh your honor. It is not my habit to be proving negatives. >> And when we then look at page 1108 uh your comment there the bet we are making uh again, your reference to a bet there assumes you are going to pay over the money. That's right, isn't it? >> It it Well, there's lots of assumptions here. Number one, we're specifically talking about a novel lease program. And what we're discussing here in is that the residual value of the Aquila after 3 years would be $3 million. It's a It's a It's a hypothetical based on a financial model represented in the spreadsheet. So >> And Mr. English, that then takes us to slightly after 12:30 UEE time. So, I suggest we we pause here for 10 minutes if that's acceptable to His Honor. >> Uh yes. >> Your Honor. I'm sorry, just before we rise, I I'm conscious that the transcriber needs a break. There is just a a short issue that's arisen in cross-examination, and it's to do with the document at page 921. >> 921? >> Um this has got the Arabic date at the top, and and neither my learned friend or I speak Arabic. And my learned friend very fairly said that the index described this document as being dated the 19th of June 2023. Um I was told by the Arabic speakers who sit behind me virtually um that in fact the date it on that one can see there in the Arabic is the 19th of May 2023. Um now, I know my learned friend has Arabic speakers in his team. It strikes me that perhaps over the adjournment they could look at it, and the parties can see if they can agree that that is the date. >> Yes, I tried I tried to cut and paste it into Google Translate, but unfortunately it wouldn't it wouldn't copy across. >> It [snorts] may not be very important, but it um you know, as as the suggestion was put to the witness. >> Well, I want to to as accurate as possible with the chronology, of course. Thank you very much. Okay, well, I'm sure Mr. Page will check that with his instructing legal representatives. Okay, look, it it's very nearly 25 to the hour. Um I think that's 5:00 a.m. where you're sitting. Um Mr. Ivankovich, if I'm not mistaken. So, we'll take >> Actually, Your Honor, it's 3:36 a.m. >> Oh, right. Sorry. Well, my my world clock is not is not is is is an is an hour out for you. Okay. So, you're not on Eastern Standard, you're on Central. >> Central. >> Uh okay. Um in which case, let's say we'll resume at quarter to the hour wherever you are. Um Mr. Ivankovich, one thing, by all means have a coffee and and relax for 10 minutes, but do not speak to your attorney about your evidence while you're giving while you're in the witness box. I know it's tempting, but please do not. >> I understand, and I also understand, Your Honor, that I'm still under oath. >> You are indeed still under oath. Okay, so we'll resume at quarter to the hour. Thanks. >> Thank you. >> We ready to proceed? >> Yes. >> Mr. Watson, your camera is not on. >> Sorry, Your Honor. Yes, I am here. >> Okay. Can I just check that the court reporter is online? >> Yes. >> Excuse me, can can everyone hear me, and is my is my camera on? >> Yes, you are coming through loud and clear and in glorious Technicolor. >> Lovely, thank you. >> Mr. Ivankovich, let's just have a look now at another email from the 19th of October, page 1121. Okay. You see this from it's an email from Periš to you. Do you recall that email? >> I do see this email, correct. >> In your witness statement, you say that this email um So, you effectively came out of the blue, that there was no request by you. Do you recall saying that? >> Yes. >> And you don't respond to this email saying words to the effect of I didn't ask for this, why are you sending me this information, this is all premature. Did you ever say that? >> Um if there's no response, there's no response. >> Let's just assume that the reason why he sent you this message is because you had promised to make payment. >> Um your suggestion would be incorrect. >> Let's now move on to uh Mason Technology. On the 28th of June 2024, so with the following summer, Mr. Moore asked documentation on the yachts. Do you see this page 1196? Oh, I beg your pardon. It's 105. See, it is 1976. There we Mr. Moore asked for all documentation relating to the Equi matter. Uh and that email comes uh immediately after KJL sent through the final payment form. Do you remember receiving that? On the next page, I think professional memory 1977. >> Are you asking me do I remember do I recall receiving this email? >> Well, do you recall being We haven't seen the only sending to you, but do you recall uh discussing this email exchange with your lawyers? Um this being this being being brought to your attention. >> Sitting here today, I do not recall specifically discussing these emails with Mr. Moore. >> And what I suggest to you that um by late June, you were well aware that Sona Eagle had given a final payment demand of 3rd August. Do you accept that? >> I'm sorry, so what date? >> Uh by the end of June 2024. >> If if that's the date they gave the demand to KJM, then I can see that could be and I I don't recall a specific date around a a final demand. >> And the Sona Eagle letter itself is back at page 1281. So, it's dated the 26th of June, and then we see the quality of sent onwards by I must have read that one to Mr. Moore. Um there's a play statement by Aquila that if they don't receive the balance of payments by the 3rd of August uh according to our purchase agreement, we will consider the paid deposit as a total loss. You see that? >> I do, yes. >> And by total loss they mean um the deposit will be forfeited. Yes? >> Um I I believe the uh Iran it says we will consider the paid deposit as a total loss. >> And if I was just using it, it's fair to understand from that email that Aquila was saying they will keep the deposit payment. >> So I perhaps I didn't catch it, Mr. Page. Uh the uh you're putting to the witness that he saw this document. >> Uh yes, I I I put it to the witness that that this document was shown to him by his lawyers. >> And uh by by whom? >> By his own lawyers. So this document was sent by uh Mr. Radwan to Mr. Moore. You can go back to that at 197 7 uh 7. >> Yes. Now, that's what's confusing me slightly. Um So as So let's just look at that. Uh Mr. Radwan, 27th June. Please note KJ received a notice of final payment from Aquila uh with a deadline 3rd August. As per records, Stephen paid 1.6 pursuant to letter from principal. Then what follows it it is What is What is that that follows it? >> So let's just and tell if we ask the EP operator to move up to something to see what they mean. >> So, it's page 11978. >> The 19 So, it it because how emails you read them from the bottom up. So, it's 1977 is where the email chain starts and you get a reply 1976. >> Yeah, I know I know how you read emails. Can we go to 1978, please? >> me. >> What is this? Do we know? >> I I'm afraid I'm not able to assist in full at all on that. >> Okay. And then looking at going back to 1977. So, then the response to that the response to 1977 >> It's Sorry, you want to I'm just the text there uh looks to be it's the same actually as the actual paper that I brought to you. So, >> That's precisely why I asked you about it. >> Yes. So, we have 1977 is the email. 1978 looks to be a screenshot of it from a phone, but I that that's me making an assumption here. Um 197 4 >> 1974, yes. >> We have the same text uh that is contained in 1978, but now we get all the text rather than an extract from it. So, this is an email from whoever posted it to Al Jazeera. >> Yes. >> And we can there it is an attachment that we can the way in which these emails work, you don't see as an attachment trace of an attachment in text. But the but the attachment itself is at 1975. >> But what I'm interested in now, if we go to 19 76, it is the um the attorney's email uh I request all the documentation to be reassured that he is being dealt with fairly. Warming him up to an effective release. So, it's your case that the that the letter from the uh yard was attached to the email that was sent to uh Mr. Avankovich's attorneys. >> Correct. It's 1977. >> 19 >> So, the letter was attached to this uh this email. >> Right. Okay. Okay, just so I understand what the case is. I find attached here with copies of the email and the payment notice. So, you So, what do you say the email and the payment notice? >> Uh that is 1974 and 1975. >> Okay. Right. Thank you. >> So, Mr. Avankovich, did you follow that exchange? >> Did I follow that exchange? >> Yes. Did you understand that the document said someone was discussing? >> I I I do, although your honor, I'm I'm not a expert at emails, but generally when there is an attachment to an email, there's like a little paperclip off to the right that would suggest there would be an attachment or a notation at the bottom. This email doesn't have to doesn't show that, so I'm a little dubious there was anything attached to this email from Mr. Radwan, but I I don't These emails are not addressed to me and I I don't recall seeing them, so I I can't comment on them other than what's written in in them. >> Well, I think where this is leading to without anticipating too much, it is that the documents at 1974 and 1975 were sent to your attorney, and your attorney would obviously show them to you. >> I'm To be truthful, your honor, I don't recall seeing the document from the shipyard. I I do recall having a discussion of that nature with with Michael Moore um that the that the the the the ship the shipyard might be canceling the transaction with KJM which my recollection why we requested repeatedly copies of the contract or to be in communication directly with the shipyard to understand their position. But we were not afforded that luxury. >> So, Mr. Radwan, as you say that the the tenor of these communications 1976 is looking for information from the shipyard. Uh there's no uh direct statement here that uh words to the effect that Mr. Bankwich has been asking for copies of the survey for months or even a year now and hasn't provided it. Uh you accept that that no one here is still talking about non-receipt of the survey. >> I don't see that mentioned in this email. That's correct. >> Your evidence is that the survey was first received on the 11th of July 2024. Do you accept that? Do you follow that? >> That is correct. >> Uh according to the chronology we've already been looking at, uh by the time you saw the report on the 11th of July, you already knew the transaction was at risk. Do you accept that? >> Um well, we do know that that was the information being conveyed to us. We had no direct knowledge of that. >> Well, I must say, I've already shown you the documents showing that that's uh the communications from the yard were provided to Mr. Moore. >> Well, you have shown me those documents. Yes, your honor. Um I again without having direct communication or direct knowledge with the factory, it's tough for me to comment how those documents came to be. >> Then, in terms of the report itself, let's take out the trial of page uh 1291, please. >> [clears throat] >> He's been actually deflated. It's all part of our scroll 1289. So, 1289 is the 5th of July. So, we here we have dialogue about um whether Moore and Co. can be in charge of possession, ownership, and title upon delivery. See that? >> I I'm sorry. Um Sir, your it was your kind of was a little muffled. Can you please repeat that? >> So, can you see in front of you on the screen? It's an email of 5th of July 2015 from Mr. Moore to Mr. Radwan. So, your lawyers or confessed lawyers and uh uh Mr. Radwan being uh uh KJM's lawyer. Uh and they're talking about um the the um logistics and legalities of transferring ownership and one thing Moore and Co. to be in charge of that process. Is that what they're asked for there? >> I I I do see that, yes. >> And if we go up a page to 1288, uh towards the middle of the page, Mr. Radwan replies to say actually, yes, that's fine, but Moore and Co. can be in charge of the seizure aspect of the offer for the delivery. Or they want to give a P O A. Our attorney. And then it would be registered under your name. You see that? >> I do. >> You accept that that that KJM through this Mad One is being constructive and facilitative trying to help this sale find lights, please. >> Um I I Your Honor, I do accept that that's what this email says, but later in time they is my understanding they rescinded uh that structure and would have not allow us to take possession or ownership of the boat directly. >> And let's look at the rest of this email. The next paragraph starts, "Kindly note that Mr. Al Jasmi has communicated on multiple occasions the upload of the length with the provided link." And if you turn over the page, "Pursuant to the loan agreement, please note that the shipping of the yacht to UAE is pending the fulfillment of the remaining balance with an amount of 2.39 million by Stephen. Considering the notice period, we would appreciate let this note final decision as after the notice due date, i.e. 3rd of August 2024, the factory will execute on the deposit." So, you see there in that email that Mr. Mad One is passing on um the documents and is saying that these have been provided to you on multiple occasions, please. See that's what he's saying? >> Uh That is what it is written in the email, correct? >> And uh I suggest you that that email is accurate and you had previously been provided with the report. >> Uh I Your Honor, I don't accept the premise of the email being entirely accurate. >> But do you accept that KJM had no reason to hold back the report? >> Um I I do accept, Your Honor, that they had no reason to hold back a report uh once it was finished. >> Let's have a look at page 1309. And again, the email chain pick it up. You will have to pick it up in the top of the emails from 1313 at the bottom, please. This is an email from Mr. Blackman, 22nd of July. Again, a warning is being provided that the uh the deposit will be forfeited. It's a non-fulfillment the non-fulfillment of the due contractual obligation, i.e., paying the remaining balance. Do you see that? >> Uh yes, I see that. >> I mean Casey Flitman replies and this is emails over 1312 to 1313. And it seems there that she's just tried to access the link. So, no one has downloaded documents between the 11th and 22nd of July. That's a fair assumption, correct? That inference. >> I I'm I'm I'm sorry, sir. When you face downward and don't speak in your camera, your audio is garbled. If you can when you speak, if you can look forward and speak in the mic, it'd be very helpful. >> So, >> I I was going to say that, too, actually. And indeed, the court reporter has marked a few parts of the evidence inaudible. >> I I Yes, I've now just seen that the microphone was the camera, rather than my AirPods. So, I've changed that over. Hopefully, that now should be better. >> It sounds better. You sounded like you were underwater. >> Oh, thank you. My My apology. I wasn't aware of that. And I'm working from a paper copy, hence why I'm not always looking upwards at you, Mr. Edan Rich. And it was a discourtesy intended I showed you. >> I I I don't blame you for not wanting to look at me all the time. >> [laughter] >> Uh So, um the 22nd of July email from Casey Flitman, um the It says there that on her first line, "The link you sent us is expired." Do you see that? >> Um yes, I do. >> Uh and uh it it it it looks like that nobody had downloaded the documents between or nobody had attempted to download documents between the 11th and the 22nd of July. Uh do you accept that? >> It's impossible for me to draw that inference from this email, your honor. >> Well, what we have, let's contrast page 1288. So, Mr. Moore's reply is this is not sufficient. So, it looks like he had looked at the document on the 11th of July. Do you accept that? That's presumably why he's saying it's not sufficient. He's looked at the document itself. >> Uh your honor, can we please ask the operator to scroll up cuz I'm not entirely sure what that's a reference to. >> Uh let's not scroll up, let's scroll down cuz we'll then >> Sorry, scroll scroll down, yes. >> So, we've looked at this email already, Mr. Ivankovich, and this is uh I've just read out all of the text in this email with the uh the WeTransfer link uh that re- refers to the yacht reports. And then Mr. Moore's reply is simply this is not sufficient. I'm I'm suggesting to you that the word this there is a reference to the document he has found behind that link. >> Um I I accept that could be a reasonable assumption. >> Your honor, I I then >> Your honor, I I hate to interrupt my learned friend's cross-examination. I'm not sure the premise of his question is correct because at at 1287 one can see the original 11th of July email that is sent by Mr. Radwan to um Mr. Moore. And one can see that the what I assume is the Admiral report is actually attached as an attachment. And then there is a wee link with two files, which presumably are the corrective action document and the the letter from the shipyard because Casey Flitman refers to them being sent three documents. I'm not sure my learned friend has established that the Admiral report is is on the link as opposed to just being a the bare attachment to the email. >> I With respect, I don't think anything turns on um precisely the form in which the document was attached. Uh but we have here the uh it's clear the report is being attached, whether it's 1287 or 1288. Uh we then have Casey Flitman's reply on 1312, uh 10 days later, saying that she she has the link has expired. Do you see that, Mr. Vangovich? >> I do. >> Yes. >> Uh so, whatever is behind the link has not been accessed and saved. Do you accept that? >> Well, I I accept that Ms. Flitman doesn't have access to it, Your Honor. I I don't know to the extent of documents being shared between Mr. Moore and Mr. and Ms. Flitman. But it's clear from this email, Your Honor, that Ms. Flitman is having trouble accessing those documents. >> So, we have a situation in July 2024 where everyone knows now that the deposit is about to be forfeited or deposit will be forfeited. Um and we have a 9-day gap where it seems at best you're saying no one was communicating with each other on your side of the fence. Is that that a fair inference to draw? >> Um no, I believe our communication was very clear in terms of what was expected from Mr. Al Jassmi and Mr. Rodwan. >> So, Mr. Miss Flitman then says at 1309 Uh, we only you see this email we only received three documents. These documents are not satisfactory and she lists those there and the uh they are the outstanding payment demand the factory correction tax access actions report and the pre-delivery condition survey. You see all of that? >> I do. >> Uh, and she's saying there they're not satisfactory and she's asking for a range of other documents. You see that? >> I do. Uh Now by the 30th of July which we can see on 1305 Uh, there is um discussion here of of uh payment of wiring the the balance of the monies directly to Sano Eagle. You see that? 30th of July 1305. Uh Would you be good enough to send us the wire instructions for transfers when Mr. Moore writes. >> Uh, that's correct. That is what is written. >> So, by this point you were prepared to proceed with the transactions. >> Uh, under the circumstances that Mr. Moore outlined correct. >> Despite your evidence that the Admiral report was not satisfactory by the end of July 2024, you were content to or you were prepared to proceed with that way. >> I was considering proceeding under the structure which Mr. Moore suggested that was rejected. >> Well, and the structure now is that you would become the owner of the vessel. Yes? >> Uh not me individually, but I I a a a vehicle. I I believe the structure that was contemplated would be a special purpose company to take ownership of the vessel. >> Well, we can see here at the bottom of the page what's communicated was that the buyer would be Stephen Evankovich or assigns. Do you see that? >> Correct. >> Uh and then Mr. Radwan replies towards the top of this page. Please find the proforma invoice with the wire details of both KJM and the builder. Uh and talks about how the contract works. Um saying nonetheless if it would like to have the owner on behalf of Stephen kindly direct the purchase to the factory, I the Sano Eagle. And KJM will process all documentation uh under the name of Contessa Marine or Stephen. In either option, please note that the transfer process should consider that the factory should receive the remaining balance before the due date. And uh why was he saying that before the due date? >> Um I I don't know other than there it seems to be implied that there was a a a date expressed that the deposit would be forfeited. I'm sorry, would be forfeited, Your Honor, on that date. >> So, standing back then, many of your dealings have been in person through through the past year, and you told us earlier that you went to Dubai about once per month. Is that right? >> I wouldn't categorize that way, but I frequented Dubai. >> And you said when you were in Dubai, and you tried to visit the factory every day. Is that right? >> Yes. Yes, that is correct. >> So, this is a relationship where we know that you saw Mr. Al Jaziri at least uh five times in July and August 2023. Yes? >> If I was in Dubai, I would see Mr. Al Jaziri. >> Uh and we also know, and we'll come to look at this later on today, that there were six meetings in person before the joint venture agreement was executed. Does that ring a bell to you? >> Uh Your Your Honor, which Are you Are you saying the joint venture agreement between myself and KJI? >> Uh well, between you and KJM. But you're involved in the creation of KJI. In February and March 2023, we we know that there were a number of in-person meetings between you and Mr. Al Jaziri. Do you recall that? >> Yes, there was definitely in-person meetings prior to the formation of the of the joint venture. >> And in September 2023, we know there were further in-person meetings. Do you recall those? >> I do. Yes. >> And let's to a digital fragment of one of those meetings. Uh page I think my reference might be here might be 1298. That might not be right. >> Before before you leave that page, um the last page that I looked at was 1305. Uh uh and there were attachments to the email from Mr. Radwan. Are those attachments on the record? Just for my record. >> I haven't been able to spot them uh so far, your honor, but I I may be told where they are. >> Okay. >> I I think, your honor, the attachment is at page 1320. It's because it's a very long chain. One has to go all the way down. >> Let's have a look. >> Well, that that isn't one of the documents because it refers to uh also documents from Simon Legal as well. >> But it does have it does have a Quiller bank details. >> Ah, yes. I've I've now seen it bottom right-hand corner. >> Yes. Okay. All right. That That may well be the document. Thank you very much. Sorry to interrupt. >> Uh So, the meeting's in September 2023. Uh this this turns to page 1298, please. I know what that that isn't right. So, I'm Let's have another look at Let's try 1928. Uh see if it's there. Yes, so we have the reference to didn't go over this in person and that's a reference to meetings that have happened in around September October. Uh and you see that on the line two when we were all in Dubai a few weeks ago. So that's suggesting that there had been a meeting in September. So we set that. >> Um Yes. I I I do accept. But it seems that Nathan Ollie and I were in Dubai a few weeks ago from the date of this email. >> Uh and there had also been a meeting on the 12th of October. Uh and one of those attachments had notes on the KGI AF 250. We can see that uh the notes themselves are page 1927. Um so it looks like there was another meeting on that date. Uh We know there's uh also looks to be meetings in November. If we go back to the email we were in Excuse me. No. Uh The numerization of those dates 1928 again. >> Sorry, what one 1927? >> So one >> What what vessel what vessel is that about? >> That's a different vessel, your honor. >> Yes, which one? >> But it That's an arrow which is part of the KJI >> Okay. >> KJI manufacturing process. So what this is shows we're we're having meetings in September. This is October meeting. Um in in local time you weren't at that meeting. So if we go back to 1928. >> Your your honor that meeting was in not about the arrow. The AF250 is specifically a 25-ft rigid inflatable boat that we had brought over to contemplate the manufacture and sales of from KJI. >> Uh if we look at 1928, you'll see there one of the attachments was going to be items to discuss with you on the 11th of October. You see that? >> Well, I see >> that it's it the the title of that, your honor, is items to discuss with Steve and the and the date, but it's unclear is if if that's the date of the document rather than specifically the date in which they were discussing it with me. >> But That's a fair response. I'm very careful if I may say so, Mr. Rankovich. I I suspect this isn't the first time you've given evidence. Is that right? >> Um This isn't the first time I've given evidence and I appreciate the specificity of language, your Honor. >> Uh So, what we do learn here uh 1928 is that uh that there looks to be items to discuss with you and the broad point I take from this is that uh uh those discussions would have uh been in person with you in or around October 2023 during a visit by you to Dubai. Is that correct? >> Um No, not necessarily. Um Nathan Greenwoods offices were in Traverse City, Michigan. And um the all all and I met with Mr. Greenwood specifically on the Aquaforum topic um and these vessels in Traverse City. So, I I I don't recall meeting with Mr. Greenwood and Mr. Hand in Dubai to discuss the Aquaforum boats, but I do specifically remember um meetings with them in Traverse City, Michigan. >> And uh we learn at 1944 This is an email from Mr. Greenwood to you and Mr. Hand that he's been traveling to Dubai every month. We see this in the fourth line down. This is the main reason I continue to travel there on a monthly basis. We'll be talking about a different issue here, but he's going to Dubai regularly. You see that? >> Uh yes, I do. >> And let's look at 1951. This is an email from Chuck uh uh uh uh Captain Chuck Trap. He's a man who's who's worked for you in some capacity. Is that right? >> Uh not for me directly, but he does work for one of the family office companies. >> And again, he's there sending you an internal email explaining that that he's spent a lot of time in his most recent trip he was speaking to Barash Parush and spent a lot of time discussing, documenting various different ideas and notes. Um so except that he was also traveling to Dubai uh regularly meeting with Parush and meeting with Mr. Al Jasmi. >> All right. That is correct and um as a family office we were underwriting their travel. >> Page 1962. Uh this is let's just pause here and do this email a little more slowly. So this is an email from you to Mr. Al Jasmi, 6th of March 2024. Do you see that? >> I do. >> Uh and uh the final bullet points in this email It looks like here like you are responding I think the black text in bold is is a message from Mr. Al Jasmi and you are replying to that. So he's asking for the transfer date of a quarter 17. Um let me just explain why I'm why I'm putting that to you um Mr. Ivanchovich if you go again to the top of this email you see it starts comments below. Uh and we can see in the subject line re aquaform and that that suggests that that there has been a an earlier email to which this is a reply. Um so again, let's go to the bottom of the email chain and I read it as the bold text being from Mr. Al Jazzmi, but tell me if you disagree on that. >> Uh no, that is correct. >> Uh and then your comment is in uh um the um normal font underneath it and you're saying there that uh you're waiting for liquidation on certain securities to free up this capital. That's I to be able to pay for the Equuleus MT, you're waiting for the liquidation of certain other assets. Is that right? >> Uh That's what is written, correct. >> Uh and as you know, the the delay in selling the Sunseeker created an unforeseen negative delta uh in our equity position. I will know more this week. So, um you're there explaining to Mr. Al Jazzmi that because you haven't sold the Sunseeker, you don't have the cash available to purchase the Equuleus. Is that a fair reading of that email? >> Um Your Honor, just to clarify the point, I I I believe counsel said uh misquoted and said equity position rather than liquidity position, if I heard that correctly. Um >> I But you you So So you're quite right that the transcript says equity, but my I I I intended to say maybe others heard it differently, liquidity. >> That's correct. >> Uh So, uh let's just get this clear for the transcripts. Uh you were here in this email linking the sale of the Sunseeker to the purchase of the Aquila 70. Is that correct? >> No, that's not what I'm doing at all. I'm simply making a statement that and also coyly reminding Mr. El Jaziri that they failed to meet their undertaking to sell the Sunseeker. And we have to sell more securities to have cash available to complete the purchase of the Aquila. >> You finished the email by saying see you tomorrow. So, that suggests that you were going to be in Dubai uh the next day. Is that right? >> Um it would suggest that, yes. >> Uh so, I I suggest to you that the report was handed to you in Dubai. Do you accept that? >> Uh I do not. >> Uh and that it was handed to you in July 2023 and uh at the latest by September 2023. Do you accept that? >> Your honor, I don't accept it. I find it remarkable that of the hundreds of documents that were exclusively passed to us electronically that this one magic document that there's no evidence of being transferred or sent to Mr. El Jaziri is somehow the only document in the world of documents that was given to me in person. And in the event that it was I would have asked for a copy to be electronically transmitted to me and to Mr. Hand. So, I I don't accept that and find it remarkable that this one single document is the only document of this nature or of any nature that was not transmitted to me electronically. >> So, Mr. Runfic, you've already given your evidence and you made this point in your evidence. This is not the time for little speeches. And so, if you just confine yourself to answering my question, if you can, please. I suggest you that you read the document when it was handed to you. Do you accept that? >> The document was never handed to me. >> Alternatively, I suggest that you chose not to read it when it was provided to you. Do you accept that? >> It's very difficult to read a document that isn't handed to you. >> On either basis, you treated the report when you received it as satisfactory. Do you accept that? >> I do not accept it. >> And I suggest you that you're wrong to say that you were never given a copy of the document by hand. Do you accept that? >> That, Your Honor, I do not accept that. That is just a patent bold-faced lie. The document was never handed to me in person. >> Uh Is it correct to say that you never commissioned your own survey of the vessel? >> We we weren't afforded the ability to. Mr. Jan Thorvason was blocked along with Mr. Hand from being able to go inspect the vessel. >> I'm not uh Even once agreed, you had uh seen the uh the report in July 2024, you raised no issues about the quality of the vessel at that time. There was no reference to the snagging list. You Do you accept that? >> Well, I I didn't, but that wouldn't have been my responsibility to do so. We we have a team for that of experts. >> And the reason is that no one had an issue with the snag list, did they? >> Your honor, that's clearly not true. Given the body of evidence. >> Well, at the time there was nobody ever said that the air conditioning unit and the comments about that were the only reason for not paying. That's right, isn't it? >> The report was unsatisfactory. >> Um the air conditioning unit was a matter that would just be serviced on delivery, like any other new vessel. That's right, isn't it? >> Uh no. Again, your honor, this is why a physical inspection after a survey report is so critical because we would have known, number one, if the air conditioning units were substandard, defective, miswired, if they were not functioning because of they would have been a fault in the way they were plumbed. That's why physical inspections to corroborate survey reports is critical. >> Let's move on. So, now I'm just going to look again some of the dialogue in the winter of 2023. Um Mr. Al Jazzmi's evidence, would take you through to that, please. Page 95 of the bundle. Paragraph 43, bottom of this page. You see there that he uh states in into January 2023 uh he passed on to an approach he'd had to sell onwards vessel for 4 and 1/2 million dollars. Do you recall that? He tell you that information? >> Your honor, what I do recall was numerous queries for Mr. Al Jazzmi that there were people interested in purchasing the vessel vessel subject to a leasing program which we had discussed. >> And he reports that you wanted to proceed as originally envisaged. And you see that at the top of page 96. And that evidence is correct, isn't it? What he says there. >> I I really I don't understand what that statement means, your honor. But did I want to proceed on the purchase of the Aquila under the terms of our agreement? Yes. I We tend to honor our agreements. >> And let's have a look at page 1107. We've looked at this exchange already, but the the 5th of October exchange is all picks up on the uh, on the earlier dialogue. So, by then we know that 4 and 1/2 million is too lower price to you. So, and you're playing with different concepts here. This is the lease concept. That's right, isn't it? >> No, not at all. The the discussion was with Mr. Al Jazzmi that the boat would be much more marketable and attractive to sellers and the sellers that he was talking to had expressed interest in purchasing the vessel under a contemplated lease or financing package. >> On that package we've seen it's it's have a look again at 1109. The it's a uh what in English we'd say is the back of a packet calculation but broadly speaking this shows the value to you of the vessel is about $5.5 million. Did you set that? >> Uh no no I do not. That that would have been the sales price and the benefit to the venture, not just to me exclusively. It was a pro uh I am familiar with the term, your honor, back of the pack. It was a pro forma >> I would use where the American witness was involved and that we get >> [laughter] >> Po- point point taken, your honor, but I I I am comfortable with that. Um the um this was a a pro forma example and um again, in simple commerce when when somebody pays for cash they are focused on the ultimate price they're paying. When somebody is financing uh a car or a boat or even a home they're focused on the monthly payment. So the the the logical and rational business decision is if someone is asking you to finance the purchase of a product they don't have much negotiating power in the purchase price. And and in in fact, what they are focused on is the monthly payment. That's all this is. This is an example of how a a a lease with a residual value would work. >> Let's look on that's another exchange from November. It's paid 1144. So, it's uh You here are the writer in white, and I think it's Perusha is the the writer in green. Uh or Mr. Jasmine, maybe. I I don't know which. So, uh but the some the person on the KGM side of the fence is talking about uh lots of response, and also favorably for the Aquila 70. How can we proceed with the matters of the 70 in the factory? Even the factory guys would like to have that boat completely paid up and moved out soon. And your response is, we have to send them a wire. Uh Um so, I'd say taken by you that you need to make payment. You accept that? >> Well, your honor, if if you've noticed sometimes from my demeanor and responses, I tend to be cheeky. It is a this response is a cheeky in the British colloquial response to Mr. Perusha's comment, "How do we proceed with the matters of the factory?" Well, obviously send send him a wire. The second, which underscores that point, your honor, >> Well, this is Perusha and Mr. Bankwich. >> Mr. Bankwich, shall I have it shipped to the US as well? That is my veiled sort of jab at Mr. Haiderbadiwala about the Sunseeker because the same structure of the Sunseeker, where I make a deposit, it would be delivered and sold to a buyer in Dubai was promised to me. It did not happen. We ended up pivoting and having you take delivery of that boat to the US. So, this is my not so veiled jab saying, "Well, if we have to pay for the Aquila, are we going to have to not have a buyer in Dubai as well and ship it to the US?" That's what this exchange is about. >> Mr. Vankevich, I'd like to just confine you to my questions, please, rather than little speeches. Your response there, there's nothing sarcastic on the face of that response, is there? You were not being sarcastic. >> I I've just explained my sarcasm. >> There's no There's no other instance of you being sarcastic in messages, is there? >> Pardon me? >> There's no other instance of you being sarcastic in messages that that we've we've seen. >> But, your honor, I'm I'm I'm sure if we call through the nature of all of our correspondence, we could find many instances. >> In fact, what's happening here is there there is a straightforward question about what what are you going to do with it and a straightforward answer. You're saying to him, "We're going to send him a wire. We have to send him a wire." And that's that's correct, isn't it? That's factually correct. >> That That is the logical question response, you know, how how do you proceed with the factory? >> And there is no >> In In your honor, I will notice again with my precision of language, it does not say, "We shall have to send them a wire." "We have to." >> Okay. >> complete the transaction. Not saying that I've undertaken that. >> So, Mr. Vankevich, with your precision of language, you have no comment here about the survey. From your perspective, you knew the survey had happened 5 months earlier. On your case, the survey hadn't been given to you yet. You must have known that it would have been produced by now. But, you're not asking for it, are you? >> The survey If the survey was completed it would have been given to us. It had not been. >> Well Mr. We know the survey was completed. We know it's completed on the 10th of July. >> Um >> So you said that it wasn't given to you. >> Your honor, I'm very dubious about that fact. One one portion of the survey that really stood out and I am no computer technician but when we receive the survey electronically in July 2024 we did a quick metadata check on when the document was created. And the metadata showed that the document was created in fact in July of 2024. So immediately our antenna were up as to when this was created. >> Well Mr. As you know part of your case to have the digital trail of this document forensically examined. Everyone accepts that it is a fair survey of the vessel in July 2023. >> We accept that's what it said. I and and the document was received in 2024. >> It would be bizarre and it's So are you saying in fact you you think the survey was created in July 2024? >> Um given the conduct and history of Mr. El Jasmine and his team it would it would not surprise me if that would be the case. >> So if it was created in July 2024 you're saying that the survey sets out the condition of the vessel as at July 2024. >> Um it's it's very possible. I have I have it's it's hard to understand again because we had no direct communication with the surveyor. We did not visit the boat with him. If and when in fact he did tour the boat. And how close of an inspection he did. >> Before we move on from this page, we can see at the bottom that Mr. Parush, at the time, he understood your comment, your sarcastic, as you say, sarcastic comment not to be sarcastic. But he simply replies, "We need the 70 in this region." You see that? >> I do see that. >> So, in fact, he understood you to be saying, "You'll have to send them a wire." And I disagree. Let's not have it shipped to the US. Let's have it shipped into Dubai because KJM was confident that it could sell it for a profit. >> And, your honor, those were the same comments and undertaking Parush and Muhammad made to me before I completed the purchase of the Sunseeker. >> Let's move on to another set of documents, but I'm just >> I'm sorry. You're If you're going to leave this set of documents, >> Yes, sir. >> then could we turn to page to page 1145? >> I That was where I was That's where I was going next, you honor. >> Uh okay. Uh you're going to go there and then 1146. >> Y- Yes. >> Okay, in that case, I won't ask the question I wanted to ask. >> Well, I'll P- Perhaps if I um be fair, maybe if I put the questions in, if I've missed anything, you know, I'm sure you'll you'll come in any questions you have. >> Yes. >> Um Uh so, we have here in in the exchange of the 30th of November at 1145. This is 2 weeks later. Parush here is pleading with you to make payment, isn't he? Please help. You see that? >> I do. >> Uh and uh again, there's there's nothing sarcastic in the face of on the face of any of his comments, is there? He He He Excuse me. He He He just really wants you to make payment. >> I'm sure he does, your honor. >> And then we see your reply on 1146. Uh you're commenting on other points initially and then you deal with the Aquila 70 at the bottom of 1146. And you say there it is as far as the balance Sorry, excuse me. As far as balance of the payment for the 70 Aquila, it is already set up and will go in order of the others. I will let you know when. Um >> That is correct. >> of the meaning of your words is you are promising to make payment, aren't you? >> That is incorrect. >> Um there is no >> Your honor, that's why we have contracts. It actually just goes to show and contrary to the previous line of questioning that we do have the funds, the funds are set up if the obligations of the contract are fulfilled. >> There's no suggestion here that you are waiting for any other documents. You agree with that? >> I think it does suggest that. >> So, you're saying there is some reference here to the survey. >> No, I'm I'm saying there is reference to procedure. >> But the last two sentences, there's nothing here to say that you are holding back money and you're you're waiting for any documents, simply that you are promising you will make payment. >> Uh I Your honor, I don't understand how having a wire set up and ready to go is a promise of making payment. The payment would would have been made had the contract been honored. >> And you, honor, did you have any questions on this on these two pages? >> No, it's just when you said you were leaving the the set of documents, I thought you were leaving the WhatsApps entirely. That's all. >> Ah, no, no, it was just that that particular date. I'm now moving on to the 4th of December. This 1158. And so we have some more WhatsApps here. Uh So the uh the first set of messages are about the 100 Sunseeker. Is that correct? >> Uh yes, that is correct. >> Uh and uh There's no mention So it's Here is Perusha speaking in the white boxes and you're in the green boxes. Is that right? >> Uh that seems to be correct. Yes. Yes. >> So Perusha is talking about the Sunseeker 100. Uh and then let's just carry on the chain, please. 1159. Uh And then again talking about uh a Nissan car, I assume. Uh And let's turn over the next page. And to what trains? You see nothing there about the Aquila 70. You agree that? >> Correct. >> Uh and then let's turn over to 1161. And now we get a reference to the Aquila 70 towards the bottom of this page. You see that? >> Yes. >> So do you accept that you are the person who raises Aquila 70 in this uh dialogue on the 4th of December? >> Uh yes, it seems to be the same text chain from a different perspective as the previous one. >> Well, it's a different uh date. And the reason you had raised uh the the Equilar is that you and Perusha had been speaking as well, aren't you? About the Equilar. >> Um I'm sorry. My learned friend has suggested that this I think my learned friend has suggested that this was a s- a second message, a repeated message. But it's it's it's clearly the same message just from a different perspective as the message at 1146. >> Yes, correct. >> It's just that um in the other chain, all the intervening messages were left out. >> Not there. Okay. Well, so uh we have this message. It says we can see here this message, you are raising the 70 Equilar yourself, yes? >> That is that is my text message, correct. >> Well, maybe the time difference uh is at fault. One's 11:52, one's 2:52. It's uh >> Well, they're different times, >> aren't they? So, one would be set to one time zone, and the other would be set to the other. >> Yes. >> But the So, Mr. Van Buit, what's important here is the reason why you raised the 70 Equilar uh and the reason why you raised the 70 Equilar in this conversation is because you were being pressed for payment. That's right, isn't it? >> Um I don't think you can infer that at all from this text chain. >> Uh and uh you were there giving Perusha an assurance that you had already taken steps for payment to be made. >> Um Yes, and I as as I did in the previous email, that we needed to raise the Equilar to do it, so correct. >> So, you said you could have said here, "What about the survey? I haven't seen it yet." But, you're not saying that. >> I I I accept I could have said a lot of things. >> And Perush's response is, "Okay, thank you." Do you see that? >> Yes. >> So, you accept that he he believed you. He believes you're going to make payment. >> I accept that he believes the payment was set up. >> And again, let's have another look at a a message you've seen previously, page 1201. >> [snorts] >> And this is the the email. We've looked at this bullet points as as well. And I think in case I haven't stressed this to you already, but here you explain that the reason for non-payment up to that point is due to a lack of liquidity, not the lack of the survey. Do you accept that? >> I do not accept that, Your Honor. It's It's not what this says at all. >> Let's then move on to the 21st of April, 2024. Page 1250. If we look towards the bottom of that page, we have there an email from Mr. Al Jasmi. He there is talking about the Equilas Energy matter. Talking about extraordinarily delayed and concerned about your deposit. And there there's a deadline it Article 2 for payment of 28th of April. Do you see that? >> I do see that. >> And he's saying if you don't pay by this date, the factory will take the deposit. Except that's what he's saying. >> It is what is written, correct. >> Uh and in your reply uh back on page 1250 I think actually we get the full replies at page 12 It starts at 1252. We only got a fragment on that page. 1252, please. At towards the bottom of that page Thank you, Mo. The replies help me draft a reply. And then you deal with Aquila over the page. Uh It's also critical that you reply to Casey and Ollie with information request about the Aquila for the purchase. Um and then you say at the bottom, "A loss of deposit end of that paragraph, a loss of deposit will be a loss for the JV as specified under the JV document." Do you see all that? >> Yes. >> Uh So, there's no reference uh in your email to surveys. Except that. >> I I I don't. I think it's plain as day, your honor, where it says, "It's critical that you reply to Casey and Ollie with information request about the Aquila purchase." >> And the uh the email exchange from uh Casey and Ollie on uh on that page 1968 1969. Let's look at 1968 first of all. >> Sorry, just uh uh Mr. Vankevich, you mean you said it's critical uh you replied I'm sorry, where is that wording? Oh, is that a comment? I >> Um I I was reading the sentence if I if you want to go back, I can reread the sentence on that >> Yes, I've just just so I can highlight the sentence so on the document. >> 1 2 1 2 5 3, Your Honor. >> Yes. I just missed that >> critical that you reply to Casey and Ollie with information request about the Aquila purchase. >> Ah, it's the first para- it's the first line of that paragraph. Sorry, I was looking at the end of the paragraph. Thank you so much. >> You're welcome, Your Honor. So, the requests about the document Sorry, the excuse me, the the requests from Casey and Ollie will see those now. First of all, 1968. So, there's no express reference there to the survey. You accept that? >> I Do you accept that the lawyer who's not responsible for the survey is not requesting the survey? >> So, what they are looking for here is information upstream between KJM and Sino Eagle. And there's no reference to the condition of the yacht. You accept that? >> Uh in this in this email, there is not. Correct. >> And then we have the chasing email from Ollie Hands uh 1969. And again, no reference there to the survey, either. You see that? >> That is correct. >> Uh and so in reality, the issue here was not about the yacht condition. The concern was whether or not KJM had made a secret profit by paying a smaller sum to Sino Eagle. That's right, isn't it? >> Your your honor, I just disagree with the with the categorization that Mr. Hand specifically says she needed all paperwork and information. And all paperwork and information certainly includes all all the condition reports of the boat, including the survey. >> Let me move on to June 2024. We have We've already looked at this document 1281. And you'll recall the exchange we've had about this document and and this information being passed on to you. So by this point, everyone now has been told about the 3rd of August deadline. And you recall that? >> Your honor, I disagree with the categorization that if he's if it's being insinuated that when when it is stated this information was passed to me, that this letter was passed to me, I do not recall >> Mr. I'm in count about my language, but there is no trick question in what I'm asking here. The information was passed on to you. >> And your honor, can I please inquire as to what specific information he's referring to? >> The 3rd of August 2024 deadline, Mr. Majevich. >> Uh Uh it it's possible at the time again, I don't recall that date being a magic date, but it was >> Okay. >> It could have been. >> Well, we need not go through it, but the references are 1282, where as as an email from Mr. Transfer me to Mr. Radwan um passing on the information if looked at Mr. Radwan to Mr. Moore, uh and that's 1973. Uh and we have the uh the third August date that been given to your lawyer or contest his lawyer. Um do you accept that KJM paid money to Sino Eagle to keep uh to hold open the deal for you through 2023 and 2024? >> Uh your honor, I I do accept it and it's always been puzzling to me after I learned of the nature of the payments of why the full million six wasn't transferred as a deposit to the company. Um I I I accept that money was transferred to Sino Eagle based on the evidence provided, but I I I scratch my head on on why the million six wasn't transferred. In In fact, and I it's hard for us to comment because we've never seen a copy of the contract, but there were monies transferred. It It wasn't the million six, which is puzzling to me. >> So, Mr. Vinkovich, I just want to give you a choice here. So, I think you were listening in on the call yesterday with with the judge and I took him through the bank statement. Would you like me to take you through the bank statements you can comment on them or you content that they do show trade transfers to Sino Eagle with the reference to Quiller? >> No, your your honor, I certainly would like to go through those transfers because I think they're very telling on what's going on here. >> Uh we're going to do that after the Dubai lunch break. Um uh and also an opportunity for you, Mr. Bankovich, to get some early breakfast at, uh, 5:00 a.m. Um, so, we're going to have to break now, uh, until, uh, well, until Dubai will be, uh, 3:00 p.m. Uh, London will be midday, uh, and it will be 6:00 a.m. then for, uh, you, Mr. Bankovich, uh, in Chicago. Uh, again, uh, I know you're aware, I just need to underline it each time. Please do not speak to anybody about your wit- witness evidence whilst you're in the box. Okay? >> Absolutely, Your Honor. Thank you. >> Okay, well, we'll resume in 1 hour. Thank you. >> Are we ready to proceed? >> Good afternoon, Mr. Bankovich. >> Let me, yes, that's okay. The transcript is running. >> Good. Now, please proceed. >> Good morning. >> Thank you. >> Um, good morning again. It's 7:00 later in the morning to you. Um, Mr. Bankovich, we were just about to look at, um, some bank statements. Uh, I What I don't want from you uh, now is a series of comments and arguments. Those are going to be for your barrister to give later. I'm just going to put through to you a number of questions about whether or not you accept payments were made or not. Um, so, let's have a look at page 1627 first of all, please. Uh, do you see this is an account statement, uh, in the name of KKM Marine? >> Yes. >> Uh, and if we look towards the, uh, the bottom of this page, we have a series of, uh, payments out. They're all debits. Uh, do you do you agree with that? >> Yes. >> The final row, uh, shows a payment out to Sino Eagle Yacht. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And the, uh, uh, it it it finishes with the word Aquila. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And this we see in this row that the payment is for $1 million. Do you see that? >> Um Well, I >> It's It's in the >> It seems to be in the >> tell you where it is. Uh so in fact in the narration column >> Yes, I I see it now, counselor. Thank you. >> Uh it says USD $1 million. And so we can ignore the precise numbers in there. I'm It's the US dollar figures I'm interested in. >> Understood. >> So >> Thank you. >> So do you accept here that we have a payment from KGM to Aquila of $1 million? >> Uh well, to to Signa Legal, yes. >> I'm so sorry. To Signa Legal, yes. Uh and that that that payment is referenced for the Aquila. >> Well, it's referenced Aquila. I don't accept that it's referenced to the Aquila 70 because the Aquila is the brand name for a boat. It could be any Aquila. >> So to your knowledge, was there any other purchase being made on the 30th of May for a different Aquila vessel? >> Not to my knowledge, but I To my knowledge, Mr. Al Jassmi was posting on his WhatsApp line pictures of numerous different Aquila boats for sale. That is what I know. >> Okay. So all I'm going to ask you about what it is you know and what you can tell from this. And and you'll get to the end of your knowledge and you can say I don't know at that point. So we and we have the three rows above this payment. And these all look to be telegraphic charges and associated charges from the bank. Do Do you see that? >> I do. >> So it doesn't look like anything there is going to Sign O Eagle. Do you agree that? >> Correct. >> Let's turn over then to 1629. Uh here again we have a bank statement in the account name of KJ Marine. Do you see that? >> I do. >> Uh and at the bottom of this page we have the table of payments again. The two payments on this page, again you see the reference Aquila, but the payee is not Sign O Eagle. Do you see that? >> I do. >> Uh then over the page um we have at the top there the payee is Sign O Eagle. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And the payment to them is $907. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And again the payment reference is Aquila. Do you see that? >> All right. Spelled different than the other one, but uh yes. >> Yes. In fact, if anything this one is spelled accurately, isn't it? >> Um I'm I actually am not sure, but I do know it's spelled differently than the other one. >> Uh and uh So, uh so far as you know, as at the 7th of August, is there any other Aquila vessel being purchased uh on on this date? >> Because I've never seen the contract, I honestly don't know if any Aquila vessels being purchased. >> Let's move on then to page 1631. Uh again that uh this is an account uh in the name of KJ Marine. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And then again at the bottom of the page we have the same pattern of we have uh bank charge payments uh reference Aquila. We now have a third spelling of Aquila, now double L. >> That is correct, Your Honor, a third spelling. >> Uh and over the page, we have a two further payments. Again, the top one is a bank charge, and the bottom one is a payment uh to Sun Eagle. Do you see that? >> I do. That is correct. >> And again, this payment uh are you aware of any other Aquila vessel being purchased other than the Aquila 70 that's the subject of our claim? >> Y- Y- Your Honor, I'm not aware of with the information I have, any Aquila vessel being purchased. >> Uh let's look on then to the next bank statement. Uh 1633 is where it starts. Uh and again, you see the account name is K J Marine. Uh that's listed at the top there. Is that right? Do you agree with that? >> Yes. >> And over the page, we see the payment transfers. And >> [clears throat] >> all of these happen on the 20th of November. Do you see that? If we scroll down just a little bit. >> Uh I do, yes. >> Uh and uh the the top three rows, where we can see the text, these are um various different bank charges. Yes? >> Yes. >> And we're now at Let's call it spelling number three um for uh Aquila for those. And those those charges look to be associated with uh a transfer that's row number four for $50,000 to Sun Eagle. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> And again, uh that says Aquila uh it's a reference. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And it's the same question again. Um uh are you aware of any other Aquila vessel being purchased on 20th of November uh uh other than the Aquila 70? >> My My My testimony again is I'm not aware of any Aquila being purchased cuz I've never seen a purchase contract. >> But you put it different way. You're not aware that it's in the You don't know that it's in respect of any other Aquila vessel the one that you are associated with the Aquila 70. >> I do recall during that time period Mr. Al Jassmi told me that he was working on the sale of a 44 Aquila. That's the only other Aquila sale I know about. >> Well, that isn't mentioned in your evidence, Mr. Vankevich, but let's move on to the next payment on the same date. You see the next three rows. Again, you see banking charges and the final row you'll see in the narration column it's a payment of $145,000 and $8. Do you see that? >> That is correct. >> And again, the payee there is Sino Eagle. You see? >> Yes. >> The payment reference to the Aquila. >> Yes. >> And let's just see that that again is linked to the purchase of the Aquila vessel which is subject of these proceedings. Do you agree with that? >> I do not agree with that comment implicitly. >> Um And that's because your your full answer to that question would be I don't know. Is that right? >> I I don't know. I I have no idea what these what these payments are specifically for because I've never seen a contract between KJM and Sino Eagle. >> Let's turn over to 1636. Again, we have a a KJM Marine bank statement and the payment records here on the next page. And now March 2024, we have three rows of bank charges. Uh again, this is a spelling number three for Aquila, and the fourth payment is a very large payment to Aquila for $588,000. Do you see that? >> I do. Yes. >> Uh and again, um do you have any reason to believe that it's anything other than uh the Aquila vessel which is subject of these proceedings? >> Your Honor, I have no reason to believe that these payments are associated with anything we've been doing with KJM and the Aquila 70. >> I'd like to turn over the page to 1638. Uh again, this is a KJM Marine bank statement, yes? >> Yes. >> Uh and uh for now it's if we scroll down, we see it's a week later, 20th of March, and again, the top three rows of bank charges, and the bottom So, the second row on page 1639, you see there is a and the payee is Saina Eagle. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And again, the reference is Aquila, yes? >> Yes. >> And the same question again, but um do you have any reason to believe this isn't for anything other than the operating lease the subject of these proceedings? >> I have no reason to believe this has anything to do with the Aquila 70. >> So, what what I suggest to you on on this issue, uh Mr. Angelevski, is that you promised repeatedly to Parush and Mr. Jasmi that you would make payment. Do you accept that? >> Uh I do not. >> Um that you made promises unconditionally and as well as repeatedly. to accept that. >> I do not. >> And that you never once raised a survey as a uh stumbling block for payment. Do you accept that? >> I do not. >> That if you hadn't seen the survey, you waived your right to review it. Do you accept that? >> Absolutely not. >> And that in reliance on your promises, KJM spent its own money, which we've just seen there, uh um to keep the deal alive. Accept that? >> I absolutely do not and I am certain if KJM spent more than the million six, they would have advertised it and let it known in the email. So, that statement is dubious and I do not accept it, your honor. >> So, let's now talk a little bit more about the Sunseeker yacht. Uh and just before we go into this, again, let's just be aware that uh it's only isn't going to be he's not finding out he's he's not going to make an factual find out exactly what happened with the Sunseeker yacht. Uh so, we're looking at broad themes here rather than the forensic detail of that transaction. Is that uh clear and understood by you? >> Um I only in so much as that's what you're telling me. >> Um so, for the Sunseeker purchase, in broad terms, do I understand it right that uh that was purchased or agreed to be purchased in December 2022. >> I sitting here, I don't have the exact date, but that time period sounds accurate. >> Well, let's just have a quick look at your witness statement, page uh 649. This is the joint venture claim witness statement. Uh paragraph 35, if you scroll down a little bit, please, on the page. Here we are. Which was You see, just towards the bottom of the page, it was purchased from One Water on the 23rd of December, 2022, for a purchase price of 11.5 million. You see that? >> Yes. >> So, the As I understand it, the original purchase price of the uh perhaps it's the retail price of 18.5 million. Is that right? >> Um There I recall that there was a version of a starting point of some sort of um MOU or letter of intent that was presented to me with that number, but um only one time. >> So, from from your perspective, the the the sale process to you um started at 18.5 million. Is that right? >> Um No, not to me. That uh as I recall um from I believe that event happened, your honor, at the Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show. And uh one of our employees, along with Perush, um brought me a document from One Water y- what yacht group about a uh a Sunseeker at that price. And I And I remember kind of chuckling. >> So, so Sunseeker was looking to sell it for 18.5 million, and you uh uh Did you originally agree a sale at a purchase price of 12.5 million? >> Um I I I I I don't I wasn't actively involved in the negotiation between One Water. So, it's hard for me comment on that. >> Okay, so what we do have is page 1206. Yes, I'm afraid this is a very hard message to read. I've I've actually had to copy and paste into a different document. But let's have a look at the first bullet point. Which talks about Sunseeker transactions. Starting September 2022, uh and Perus primarily sales professional earning brokerage fee based on your request with the Perus effort, the price dropped down from an ask. Let me scroll to the right of it, please. of 18.5 million to 11.5 million even after the deal being agreed for 12.5 million by one of your direct employees. Do Do you agree with that an accurate um summary of the commercial discussions? >> I I I do not. >> You don't agree? >> I don't agree. >> What is wrong with that summary there? >> Your honor, that is a a self-serving unsolicited post facto email by Mr. Al Jasmi. Uh I believe I started uh negotiating I I told him to go back to the Sunseeker and offer them $8 million. >> But so of course negotiation involves one person saying high, the other saying low, and you meet in the middle. But they wanted 18.5. You originally agreed that Well, one of your employees agreed at 12.5. Is that right? >> Uh I One of my employees doesn't have the ability to bind any of our companies in a in a contract, and I have no knowledge of any employee agreeing to 12.5 for a Sunseeker. And if he did, it would have been irrelevant. >> But the the final purchase price you accept is 11.5 million. >> That is correct. >> Okay. All right. Now, Perush brokered that deal, and he earned $180,000 commission. Uh does that ring a bell to you? >> Um your honor, that is a generous way of putting it. Um I found out that Perush and Muhammad uh received what I would call a backdoor payment from OneWater Yacht Group who complained to me about it, that they came back to them again uh to seek another uh what in colloquial terms is called a backhander. Well, that was never an agreed-upon or disclosed commission. And to my understanding from OneWater Yacht Group, they increased the purchase price by that amount to be able to pay that to Perush and Muhammad. >> So, uh we can just see the dialogue between OneWater and uh Well, between OneWater, I'm not quite sure where this income comes externally, but let's have a look at 1191 to follow through the story. So, Brian Braley, he's someone at OneWater, is that right? >> Um uh he seems to be the president. >> Right. And then Oh, yes, sorry. I was My hand My printed version is not not as clear as that. Yes, so he's the president of OneWater. He's writing to Perush, and he's saying, "In total, um Perush is going to get $180,000 commission." Do you see that? >> Um I What Yes, I I see it's the correct >> Uh and then if we scroll up to 1190, at the bottom of that page, below is the commission agreement with the buyer's broker on 100. This also is first commission payment, and then at the top of that page, this is now some months later in October 2023, uh and uh then a communication about the uh about the commission again. Do you see that? >> I do. >> So, from One World's perspective, they were being perfectly open about facts of commission, not calling it backhander. >> One One One Water and they certainly weren't open to me about it. Peroush was never the buyer's broker. I never hired the buyer buyer's broker. I never agreed or was it disclosed that Peroush and Muhammad would receive a commission about this. So, I was never copied on these emails. Nobody This was completely done opaquely to me and without our agreement. >> And this all came to light for you in March 2024 or thereabouts, did it? >> Uh that sounds about right. >> And that If we're trying to find a moment in time when your relationship with um Muhammad and uh Peroush deteriorated, it's when this information came available. Is that Is that a fair summary? >> Um No, I think the deterioration happened well after that, but this was certainly um certainly disappointing to me, and I recall a conversation in Dubai in my office at the factory with Peroush saying, "Please don't do this again. Put the money back in the company. It's my capital account. Let's move forward." >> Now, just to confuse matters a little bit further, the Sunseeker 100 do I understand that it was due to be named Contessa? >> Correct. >> So, we have Contessa the company and Contessa the yacht. >> Uh there are several Contessa companies and Contessa the yacht, correct. >> Okay. So, this particular Contessa yacht, it was going to be Jamaican flagged, is that right? >> Uh no. Um it was at the time of purchase and when it was registered, it was Cayman Island flagged. >> So, I found a Contessa yacht at page 1680. Let's just have a look at that. This is from the one of the US court judgments. And if we look towards the bottom of that page, uh there's a sentence starting six lines up, starting in addition. You see that? >> Yes. >> So, uh this is a 2023 Sunseeker yacht flagged in Jamaica under the name Contessa. So, that looks to me like it must be this vessel. It's a 2023 yacht uh Sunseeker and it's Contessa. >> Well, the answer is it is correct, but it is incorrect. The the vessel is actually a 2024 vessel. At the time of purchase for 2 years, it was flagged Cayman. When we decided to keep the vessel, we reflagged it Jamaica. >> So that is but what the judge is referring to there is this vessel, the one we're talking about now. >> Yes. >> Thank you. When were the payments out for the vessel? When did they all happen? >> I I don't understand the question, Your Honor. >> Well, the 11.5 million dollars, when was that actually paid out to Sunseeker? >> Um Are you asking me for specific dates, sir? >> Um as specific as you can provide. It's up to you how how If you answer the the question to the best of your ability, please. >> To the best of my knowledge, we we paid a total of 11.5 million dollars to to to purchase the vessel. Uh I believe there was It was comprised of of a of a deposit and a a final payment. >> So the deposit I'm receiving must have been no earlier than November Sorry, Q4 2022 because that's when this purchase all is being talked about. >> Uh Your Honor, I don't specifically recall the date of this deposit other than it was after the initial contract was signed. >> And the balance and payment must have been in Q1 or 2 of 2023 because you already had delivery of the vessel towards the autumn of 2023. Is that right? >> Um I It's possible that the payment was even made prior to that, but certainly by that time. >> What was the expected sale price, the onward sale price of the vessel? >> Well, it was undertaken to me by Mr. Aljasmi and Mr. Hyderabadwala that even prior to the completion of this vessel that they had a buyer for $15 million for this vessel. Uh that buyer never materialized and I found out later that the vessel under the at the direction of Mr. Hyderabadwala was specified for US electrical fitting and current which would have been odd if they had a >> [snorts] >> buyer in Dubai which would have been under the British 220-V and prong system. So, um led me to believe that the alleged $15 million buyer buyer that they said they had which I think we identified previously as Fahad was a ruse. >> Mr. Angliss, before you parted with or your family companies parted with the $11.5 million, you must have had some sense as to uh but the the onward sale price you wanted to achieve for the vessel. What's that? >> Um more than $11.5 million. >> As simple as that? You had no fixed view at all? >> In my world, um making money is good, losing money is bad. >> Um is it fair to say that you had uh having committed that level of cash on the vessel, you had limited liquidity? >> Me personally or my family? >> The family companies. >> But not at all. Uh If we had limited If we had limited liquidity, we would have financed the vessel, not paid cash for it. No. >> But you needed it to be sold in order for your liquidity position to be better. Do you accept that? >> I do not accept that because that was the case we would have sold it by now. But we still own it. We don't need the liquidity. >> So is your evidence that that your liquidity position was entirely unaffected by this purchase in 2023? >> Correct. >> Let's have a look at the a couple other events in 2023. On the 18th of May 2023 the Hanoi court made an interim fee award of $425,000. That's at page 898. Do you see that? And there's a Just to the end of number point one in the order is a requirement to you to pay and and I say you here it is a personal order for you to pay this amount of money in 45 days. >> Yes. >> And uh the you didn't pay that amount of money within that period of time. Is that correct? >> That's correct. >> And apologies this document here we are I was thinking I've made an error on the numbers but we we do have $400,000 on paragraph one and paragraph five is $25,000. Do you see that? >> Yes. >> So it is fair for me to say that it is $425,000 total that you had to pay in 45 days. >> Correct. >> And is is it also correct for me to say that that you did not make that payment in time? >> Correct. >> And that your evidence to the court is that you could not pay the money in time. >> Me personally? Correct. >> Yes. And that's what you say at paragraph Let's just take you to it page 654 paragraph 50 of your first written statement. Um you say your evidence is, "I failed to make these payments to Janette by the deadline prescribed by the court as then I had no direct means of doing so because of our family's sophisticated estate planning." And that evidence is accurate, is it? >> That's accurate. >> Now, the consequence of not paying is that you were held to be in contempt of court. Uh is that right? >> Correct. >> Uh and we see that at page 1 0 9 7. And we see again a reference there to the $425,000 uh and the order. Uh and uh it's a uh a finding of contempt in the operative part of the order there further uh down the page. Uh if you turn over to 1 0 9 8, please. The order continues here. Uh and uh You see in the middle of the page it says, "It is therefore ordered and judged that the contemnor," that's a reference to you, uh is committed to Cook County Jail uh there to remain until he she shall have purged him herself of contempt by paying an all cash bond of $425,000. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And uh you didn't appeal that order, did you? >> I My understanding is it was unappealable because it was an interim order. >> Uh and we then see at the next page uh page 1 0 9 9, this is a body attachment order, so which means effectively an order for your arrest. Uh and that says a power of one of any deputized law enforcement agent can seize and apprehend you. Is that right? >> Correct. >> Uh and just as we can see the the full body of that order itself uh that continues over the next two pages. I'll just pass that through the screen. So, again, we see the requirement of a payment of this amount of money as a bond in cash. And then conditions of the body attachment order are page 1101. You see that? >> I do. >> And again, that that order was not appealed by you, was it? >> Uh no, we did not. >> The order remained outstanding for 6 months. Is that correct? >> Uh until it expired, correct. >> Uh so, that means that during that whole period of time, you didn't actually make the payment of 425,000 dollars. >> That is correct. >> Um Uh and that was all happening, you see the on the page there, September the 6th, 2023. This is all happening at precisely the same time when the balance payment for the Aquila fell due. That's right, isn't it? >> Uh It seems to be, yes. >> So, in fact, Mr. uh Lankevich, the the plan was to sell the Sunseeker and then use those proceeds to pay off all your debts, wasn't it? >> Um Absolutely not. >> And we can see that if we look at page 1095, this is document we've seen before. These are the minutes of the meeting from 23rd of August, paragraph one. Um by 23rd of August, you're expecting uh payments to be received for the Sunseeker yacht. Um you've told us that never completed. Um by December 2023 >> That is a incorrect reading of that statement. The first sentence says Muhammad informed that payments from Fahad are expected on Monday for Sunseeker yacht. I never expected and those were Muhammad's words. >> Well, that's someone telling you someone's going to be buying the Sunseeker yacht on Monday, correct? >> Um That's That's what was said in the meeting by Muhammad, it seems. Yes. >> And it was recorded by Ollie Hand in his in his minutes as well, yes? >> Uh yes, correct. >> And at that time you believed him. >> Um at the time I did. Yes. >> And there was no reason for anyone to be saying anything other than the truth there. That everyone did expect Fahad to be paying the money on the Monday, yes? >> Uh at the time of the statement, I believe so, yes. >> But it's common ground that he didn't make the payment, yes? >> Correct. >> Well, and instead you were trying to look at other ways to sell the vessel in 2023, is that correct? >> Um in 2023 we moved it to the US to bring it to the Florida International Boat Show to for sale, correct? >> You say trying to sell it at the Florida International Boat Show. When was that boat show? >> Um I believe the Florida International Boat Show takes place in the fall of every year. >> So, um to translate that into more precise dates, is that September, October? >> It It It could be. There's a whole string of South Florida boat shows boat shows starting with in succession uh Fort Lauderdale, Miami, and Palm Beach. And they all sort of blend into one. So, it's kind of the season. I I couldn't tell you specific dates. >> And when does that season finish? >> Um end of November, just before Christmas. >> And then uh so so we know that the Santeca didn't sell despite being marketed through that period. Is that right? >> I It didn't sell the price we wanted it to sell. Correct. >> Uh then page 1161 This is an exchange we've looked at before, but we see at the bottom of that page um a suggestion from Perush, "Why not list the 100 on USA websites privately?" So, that's a suggestion by him, which I think we now understand comes after the Florida boat sales, where he's saying, "Why don't you try and sell the Santeca in a different way?" Is that right? >> Correct. >> And we see the uh in fact, the rest of the exchange over the page at 1162. And your response is that is that and he was mention passing on that there's a few brokers looking to sell it. Your response is, "Getting there. We have two to three people looking at it. One would have a client as well as a Mexican broker. If nothing catches, we will consider next steps." You see that? >> Yes. >> So, the answer is you were at that time you were actively marketing the vessel and you were trying to sell it. >> No, we weren't actively marketing it. I would say it was quietly for sale, just as everything's always for sale. >> Now, let's look on with by 7th of March 2024, your email of 1201. Again, we've looked at this email before. And these are the different bullet points. Um, your comments after Mr. Al Jaziri's uh, headlines. And here on the Sun we have the Sunseeker being mentioned in that final bullet point. As you know, the delay in selling the Sunseeker created an unforeseen negative delta uh, uh, our liquidity position. So, I'm describing that and having now seen the story, I think we can see here that you had hoped to have sold this vessel uh, between September and November 2023, but that it hadn't sold. Is that right? >> We hoped to sell it, correct. >> And the uh, the failure to sell it created an unforeseen negative delta for your liquidity position. Yes? >> That's what's written there, correct. >> And by that in in straightforward English, means you had a liquidity problem because it hadn't been sold. >> Uh, momentary at the time and by liquidity I meant cash. >> Yeah. Uh, and that's And really what you were saying there, linked to the Aquila 70, is that due to the failure to sell the Sunseeker, you didn't have the cash available to make the balance of payment for the Aquila vessel. That's right, isn't it? >> That is not correct. >> Uh, and that's what uh, Mr. Al Jaziri understood by your comment. Let's see his reply at page 1200, 1200. >> [clears throat] >> He deals with this at numbered point three. Can you see that? Let's resume in further. >> Can you read that again? >> If you just read that paragraph to yourself. >> I I do see point three. Yes, is there a question? >> [clears throat] >> Well, I think can can you please read the paragraph to yourself first and I'll ask you a question. >> I've read the paragraph. >> So, do you agree that in basic terms what Mr. Al Jassim is saying here is that the failure of the seller Sunseeker is your problem, not KJM's? >> Uh not at all and as a matter of fact, the substance of that paragraph is just patently untrue. >> Uh but what Mr. Al Jassim is saying is that he will try to buy more time for you with Sun Eagle, but he can't guarantee anything. That's right. >> Your honor, Mr. Al Jassim is not buying more time for me or my family, but for himself in order to fulfill the obligations of the contract. Those are just entirely self-serving comments because he did not fulfill the terms of the contract if in fact with with us assuming there was a contract for the Aquila 70 with Sun Eagle. >> And his final sentence there is he's giving you fair warning that if he can't buy more time, the factory will keep the deposit for itself. Yes? >> I did not have a contract with the Sino Eagle factory. My agreement was with KJM and Mr. Al Jassim, which they were obligated to fulfill. What What contractual obligations, which I was never a party to or ever saw, between KJM and Sino Eagle are between them. >> So, this is one of the first times we have the deposit forfeiture being mentioned. And what we don't see in response to this is an email from the user saying, "Hang on. Nothing to do with me. What about the survey? What about my contractual rights?" There's none of that at all, is there? >> I shouldn't have to. It's implied. We signed an agreement. >> So, and the reality is you understood perfectly well that if you didn't pay over a balance, you would lose the deposit. Yes? >> We wouldn't lose anything. >> And we see more about the liquidity issues as 2024 carries on. On the 10th of June, 2024, that's the date when four family companies went into Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Do you remember that? >> I do. >> And the the plan that was ultimately approved by the court is at page 1647. On the bundle. This is a a judgment which then carries on for the next 40 pages or so. Uh We see here at page 1675. >> Think of the terms page. It says paragraphs Uh starting not withstanding the following foregoing. Do you see that in bold? >> Yes. >> Maybe if we zoom in ever so slightly, please. Uh and scroll down slightly so we can see the text which follows not withstanding the foregoing. And if you read that um through to the end of the page and the sentence carries on to the first line of the next page. >> Yes. >> So uh the order made by the Florida court in September uh was that uh your ex-wife secure the a second charge over the Sunseeker vessel. This is the um Sunseeker 100, yes? >> Where Where do you see that? >> Uh sub-paragraph D. >> Okay. >> If we just scroll up a little bit. >> Here we are. >> S- Sadly, Your Honor, she is still my wife, not my ex-wife, although that is the plan. And where do you see that my soon-to-be ex-wife has a mortgage over the Sunseeker? >> So, let me just walk you through it a bit more. Uh says not withstanding the foregoing no provision of this confirmation order uh other than those provisions regarding payments of and the assets used for payments may be used to limit or restrict the rights of Janette Ivankovich or Shilowitz and Cantor and Fleck. I'm assuming all of that. I'm assuming that's her lawyers. >> Correct. >> right? >> Yes. >> Um Uh so sh- there is a pretty exemption in the effectiveness order that whatever's going on for chapter and bankruptcy, it won't prejudice her rights as against you. Correct? >> Correct. >> And also as against the Ivankovich companies. Correct? >> Correct. >> Um Uh Then we have the text carries on. The debtor's claim or may claim an interest Uh and then we have Uh A, the plan guarantors shall be second in priority to the first priority lien granted to Dr. Olga Ivankovich and Dr. Ben Anthony Ivankovich. But those were your parents, yes? >> Correct. >> Uh and then B, the Sunseeker shall be second in priority to the first priority ship uh mortgage in favor of P5CRA LLC. So there So what we learned from this is that there is money lent There's There's a There's a loan secured against the Sunseeker. Is that right? >> Um it's not a loan. It's a priority guarantee as stated. >> Okay. And how much is owing under that priority guarantee? >> I I don't know. I'm not party to those documents. >> Uh and uh the second in priority guarantee or the second in priority uh element there, is that anything to do with Janette Ivankovich? >> Um I don't believe so, no. >> So what I suggest you we we learned from this is that there's a restriction on you selling the the Sunseeker uh and or even if the Sunseeker were to be sold >> not all of the cash would make its way through to you because other debtors would have to be paid first. Other creditors would have to be paid first. Is that right? >> There would be no cash from the Sunseeker that would come to me from the sale of the Sunseeker. >> I think you're on mute, Your Honor. >> I said this is extraordinary hard to follow and I um I won't make any comment on the drafting. >> Uh I'm I'm sorry. Did you say I was on mute? >> No, me. >> Oh, oh, okay. >> But as I understand it there is a plan then there's an exception to the plan in favor of Janet Ankovich. Then there's an exception to the exception in relation to the ship mortgage. Is that right? >> Um Y- Y- Your Honor, if I can take a layman's stab at what I understand the outcome was if I'm not sure if that would be helpful. My my understanding is that my parent so the the purpose of this language is that my soon-to-be ex-wife could continue to to litigate in the Chicago divorce proceeding that um a a bankruptcy would potentially wipe out all claims. She did try to make an attempt against my parents and these companies. That is against my parents directly that has been wiped out. They have the right to reorganize all of these debtors and have a first priority lien against them. And then there is a a third company in addition to these fourth companies that were sub companies of the debtor that also also have a lien against the Sunseeker. So essentially my my my parents have a first priority lien against all of their assets including the Sunseeker in in this adjudication. That's my layman's understanding of the outcome. >> What we What we do see, Mr. Rankovic, if we look at page 1665 the the reader at this point is rewarded with a footnote written in standard English, finally. Uh footnote five you'll see there it is the judge's finding that this is all linked back to your divorce proceedings. Do you see that? >> Correct. >> And do you accept that that's the judge's finding of fact? >> Uh that's what she wrote. >> Um so, Mr. Rankovic, I suggest that from maybe 2023 you were short of cash because you had uh or family or capital family companies had paid out a lot of money on the Sunseeker vessel. Do you accept that? >> Uh I don't accept that we were short of cash. >> Um but the the balancing payment for the Equila vessel awaited the sale of the Sunseeker. Do you want to do you accept that? >> I do not accept that and that is factually incorrect, Your Honor. >> The Sunseeker never sold. I think we agreed on that point, yes? >> The Sunseeker never sold. That is correct, Your Honor. >> And that's the reason why the balance of the equity was never paid. Do you accept that? >> I do not accept that, and that is factually incorrect. >> And clause 2B of the contract had nothing to do with this in reality, did it, Mr. Evanchik? >> Um clause 2B of the contract, which has everything to do with KJM not fulfilling the contract and not completing the transaction. >> And it's only me after the event that you and your lawyers have alighted upon clause 2B and the unsatisfactory report story that has been created for the purpose of this claim, as right as it is. >> That is categorically incorrect. >> Let's have a look at the conduct of July and August 2024. We've already looked at some of this, so I hope we can move through fairly quickly. We'll pick up the story on the 11th of July. Page 1286. So it's common ground that on the 11th of July, Mr. Radaram sends over the report and the corrective actions document, and Mr. Moore responds, say it's not satisfactory or not sufficient. We'll get that I think at 1302. So that's the 22nd of July, and that's Casey Fitman's email. Then the 30th of July 2024, so another week on, 1296, that's when we have the wire instructions I've been asked for. We've looked at this, you recall that? >> I do. >> Uh and uh assistant, that email was sent on your instructions, Mr. Bankovich. Is that right? >> Uh the email from Michael Moore? >> Yes. >> I I don't recall instructing Michael Moore to send this email, but he did send >> He wouldn't have asked someone to provide the um wire instructions for payment without first checking with you that he wants to make payment. So, surely he you must have asked him to do that. >> Um I I don't recall and un- unlike the the Brits, which I know um require specific instructions, American attorneys can act independently. >> Then uh let's have a look at 1321. I'll start uh this at 1322. So, after we saw the earlier email asking for the payment instructions, Mr. Radwan replies with a pro forma invoice and wire details. Uh and uh that document we've already had a look at, and that's at 1320. We're jumping around here slightly, but you'll forgive me moving quickly because we've looked at some of this material before. So, this is the pro forma invoice that Mr. Watson helpfully flagged up as being the document we think he attached. Uh and it says there in the middle of it, balance in Quiller 70 yacht. You see that? >> Yes. >> Yes. Uh and then we have Mr. Moore's email back at 1321. So, reply to this invoice. He says, "I beg your indulgence at this very late moment in the process. I had a very productive conversation with you, Mr. Ankovic, today. The good news is that he does wish to close on the purchase of the equipment." You see that? >> Correct. >> And so, there's a statement here that he you would make payment of 2.39 million. Yes? >> Uh under the terms proposed here, correct. >> Yes, exactly. And there's no trick in what I'm going to just take you through, Mr. Ankovic. We can turn over the page and we'll see uh some requests from Mr. Moore. Uh And there's a request for uh you to send a representative to the yard to do a pre-delivery inspection. So, that's going to be Mr. Hand, is it? >> Uh Ollie and Jan. Yes. >> Uh well, it's your representative is going to be uh Mr. Hand, that's just you. Uh so, not a surveyor. Uh is that Do you accept that? >> Uh no, Mr. It was Ollie and Jan were both going to go. >> Uh so, I suggest to you that you were content to proceed with it, subject only to having a fresh look at the vessel. Uh and the 24 items on the snagging list were not an obstacle to take delivery. Do you accept that? >> I I do not accept that. That is factually incorrect. >> And there's no mention of those snagging items here at all in in these one of these conditions is there. >> There was a mention of an overall inspection. >> And there's also uh no specific objection to the report's age as well. Do you accept that? >> Uh there are numerous references to the objection of the report's age. >> In reality, Mr. Ankovic, this email was sent on your instructions to play for a bit more time, wasn't it? >> Not at all. I was willing it was it was very alarming to me that we were offering a your honor a pragmatic solution to complete the purchase, which actually financially would have been better for KJM. And and I took the vessel in my name. And Mr. Radwan agreed to it. I suspect he didn't check with his client if it was agreeable because they backed off it and never allowed us to complete that transaction or ever interact with a factory directly because I suspect they were probably getting another backhander and they didn't want us to know about it. >> Mr. Ankevich, I suggest to you that that uh in reality you're trying to string things out a little longer uh because you didn't have the cash available to pay the balance. Uh that's right, isn't it? >> No, but I was trying to get to the bottom to see what the transaction was really like, if it was a real transaction and if there was money flowing to our partners without being disclosed to us. That's why I wanted to buy the boat directly and in my name because I smelled a rat, as they say. >> Um okay, let's just have a look at some um payments issues from your side if we may. Um you said that Contessa itself paid nothing for the vessel. >> Uh I don't know what you mean by that comment. >> Well, who was the payer of the $1.6 million? >> Um I don't know where the the money was wired from, but Contessa was responsible for the payment. >> Well, let's have a look at who wired payment. It's page 894 of the bundle. See the top there, Glencoe Family Dwelling LLC. >> I do see that. Yes, correct. >> And then uh this uh bank statement goes on for a number of pages, but at 896 we see the wire transfer. You see that? >> I do. >> So, the paying party was actually Glencoe, wasn't it? >> Uh they did make the wire they did remit the wire for the deposit, yes. >> Now, in your evidence, you tell the judge that you tell the court that there's an arrangement between Contessa and Glencoe, yes? >> Correct. >> When was that arrangement made? >> I don't recall. Both companies are 100% Well, they were owned by my father who passed away several weeks ago. But, Glencoe Family LLC was 100% owned by Anthony Ivankovich, as was Contessa Marine Research. Um how he conducted his internal business and tax planning was between him and his advisors, but I was advised that that's how the transaction was to be documented and proceeded. >> Um well, I I suggest to you, Mr. Ivankovich, that there is no evidence of any arrangement between Glencoe and Contessa. And to suggest >> Your Honor, um before the witness answers that question, I feel I must object, given that my learned friend's pleaded case is that Contessa paid the 1.6 million, and there was never any request for disclosure about this issue. To put to Mr. Ivankovich that he hasn't produced any evidence um is um is not proper. >> Well, I have to say that uh given that there's a group of companies operated by the Ivankovich family uh and with some knowledge and experience of how family offices and family businesses work uh I'm not massively impressed by this point. But if you wish to pursue it, Mr. Page, that is entirely a matter for you. >> Um you're I I'm more than happy to take your hint. >> Yeah. >> Uh I I I shall um uh gladly move on. Uh I think what I will just look at, Mr. Ivankovich, uh just a few other payments that may So, we we've dealt with that payment by Glencore. Um uh as you mentioned, I think, in your evidence to the court, Glencore is a company beneficially owned by your father, is that right? >> It was. >> Your Excuse me, your late father. I'm so sorry. >> Yes, thank you. >> Um uh Uh and uh you are a director of that company, is that right? >> Um uh in in in the proper corporate parlance of a of a LLC, I would have been I I was the manager, which is directly the equivalent which is the equivalent of a director in under British corporate parlance. Yes. Just for clarity's sake. >> Of course. The A&O uh company, uh that uh is or was managed by your parents, is that correct? >> Um Your Honor, for the sake of clarity, uh we again, we do have a fairly complicated family office structure. There are two A&O family LLCs. One that's a Illinois domiciled A&O family LLC. The other that is um a Florida-based ANO family LLC. Um I I just to know that there's a distinction and so you can just specifically ask me which one you're referring to so I can answer precisely. >> I think we learned this in paragraph 50 about the it's the ANO family LLC. It's that company. That's what I mean. >> Which which which sir which which domicile of that particular company Illinois or Florida? >> Florida. >> Okay. Thank you. >> So that company is or was managed by your parents. Is that correct? >> Correct. >> And you have no beneficial interest in that company. Is that right? >> Correct. >> Uh Now in terms of the 1.6 million you you personally arranged that payment. Is that right? >> Um I would have had to sign off on it with the bank but it the arrangement would have had to in the broad sense of the term been approved by uh ultimately by my father. >> And also you would be the person directing the payment of any balance. Is that right? >> Um I think I know what you mean by that question sir. Can you please clarify that? >> Yes, I just want to understand I am that I'm understanding correctly paragraph 36 of your first witness statement page 82. So We have that in the middle. I instructed Michael to write to Muhammad Radwan informing him that I would make the transfer of the remaining purchase price. I wrote to say my legal, you see that? >> Yes. >> So, um when you use the word I there, what what do you mean? You mean you personally or a company? >> No, that that I would direct to have it made in the in the appropriate way of our family office structure. >> And that it the owner was to be you personally or one of your assignees. We've seen that email, haven't we? >> It certainly it wouldn't have been I I believe what was contemplated, your honor, by Mr. Moore was that I would initially be the direct owner of the contract until a appropriate company was set up to take possession of the Aquila vessel. And that that is the the precise order of events. I I would never have taken ultimate ownership of the vessel in my name. >> Let's just look at a few other payments. These are linked to the KJI case. Uh 1164 I mean to get the assess Uh all we have in terms of the account name there is is a handwritten note at the top. I think this is from you, Mr. Anglevich. AO Uh so this is an uh an AO company making a payment here, is that right? >> Yeah. It would It would appear so. I I I don't know, but that is the notation. >> And is that your handwriting at the top? >> It is not. >> Okay. Um but if we just turn to the next page we see AO being listed again. Uh so 1165 uh we see on that page another payment uh being made there to KJM. And at 1166, another yes a third payment being made to KJM. See that? >> Yes. >> And so it looks like the the paying companies were Glencore and um one of the ANO entities. Is that right? >> Uh can you please clarify that the paying companies for what specifically? >> Well, we have a different things going on. So so we've we've looked the Glencore payment and that's for the Aquila vessel and these other payments that as I hope I fairly stated at the start, these are linked to the joint venture agreement. So the ANO payments are linked to the joint venture agreement. >> Well, in in in the broad sense of the term, Your Honor, um there were numerous third-party vessels during the time purchased that Mr. Al Jassimi was was arranging. So in a broad sense um it could be construed they were part of the JV, but there was lots of money flowing to KJI and KJM from the Avankovich family at that time for different purposes, but all maritime related, I would categorize. >> And we see an example of that, Mr. Avankovich, at page 1140. Because here is a payment from Glencore, it looks like. And if we see there the there's a payment reference of Arrow. >> Yes. >> Do you see? So that that would suggest it is linked to a vessel rather than the JV broadly. Is that right? Not fair? >> No, that is incorrect, your honor. Uh the Arrow was actually the first vessel contemplated to be designed, built, and sold by the joint venture. And that was the initial deposit for the production um of the first five what I would call prototype Arrow vessels. >> But Mr. Engebretson, we can now move on um to the joint venture claim uh uh in a bit more detail and we'll perhaps do about 10 minutes of this and then take our mid-afternoon break or you might find you have to have a mid-morning break for you. >> Early morning break for me. >> Early morning break. Uh can I check, your honor, are you content if I carry on for another 10 minutes or so? >> Uh yes, yes, I have no problem with that. >> Uh So, in terms of the basic chronology, let's just orientate ourselves. Um do you recall the joint venture agreement was signed on 20th of March 2023? >> Um I do recall that, yes. >> And uh it was largely drafted uh by your lawyers uh at KJM's offices. Is that uh right? >> I I I recall that um both uh Mr. Ridwan and uh Michael Moore and Casey Fleetman were involved in the drafting. >> Yes, lawyers So, lawyers on both sides um drafted it, is that right? >> Yes. >> Uh and uh that required payment uh excuse me, a bullet payment of $2 million within 30 days. Um do you recall making that commitment? >> Um I don't believe it was a bullet payment, but my commitment to the joint venture was a total of $2 million Yes. >> Let's just have a look at the contractual language here. Uh So, page 881 is where the joint venture agreement starts. And then at the bottom of that page, paragraph number one, we have the reference here to initial contributions. Uh and over on to page two, subparagraph C, you'll make your initial contribution within 30 days of execution of this document, and that's going to be $2 million. You see that? >> Yes. >> So, uh on reflection, is it fair if I describe it as a bullet payment of $2 million within 30 days of signing? >> Uh in this version of the agreement, that's what it says, correct. >> Um but you agree that you didn't make payment in time. >> Uh no, I I don't agree. Your Your Honor, the contract this JV agreement was modified uh to reflect the business realities of the joint venture once we had a specific budget for specific line items to be paid, and when we deemed that KJM's facility was inadequate for our needs, and moved over to a a new facility, which it seems that uh my family entirely paid for. >> So, Mr. Mainfish, you're you've been saying a few times today you're a real stickler for details. So, let's just look at it properly together. Page 889, we have the date and the signature of the documents on the 20th of March, 2023. You see that? >> I do. >> And so 30 day within 30 days of that takes up to the 19th or 20th of April depending on when you count from. Yes? >> Correct. >> And you didn't make payment within that time, correct? >> I didn't make payment at that time, that's correct because there wasn't a suitable budget and uses for that payment provided to us until later. >> And that was in breach of contract, wasn't it? >> No, because the contract was modified to reflect the realities of the business going forward. >> When was the contract modified? >> I couldn't tell you the exact dates, but there's a supplementary document that details the uses for the $2 million source. It was you know, within this within 6 months of the signing of this document. >> Yes, it was actually it was closer than that. 21st of April, that's page 893. You see your signature there, so it is it's after but just after the deadline lapse. You then had an agreement to extend payment by 15 days. No particular proposal there that any structure should happen or anything else should be made different. Effectively, you were just given more time to pay. That's right? >> Well, your honor, it was beyond that. Um the company actually KJI wasn't set up. There wasn't a corporate entity to pay that deposit to, so the extension was actually given on behalf of the other shareholders who had failed to set up to actually set up KJI Boats Manufacturing or a corresponding bank account. >> And you accept Mr. Rankovic that this contract could have said words to the effect of um payment will be made into a KJI bank account after it's been created. But it doesn't say any of that. It simply it's going to be payment now uh within 45 days of the original deadline. See? >> Your honor, I I accept that this contract could have said many things. >> Okay, but it doesn't actually say what what you wanted it to say. You accept that? >> It It didn't need to. >> Uh and you didn't make payment in 15 days, did you? >> Uh Your honor, we had nowhere to make a payment to. >> So you accept that uh you're in breach of contract by not making payment by 10th of May 2023. >> I I don't because this contract contemplates that KJI Marine Boats Manufacturing LLC would actually exist in order to make this payment. It did not. >> Uh And that then gives rise to a further amendment to the JV agreement. And that's at page 913. Let's have a look at that together. So you can see there at the top we have mention of the original JVA, 20th of March, the first amendment, 21st of April, and then um paragraph one, it's deleting all the previous payment obligations, and now we have uh slightly more than $2 million payment being stretched out over a uh a multi-tranche uh process. Do you see that? >> Uh yes, I do. >> So that envisages now now quite a different thing. Now we are talking about um payments linked to events on the ground. Yes, you said that? >> Uh I do. >> Yeah, where did these numbers come from? >> But you're on all right, you just had a question to me. >> Yes, yes. We've got very specific numbers down to uh down to small numbers of cents. >> Uh yeah, >> Where did this Where did this calculation come from? >> Um the budget was provided to me by Mr. Al Jassmi. Um As as I mentioned previously, the the KJM facility, which they were supposed to contribute to the venture, was ultimately deemed inadequate. So, this budget was created specifically around a new facility that uh was leased and renovated with the funds I provided. So, this this budget was um originated by by Mr. Al Jassmi or his team in some form. >> [clears throat] >> And did you see anything more than these numbers? >> Uh no. I I assumed based on the agreement that you know, we would be provided backup um in the normal course of business during accounting meetings, but never never any underlying detail than these numbers. >> Thank you. >> You know, I wonder if that's a convenient moment. >> Uh yes, sure. Let's take 10 minutes break now uh and come back at 25 past the hour. >> Thank you. >> Are we ready to proceed? >> Oops. Mr. Al Jassmi, you're on mute, I am afraid. >> Some people would welcome that. Thank you. I'm ready, sir. Listen. >> Mr. Rankfish, let's move on then, please, to the uh um some other aspects of the joint venture uh uh agreement. Um so, in the in the original agreement uh it was envisaged that there would be three initial directors. You can see that on page 884. Do you see that? >> Um >> [clears throat] >> under number F, Board of Directors, yes. >> Yes. Uh and those directors would all be appointed at the outset with then uh with sub paragraph C, Mr. Qasmi, being the executive director. Do you see that? >> Correct. >> Uh and at that time, KJI didn't exist. That's common ground, isn't it? >> Uh I Your Honor, I don't believe it existed on the ground or in the air. But, yes, it didn't exist. >> Uh and it was already in the water. Uh it was brought into existence uh on the 19th of July 2023. Uh and we see that through the memorandum of association at 1038. Uh and you've seen this document before, haven't you? >> I have. >> Uh and it's your signature at the back of this document. Let's just turn through to page 1056. And you're the second party there. That's you, isn't it? >> That is correct. >> And you don't challenge the lawfulness of this document. You accept that it was validly executed. >> Um I I accept that I signed it, Your Honor. The circumstances of me signing it I'm a little disappointed about, but it is my signature on what I believe to be a legally valid document. >> And so we see here in this document that the uh the structure of what was ultimately created was a bit different to the joint venture agreement. So, page 103A, you can see that we can see we now have three parties, KJM, NU, and Mr. Al Jazzmi. You see that? >> Yes. >> And that's a change from the original JVA. You don't need to do a comparison, but tell me if you don't accept any of this. Um where originally it was KJM and NU only. So, right? >> Um Correct, Your Honor, but it was my understanding cuz it was told to me that uh Mr. Al Jazzmi and Mr. Karafi were 50/50 um uh equal shareholders in KJM. So, the material difference um in in my mind would have been the same. >> Yes. Uh and we can see here uh in the middle of box one, it's Mr. Karafi who is being represented. And so, who is the representative of KJM Marine? You can see that? >> Yes. >> So, in effect, there's been a subdivision of KJM between Mr. Al Karafi and Mr. Al Jazzmi, but your interests are unaffected. >> Uh that is correct. >> Did you read this document document before you signed it? >> Um I remember glancing at it because it was given to me at I Your Honor, I don't know what the formal uh term for the agency is, but I would categorize it as the corporate register. Um and I by Mr. Radwan and I just remember that this was a necessary document to be signed to incorporate the company, so I quickly skimmed it. We were standing up outside the offices. >> So, and rather than the three initial directors, we have one director being appointed here. Let me see that at 1043. See that? That's Mr. Jazmi is the director at this stage, yes? >> Yes. >> So, dealing then with the three tranche of the payments set out in JDA Amendment 2, uh let's have a look at that again, 913. Tranche one was 611,000 to be paid by 19th June 2023. Uh you missed that deadline, didn't you? >> Um I the answer is I don't think so. I think I initiated the wire prior to that deadline. I can't comment on when it was received. >> Well, uh we can see it was received uh Well, it's not we can see it was paid some days later, 1164. So, the are your uh or rather A&O's bank statements and that shows the date of payment 22nd of June. You see that? >> Uh Yep, that is correct. >> So in fact the the payment was late at your end. No one else is to blame. That's right, isn't it? >> Well, your honor, there's always someone to blame, but in this case I'll accept responsibility that this was made on 6/22. >> The industrial license itself is issued uh >> So this was 3 days late. >> So 3 days late and payment here was being made to KJM, correct? >> Uh that is correct. >> So previously you've been saying that you wouldn't make payment because KJI's bank account hadn't been established, but that's no longer a problem by June because you're making payment to KJM. >> Well, yes, we just decided to get on with it. I was assured it wouldn't be an issue. >> And uh this payment is being made still before KJI was even being created, yes? >> Correct. >> Right. The industrial license for KJI >> you have a bank account before the company is created? I mean any bank will want to see the constitution documents to understand what is the identity of its client. >> Yes, that's correct, but I understand that it it wasn't created and we didn't have the bank account, which is why we wired to KJM. >> So it was wired to KJM, not to KJI. I'm sorry if I misunderstood. >> Uh the industrial So and KJI So we can see this was wired 22nd of June 20 2023. Um then KJI was created uh on the 19th of July 2023, so about a month later, and it then achieved received its industrial license on the 31st of July 2023. We can have a look at that at 1062. >> So, do we have evidence of KJM transmitting the money for KJI? >> Uh you are In fact, as I understand it, KJI never opened a bank account. >> Okay. >> All right. You're right. All right. I don't believe that's correct because I do recall making a wire transfer to KJI, but I could I could be wrong in that, but it was it was much later in the process. >> Okay. Well, we'll investigate that. >> Um so, Mr. Which, we can see here the industrial license uh and that is uh the expiry date on the left-hand side, 30th of July 2026. Uh and there is a an issue date, which I haven't highlighted, I'm afraid, but that is 31st of July 2000 I think um maybe it's the page before. Anyway, but you accept the industrial license was issued. And there we are. It's on the right-hand side of that page, 31st July 2023. Um it was issued on on that date. >> I do accept that, yes. >> Um >> [clears throat] >> Uh So, tranche two payment >> And do we know how much that cost? >> The industrial license? >> Yes. >> Uh it's not stated on this document, Juana. We can have a look back at 913, where we're going to have a look anyway. >> Yes, I'm not interested in what the budget was. I'm interested in actual evidence of cost. So, we don't know what it actually cost. >> I'm afraid I I I can't help you with that at the moment, Juana. No. >> Okay, well, that's something we need to investigate. >> Uh so, if we go back to the amendment number two, Mr. Rangelovic. So, we have there the requirement for first tranche we paid uh 19th of June and uh the budget here for various different elements. Then, the second tranche over the page of 914. That was going to be just over 1.1 million dollars to be paid within five business days upon all approvals for the build out. So, my understanding of the phrase five business days for all approvals apart for the build out it links to the industrial license. Is that right or or is that referring to something different? >> No, I that refers to specific build out approvals of construction budgets for the new facilities, approval of designs, um it It a comprehensive approvals of the next phase of the facility. So So, I I would believe uh the industrial license in so much as that it was required to do that construction would have been part of it but not not a significant part. >> So, when was that threshold reached? >> Um it would have been a notice provided to me by Mr. Eljasmy and I would have relied on him to just essentially tell me we're ready we're ready for the second tranche. So, whenever he notified me and I do recall asking for backup um but he told me that would be addressed you know, at the end in in our in our meetings. >> And did you see the actual work being carried out? >> Uh yes, I I I did come Your Honor um to the facility with people doing work. I um as someone who does construction both in America and the UK it was astounding to me that there were people using jackhammers in sandals and flip-flops but they were definitely working. Um I I did see it carried out. And of course, I did see the finished product. >> So, what we can see of capital calls is at page 1137. So, first capital calls uh and this is an email from Mr. Radwan to you. Uh It's on date blank. KJI received an amount of $1 million towards second capital call. The shortfall of $151,000. So, that suggests that that there had been an earlier call for payment and some shortfall in that payment. You said that's what he's saying there. >> Um Well, that's what he's writing. The reality of the situation on the ground, your honor, is Mohammed called me up and said wire a million dollars for the next payment because that was the work that he could created and that's what was wired. >> So, the the wire instructions at page 1165 So, this is on the 27th of October. And you say it's it's for around around sum of $1 million. Uh Uh and then uh >> [clears throat] >> As Mr. Radwan points out then a month later, that was a shortfall on the second capital call. And then the third capital call uh is then formally requested back at page 1137. Uh and you'll see there third capital call is due underlined. Uh and there's a request also to transfer the the shortfall for the second capital call as well. Do you see that? >> I do. >> Uh and then towards the bottom of that page um Mr. Radwan says in order to preserve the capital invested and mitigate the risk of losing it I'll start in KJI without the core asset, either mold. Uh KJI has decided to use its mold to serve the manufacturing process of KJI. So, we have zero tolerance in the wasting your funds or contribution or contribution or ours. Um and then so that's a reference to 20 by 20. That's the arrow, is it? >> Yes. >> Yes. So, we have here a statement by uh KJM's lawyer uh on behalf of the joint venture that it's trying to do whatever it can to mitigate the risk of money being lost and it's getting on with a manufacturing process. Yes? >> Yes, that's what's written. >> Uh and you accept that's accurate? That they were manufacturing? >> No, we we weren't manufacturing at that point at that point. And um his categorization of the mold is also in incorrect. >> So, if we look [clears throat] back at page 914, you see the third tranche uh to be within 45 days of the mold arrivals. You see that at the bottom of the page. >> Yes. >> Oh. We've already seen this email that the molds have effectively have arrived and are being used. Um payment is then only made on the uh at the end of December, isn't it? >> Yeah, that's not a correct portrayal of Mr. Radwan's email or the events on the ground. >> Well, is it accurate to say that in that email he's calling for the third payment tranche? >> That that is accurate and the third payment tranche was made. >> Uh and then you made that more than a month later on the 29th of December. >> If if that's what's in evidence and I have no reason to believe it's it's an incorrect statement. >> We have that at uh at page 1166. And these are your bank statements I understand, Mr. Vesper. >> Um not mine but whatever family office company associate with the wire transfer, yes. >> Yes, well if we just scroll up a little bit again, we'll see it's AO. You see that? >> I do. >> Yeah. So, in fact, that this is the last payment that you make. So, at no time have there been any payments at all from you personally. You accept that? >> I do. >> Uh and each of these payments we can see are made late. You accept that? >> Um I do not. >> Um the reason why all these payments coming in late is because in reality it's there are other issues going on with the Sunseeker and your divorce proceedings. Yes? >> Um that is certainly incorrect. I think the biggest issue was I kept wondering why I was making these payments on behalf of the family companies to KJM and not KJI. And also I requested at least cursory backup for these payments. Um but never got a satis- I never got a satisfactory answer as to why a KJI bank account had not been set up or why I couldn't get accounting backup, but I I periodically authorized these wires anyway. >> Well, Mr. Rakoczy, I suggest that you promised to make payment of $2 million that you didn't actually have to hand. >> I'm sorry, can you repeat that comment, please? >> You promised to make payment of $2 million which you didn't actually have available. >> Um how do you figure since those payments were made in full? >> Well, because we've been through your your late payments throughout throughout the period. >> I I I fail to understand how making payments late because there wasn't a proper bank account in place equates to the money not being available to be paid since it was paid, but I I'm just not following your line of questioning. >> The Well, all >> The payments The payments were made and reluctantly because there wasn't a KJA a bank account or sufficient backup to justify the previous payments, but in the spirit of being a good partner and and getting on with the business, we made those payments. >> Well, Mr. Rakoczy, I suggest that that the effect of you making late payment is that KGI was starved of money whilst you were scrambling around trying to find liquidity. >> Your Your suggestion is both inaccurate and comical. >> Let's look at the companies themselves. Um Your pleaded case is that the Chapter 11 proceedings didn't involve you personally because you have no legal or beneficial tie to the Chapter 11 companies. Have I summarized that fairly? >> That's correct. >> Um So, one of those companies was the Ivankovich family LLC. We see it 1843. You are described as its manager. And if we can look at Article 7, please. It is It's not there on that page. Um it's Here we are. It's back on 1842. Excuse me. We can see the definition of the term manager at the top of 1842. >> I do. >> Yeah. And And that's you, isn't it? >> Yes. Yes. >> And you were the person who executed the certificate of formation. Is that right? >> Uh That is correct. Yes. >> And we see that on page 1841. Uh for the Chapter 11 debtors, you filed the confirmation affidavit. That's right, isn't it? >> Um for this company? >> Well, for all four debtors. Let's have a look. Perhaps you don't recall. If we If we look at 1648, please. We see there I'm afraid it's quite hard to follow this text, but uh Hopefully spot your name. It's It's somewhat bigger than you see three lines up from the bottom. A confirmation affidavit. You see that? >> Yes. >> Yes. Um did that cover all of the companies? >> Um I I I don't know. I'm not really a bankruptcy expert. >> Uh we've seen already when we looked through at the um uh payments made uh on your behalf into the JDA that the payer was the A&O one of the A&O offices. Uh yes, one of the A&O companies. >> That is correct. >> And there were two A&O companies in total, the A&O family in Florida and A&O family in Illinois. Is that right? >> That's correct. >> Both those companies went into Chapter 11 uh bankruptcy. Is that right? >> That is correct. >> And we see that at page 1647. Um You also say in your evidence that it's your family office that funded your divorce proceedings. Do you remember saying that? >> Um I don't specifically, but that would be an accurate statement. >> So, that's uh page 654 of the bundle, paragraph 50. >> Okay. >> You see that? Final sentence. Your family office had been funding my divorce proceedings. You see? >> Yes. >> Yes. Uh and that same paragraph says that you had no direct means of making court order payments yourself. Yes? >> Correct. >> Uh now Um This may be stretching my I uh my um interpretation of the family of chapter 11 proceedings, but uh we've already seen in the uh in that footnote I showed you earlier from the chapter 11 proceedings that there's a link between all of this uh and your divorce proceedings. You accept that? >> I do. >> Um The reality is that the in practical terms, the assets you call on to meet substantial personal personal liabilities uh your family assets. Correct? >> Correct. >> Uh and those companies hold and deploy your wealth. Correct? >> Um I would argue your honor that I don't have any personal wealth, but it's all part of our family office that I manage. >> I >> Or assistant manager. >> I suggest to you that any attempt in practical terms to separate yourself from those companies is artificial. Do you accept that? >> Uh I don't accept that. No. >> Uh and that their chapter 11 bankruptcy amounted to a material change in your assets and business. Do you accept that? >> I I do not accept that, Your Honor, and that's not accurate. >> Um Alternatively, that their Chapter 11 bankruptcy related to a substantial proportion of your assets. Do you accept that? >> I I do not, and that is an inaccurate statement. >> Um we've already looked at the uh personal orders made against you. Um Uh I suggest to you that those personal orders show that you were failing to satisfy judgment debts in time. Do you accept that? >> I do. >> Uh and that those orders and the >> I'm sorry for interrupting my learned friend's cross-examination, but um certainly for me, the real-time transcript has stopped. I don't know whether it has for you, Your Honor. Or indeed for Mr. Page. I just wanted to check. I wanted to know whether it was my problem or whether there was an issue with the transcriber, because I'm sure Mr. Page will want this evidence to be transcribed. >> I got to page 162, line 11. >> And that is where I've got to, which um was my learned friend's suggestion. >> Uh this is the court reporter. I'm still here. Um I'm aware that tech is doing something with the real time, but I'm still here, and it's still being recorded and transcribed. It will be here in the final transcript. >> Okay, thank you. >> Very good. >> Thank you. >> We've only got a few minutes left anyway. Let's let's persevere. >> Thank you. Um So the the divorce orders, Mr. Vankevich, uh I suggest to you that that they uh amounted to a material change in your business and assets. Do you accept that? >> I do not. Nor nor do I find that accurate. >> Um in terms of a factory lease and license, um let's have a look at an email from Mr. Radwan at page 1349. I'll just turn up my version. Uh You see there that uh um Mr. Radwan is saying in first paragraph that an external auditor has issued a draft of the annual financials. You see that in the first paragraph? >> Uh that's the bullet point starting with the accumulated losses arising from the JV partner. >> Uh no, it's actually before any of that. It's after um salaam alaikum. >> Uh beginning with following up on the trail below. >> Yes. >> Yes. >> And then so we have some discussion of that point there. And the next paragraph talks about uh whether or not KJI might no longer be a going concern company. And then we have two bullet points which follow. Do you see that? >> I do. >> And the uh second uh bullet point concerns the factory annual lease. Do you see that at sub paragraph A? >> I do. >> And the renewal fees of the industrial license. Uh that's little B. And just Do you see that? >> I do. >> Holding that this may help his honor answer the question he posed earlier about the the length of these fees. So do you accept that there was a need to pay an annual lease for the KJI factory? >> Um Yes, there there was there was a lease payment, correct. >> And also a license payment. >> Uh That is correct, too. >> And plainly somebody needs to pay that by the 16th Oh, sorry. Um plainly somebody needs to pay that by the 16th of August 2024 in order to maintain the industrial license and the lease. Do you accept that? >> I do. >> You didn't pay that, did you? >> Not because I didn't offer. >> Sorry, is that a double negative? Are you saying you did offer? >> You know, I apologize. Yes, your honor. I'm sorry for my poor English. Um we we we did offer and um all we were asking for is um a proper financial statement to understand where the money had previously been invested to, but we did offer to make through my attorneys um my 50% portion of that payment as well as the lease payment. >> What we can see in the letter from Trauer is 1355 have the sub paragraphs A and B there. So there is a statement that you stand ready to make the payment. Then there's a rejection that you'll do so by the 16th of August. You see that? >> Yes. >> So, in fact, there was no clear promise to make payment of this amount of money by the 16th of August, and you didn't in fact do so, did you? >> Um I did not make it, and the payment was based on certain contractual obligations of the company which had been overdue, which we believe are reasonable. >> The essence of the joint venture agreement was for manufacture of vessels in large part. Do you agree with that? >> Yes. >> And that required a factory lease and an industrial license. Do you accept that? >> I do. >> And do you accept therefore that KJI could not lawfully and practically operate without either a factory or an industrial license? >> Well, Your Honor, that would be a a question for debate, but it definitely needed a facility to manufacture if we were to manufacture our own boats. >> Do you accept it as commercially unreasonable for you to refuse to hand over this money, but still insist that the joint venture remain alive? >> Your Honor, I believe it's commercially unreasonable to ask someone to keep sending money into a bottomless pit without any transparency or knowledge how that money was being spent. >> And And as far as you're aware, the factory now has closed. Is that right? >> Uh no. They They I asked somebody to um check last week, and they drove by the factory, and according to that report, uh, the factory was still operating. >> So, somebody drove past last week, it's still operating. It's not being funded by you, though, is it? >> Uh, your honor, it is not being funded by me, nor is it obligated to be funded by me. >> So, the last time you put in any money was that payment we've seen, uh, back in December 2023, I believe. Is that right? >> Uh, which payment are you referring to specifically? >> It was one of the A&O payments. >> Which one, sir? >> 81166. That one there. That's the last time you paid me money into the JV, isn't it? >> Oh, no, that is that is incorrect. Um, I paid, in addition to my the to the slightly over $2 million investment we made, we made substantial additional payments, um, in excess of our commitment for the manufacture of, namely, the airboat research and development, um, payments for experts to come and assist. Um, we directed a company called Aquaform to come and have parts and boats produced there, which we also paid for. Um, my my estimate is we probably funded into KJI, uh, close to a million dollars of additional payments on top of the $2 million initial capital contribution. >> Okay, none of that has been broken down for Judge Hazard. >> Do we the financial statements? >> I'm just about to now show Mr. Wangwe if I may you want to what we do have. >> Well, we we This is going to take some time, isn't it? >> I uh Well, I I would hope not because I'm conscious that I need to finish in very short order. Uh so I'm planning only on really putting the essence of my case and then a lot of this is going to be for submissions. >> Well, it's up to you what you put in and and and don't put obviously. Um but we can't go on It's now 5:00 p.m. uh Dubai time and uh I can't keep my court staff indefinitely. So, how long do you think you'll be? >> So, I >> got re-examination, of course. >> Uh I have another three pages of my notes um of of 25. So, that gives a sense of I really am nearly there. >> So, let me do the arithmetic. You've got three pages of 25. You've taken 5 hours so far. Uh >> It It It all should be no longer >> an hour, aren't you? >> Well, I I I I would like to be no more than 10 to 15 minutes. >> You might like to be, but you're going to go through a You're going to go through financial statements now. Everybody knows you can't go through financial statements slowly. >> I was only going to put one or two figures to Mr. Wangwe in the first Your Honor. >> Okay, look. You've got an extra quarter of an hour and then we'll see Mr. Watson in in re-examination. >> So, we were just going to look at the financial statement. He starts at page 1702. Now, the appointment of the auditor itself has been contentious, hasn't it, between the parties? Um But, let's have a look at 1717, please, Mr. Lankevich. And we scroll towards the bottom of that page. Here we are. We'll have to see there the shareholders' contributions to the 31st of December 2024. It That figure is Is that accurate? >> Uh which line item are you referring to specifically? >> Excuse me. I'm referring to your contribution of 7.1 million dirhams. >> Uh No, I believe that is understated. >> Uh and we can see here that KJM's uh uh contribution is stated at 1.4 million dirhams. Uh yes? >> That's what is written in the report, yes. >> Uh plus also uh uh uh uh item 19. >> Uh which page are we on? 1717 >> Okay, thank you. >> Uh that KJM Marine has made uh uh made payments on behalf of KJI to the tune of just under $4 million. Do you see that? >> I do see that. >> Do you accept that uh KJM put in his own money uh to to the joint venture? >> I do not accept that. >> Uh and uh Do you accept that KJI has suffered a loss? >> Without independent verification, your honor, from a a a what I would deem a top-tier auditor, independent auditor. These are just numbers on a page. I I don't I don't find any of these reliable or accurate without independent verification. >> Well, let's have just have a look at one of those numbers. Look page 1703. Can you see the uh accumulated losses uh just under 9 million dirhams? You see that? >> I do. >> So, the auditor here uh Unity Auditing is reporting that the company has suffered a significant loss. You accept that? >> That is what is written on this document, yes. >> You said that your relationship with Mr. Al Jassmi has completely broken down. >> No, I do I do not. I I like Muhammad. Every time I see him, we kiss on both cheeks and are very cordial. Frankly, I don't know. >> I'm sorry to interrupt you. Go ahead. >> When was the last time you saw him? >> Um I want to say there probably the the last um board meeting that I attended and I I'm going by memory and I I want to say September, October of last year. But I I Don't Don't hold me to that, but I It's been I have not seen them in the calendar year of 2026 that I that I recall. >> You said you've made allegations of uh misconduct against Baruch. >> Um Correct, and Mr. Al Jassmi, as well. >> Yes. Uh and and they in turn have made uh allegations against you. You accept that? >> I do. >> Uh Uh, do you accept that KGI is now uh insolvent? >> I have no reliable information, nor have I ever been given any reliable information about KGI's activities, where my investment, my family's investment has been allocated. I have no idea. I've been in the dark from day one. >> You accept that there is no joint plan for the company's future. >> Um I I I don't accept that. >> Your case is that you don't know how your funds have been used, um but we we did see in the budget a detailed breakdown. That's on page 913. Have you seen that? >> I do remember seeing that. >> And in through the course of today, you've given evidence about the frequency with which you visited Dubai and the factory. Do you recall that? >> I do. >> So, you accept that money was spent on a factory lease, yes? >> Uh I do. >> Industrial license? >> I do. >> Some manufacturing process? >> I do. >> Uh staff? >> I do. >> Equipment? >> I do. >> Uh And we can see here page 1201. Uh Uh, this is the uh email. It looks like a few times in the bullet points. Where you talk here about one prototype, one working version, and four to five holes in production. I'll see if I can find the precise location for you. >> Yes. >> Uh, so you you accept that's what uh, you had seen by that date. >> Um, that's by the time of this email, that's what I had seen, yes. >> Yes. And that's Excuse me, I've now found the page myself. It's 1 2 3 It's It's a third black um, circle bullet point. >> Which begins with a purchase order has been received dated 10 10 2023. >> Exactly. And then your uh, I think this is your comment in response I saying, "I think we have one prototype, one working version, and four to five holes in production." You see that? >> Yes. >> So, um, this is not it would be unfair to say that you were completely in the dark at this point about how your money was being spent. You accept that? >> It would be completely fair. I had no backup to anything, how much anything cost. There was never budgets provided or approved in the normal course of business. I had an idea, but I mean, there was there was no transparency to to anything. >> Let's have a look then at page one. >> To answer your question, Your Honor, I saw money was being spent but in what quantum in verifiable amounts, no idea. >> Uh and let's moving forward in time to the 9th of August, 2024, page 1349. Uh this is an email from Mr. Radwan uh uh saying that the external auditor has issued a draft of the annual financials through the May 2024. You see that? >> I do. >> Uh I don't think that document itself has made it into our bundle, but we've seen uh an audit report up on 31st of December. And do you accept that if we look at the attachments there, you talked earlier about paper clips, um we can see there was an attachment. If you look at the second one, it's called KGI financial statement June till May 2024. You see that? >> I It seems based on this email, there are seven attachments. Yes. >> Uh and so accept that you were provided at time with a financial statement for the company. >> I I would categorize it, your honor, that I was provided an unverified page with a bunch of numbers that were essentially meaningless to me. >> Well, I suggest Mr. Ankowicz that the um the reason everything collapsed is simply that the joint venture ran out of money. Uh and you refused to provide any more money. Is that right? >> Well, the joint venture collapsed because I think Mr. El Jasmi became disappointed that I wanted an accounting of where my money went. And I was perfectly I was perfectly happy, the family was perfectly happy to keep funding the company with accurate information and a full accounting of where the money went and transparency and corporate governance which was owed to us. >> The relevance to Mr. Ivankovich is that both you and KGM lost money in this venture. Do you accept that? >> I I don't accept it at all. I I accept that we lost money. I I I have absolutely no idea what KGM took, didn't take, made, didn't make. And I really would like to know that. >> And finally, I suggest to you that the letter of termination sent on 10th of September was valid and that the relationship has been properly terminated. Do you accept that? >> I do not accept that. >> Thank you. I am I think 1 minute within my extended >> You are indeed. Do we have a copy of the lease of the premises? >> No, your honor. >> So, no copy of lease. Do we know if it's in KJI's name or KJM's name? >> That would be a question for you to pose to Mr. Al Jasmi tomorrow, your honor. >> Okay. Well, maybe not maybe not then. >> Your honor, I have an answer to that question. >> Yeah. >> I can answer that question. The The lease is in is in KJI's name. I've spoken to a representative of the landlord. I did find out subsequently that Mr. Al Jasmi approached the landlord and tried to get the lease changed to KJM's name misrepresenting to the landlord according to their agents that the companies had merged. The landlord's representative informed me that he re- asked for evidence of that merger from Mr. Al Jassimi, which he didn't provide. So, he didn't change the name of the lease to KJM. Um and that so as far as I know, the last communication with the representative was in January of this year. And it it was expiring but being extended in KJI's name. >> Okay, thank you. Mr. Watson, I've got a couple of questions for uh Mr. Vankevich. Probably better if I ask them before re-examination. >> Well, I can I can assist in that I have no questions in re-examination. >> You have no re-examination. Well, in that case, that's that's uh that makes life easier. Um I just one very simple question um Mr. Vankevich. Uh uh From my reading, I'd I'd rather thought that Octopussy was the um Sunseeker, but it's not. It's a It's a It's another It's another boat, is it? >> Yes, it's a it's a 150-ft Heesen that was specifically carved out >> 150-ft Sorry, what? >> Uh Heesen. It's a Dutch a Dutch builder. >> Okay. How do you spell that? >> Uh Heesen H E E S E N >> Thank you. Okay, and that you said was carved out. >> Yeah, it it in it was a a vessel the family owned um in the construction of the of the JV, we were both contributing to avoid conflicts of interest all of our mari- maritime activities into KJI but we specifically requested that that that the octopussy um be carved out of of that activity, which it was in the JV. >> Okay. Uh next question. Can we just go to the loan document at page 904, please? Do you have that before you? >> I do, your honor. >> Yeah. Okay. So, the object of the loan is expressed there uh for the purchase of uh uh the uh vessel from uh Sino Eagle for 399 3.99 million. Uh and K J M undertook a clause 4A to purchase the vessel. Did you ask for evidence of the contract of purchase at this early stage? >> Um at this early stage, no, your honor. And >> Why not? >> Well, >> It's the basis of the loan agreement. >> Yeah, the So, the reason the loan agreement came up and it wasn't structured the same way as the Sunseeker. So, um in my mind, according to the re- reading and the intent of the JV was we would advance money uh outside of this loan agreement to to purchase the Aquila. It would be part of the JV. It would be sold and that revenue would become revenue of the KJI company. Um Mr. Al Jasmi was really pushing me to do this transaction. I really didn't want to do it, but I didn't want to you know, what if there was a way to make this I wanted I wanted more than the 50% contemplated. So, we structured it as as a loan where we believed there was security, but you know, again, we didn't contemplate that we would have to we thought we would be given transparency to the to the contract, but it was in fact KJM that was guaranteeing this loan backed by Mr. Karafi, so we thought our money was safe and that they wouldn't you know, they wouldn't do silly things when purchasing this boat. >> But didn't didn't you want to see documents of of title and indeed the the the contract with with the with with the yard? I mean, you need documents of title for insurance, classification, you name it. >> We we did and that was requested in in numerous emails by Mr. Moore and was never provided to us. >> But that's later on. I mean, >> Yes. >> I I'm going back right to the beginning. I mean, why didn't you want to see that documentation to know that there there was a boat, the conditions under which it was being built and that it would be seaworthy? >> Well, the the boat was built to our understanding and per perhaps in my naivety, your honor, I I never would believe that we would at that point of the relationship that we would be treated in such a way by our partner, especially we both had a vested interest from making a profit of this. >> Okay, well, let's let's then fast forward to when the scales would have fallen away from your eyes. Uh and and the uh uh to use uh the the back end of relationship. So, you're being told that it was a condition of the contract with the yard that the 1.6 million was forfeit. >> We were we were Yes, we were told that much later. >> Didn't you want to Didn't you want to see the contract at the time you were told that? >> And and we did ask for it then, absolutely. >> And you asked for it, but didn't you want steps taken against the yard to try and recover the money? >> We We We can't We We took steps through Mr. Hand to directly contact the yard um to go out and travel and see the yard. We were informed by a representative of the yard that they would not that they were informed by KJM not to directly deal with us. Um yes, we took those steps post facto to try and buy the boat directly from the yard to visit the yard, to let them know that we were the funder behind this. And my understanding through the conversations with Mr. Hand is that that transparent open eye dialogue was actively being blocked by KJM. >> But what about proceedings in China against the yard? >> Uh well, Your Honor, um having experience in China, I I I think the answer is it was determined that we wouldn't have standing to make proceedings against the factory since the relationship or purported contract would be between K J N and the factory and it that would just be good money after bad. >> Okay, I understand that. Uh any questions arising out of uh what I've just asked, Mr. Page? >> Not for me, your honor. >> Uh any re-examination of what I've just asked, Mr. Watson? >> None for me, your honor. >> Okay, well, in that case, uh thank you very much, Mr. Ivankovich. Um it it it is uh I think approaching 8:30 in the morning for you. Uh have a good rest of the day. >> Th- thank you, your honor. I think I'm due a Bloody Mary at this hour. >> Uh you probably are. Uh and um I will see then everybody uh else tomorrow morning uh actually 11:00 a.m. Dubai time. Thank you very much indeed.