---
title: "Ivankovich Family LLC adversary — Bankr. S.D. Fla. abstention order (2025-02-26)"
source_court: "Bankr. S.D. Fla."
docket: "24-01411-LMI"
order_date: "2025-02-26"
claim_label: "Verified - verbatim public court record"
mirrors: "records/text/ivankovich-family-bk-adversary-opinion.txt"
public_records_notice: "HelmLegal public records mirror. Not a law firm. Not legal advice. Not a PACER substitute."
---

# Ivankovich Family LLC adversary — Bankr. S.D. Fla. abstention order (2025-02-26)

> **Public-record mirror.** This page reproduces a court order/opinion for public-record research. It is not legal advice, is not a finding of liability beyond what the court actually held, and is not a substitute for PACER or licensed counsel. Dollar figures appear only as stated in the underlying court document.

---

--- page 1 ---
 
Tagged opinion  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT 
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 
 
 
ORDER ON MOTION TO ABSTAIN FROM ADJUDICATING COUNTS II, IV, 
AND VI OF PLAINTIFFS’ ADVERSARY COMPLAINT 
IN RE:  
 
IVANKOVICH FAMILY LLC, A&O 
FAMILY LLC (FLORIDA), A & O 
FAMILY LLC (ILLINOIS), ATLAS P2 
MANAGING MEMBER, LLC.  
 
              Debtors-In-Possession. 
___________________________________/ 
CASE NOS.   24-15755-LMI 
                     24-15762-LMI 
                     24-15767-LMI 
                     24-15770-LMI 
Chapter  11 
 
 
IVANKOVICH FAMILY LLC, A&O 
FAMILY LLC (FLORIDA),  A & O 
FAMILY LLC (ILLINOIS),  ATLAS P2 
MANAGING MEMBER, LLC., 
ANTHONY IVANKOVICH, and OLGA 
IVANKOVICH,  
 
                      Plaintiffs, 
vs. 
 
JEANETTE IVANKOVICH, SCHILLER 
DUCANTO & FLECK LLP, and 
STEVEN  IVANKOVICH,  
 
                       Defendants. 
___________________________________/ 
ADV. CASE NO. 24-1411-LMI 
Laurel M. Isicoff, Judge 
United States Bankruptcy Court
___________________________________________________________________________
ORDERED in the Southern District of Florida on February 26, 2025.
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 1 of 13
--- page 2 ---
 
2 
 
This matter came before the Court for a hearing on January 29, 2025 and 
then again on February 11, 2025 for a further hearing (the “Hearings”) upon the 
Motion to Abstain from Adjudicating Counts II, IV, and VI of Plaintiffs’ Adversary 
Complaint (ECF #31) (the “Abstention Motion”) filed by Defendants, Jeannette 
Ivankovich (“Jeannette”) and Schiller Ducanto & Fleck LLP, (“Schiller”) 
(collectively, the “Defendants”). The Court has reviewed the Complaint1, 
Abstention Motion, the Joint Response and Joint Supplemental Response2  filed by 
the Debtors Ivankovich Family LLC, A&O Family LLC (FL), A&O Family LLC (IL), 
and Atlas P2 Managing Member, LLC (collectively, the “Debtors”) and Anthony and 
Olga Ivankovich (collectively, the “Doctors”) (together, the “Plaintiffs”), the 
Defendants’ Reply3, and considered argument of the parties at the Hearings. For 
the reasons set forth below, the Court will exercise its discretion and permissively 
abstain from adjudicating Counts II and VI of the Complaint pursuant to 28 
U.S.C. §1334(c)(1).4 
FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY 
 
1 Complaint for Objection to Claims and Interests of Jeanette Ivankovich and Schiller, Ducanto & 
Fleck LLP, and for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief (ECF #1) (the “Complaint”).  
2 Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendants’ Motion to Abstain from Adjudicating Counts II, IV, and VI of 
Plaintiff's Adversary Complaint (ECF #36) (the “Joint Response”); Joint Supplemental Response to 
Defendants’ Motion to Abstain from Adjudicating Counts II, IV, and VI of Plainitffs’ [sic] Adversary 
Complaint (ECF #48) (the “Joint Supplemental Response”).  
3 Defendants’ Reply in Support of Defendants’ Motion to Abstain [ECF 31] and in Opposition to 
Plaintiffs’ Joint Response to Defendants’ Motion to Abstain from Adjudicating Counts II, IV, and VI 
Plaintiffs’ Adversary Complaint [ECF 36] and Plaintiff’s Supplemental Response [ECF 48] (ECF #49) 
(the “Defendants’ Reply”). 
4 At the Hearings, the Court granted Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss (defined hereinafter) as to 
Count IV. Therefore, this opinion addresses the abstention arguments only as to the remaining 
Counts II and VI.  
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 2 of 13
--- page 3 ---
 
3 
 
The Debtors are a string of related investment companies whose ownership 
interests are in dispute. The Debtors were allegedly founded by the Doctors and 
managed by the Doctors’ son, Steven Ivankovich (“Steven”). Steven is in the midst 
of a contentious divorce proceeding with his estranged wife – the Defendant 
Jeanette. The divorce is pending in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois 
County Department, Domestic Relations Division as In re: Marriage of Jeanette 
Ivankovich (Petitioner) and Steven Ivankovich (Respondent), Case Number 2021-D-
9220 (the “Illinois Divorce Proceeding” or the “Illinois Divorce Court”).  
 
Jeanette initiated the Illinois Divorce Proceeding against Steven on October 
22, 2021.5 On March 12, 2024, after an evidentiary hearing, the Illinois Divorce 
Court found that Jeanette has a clear protectable right in some of the Debtors’ 
assets (by virtue of Steven’s affiliation with them or control over them) because 
said assets are marital property and entered a preliminary injunction against 
Steven and his affiliates (the “Preliminary Injunction”).6 The Preliminary Injunction 
enjoined Steven from dissipating, destroying, transferring, encumbering, 
concealing, or otherwise disposing of some of the Debtors’ assets held in 
investment accounts at Celadon Financial Group ("Celadon"). Pursuant to the 
Preliminary Injunction, Celadon was ordered to pay Jeanette child support and 
spousal support in the amount of $651,446.38 in satisfaction of unpaid support 
judgments entered in favor of Jeannette and against Steven. Celadon was also 
ordered to pay Jeanette’s counsel, Schiller, $400,000.00 for legal fees and 
 
5 A copy of the Illinois Divorce Proceeding docket is attached to the Joint Supplemental Response 
(ECF #48). 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 3 of 13
--- page 4 ---
 
4 
$25,000.00 for the appointment of a forensic accounting expert. The Preliminary 
Injunction also ordered that the Celadon accounts be frozen in order to preserve 
the Debtors’ assets until the Illinois Divorce Court had the opportunity to 
determine what interests Jeanette has in the Debtors’ assets. Steven and the 
Debtors appealed the Preliminary Injunction to the First Judicial District in and 
for the Appellate Court of Illinois, Appellate Case Number 1-24-1118 (the 
“Appeal”); however, the Appeal is currently stayed as a result of the Debtors’ 
bankruptcy.7 
 
After the entry of the Preliminary Injunction and apparently prior to the 
Debtors’ bankruptcy filing, the Illinois Divorce Court ruled that Ivankovich Family 
LLC, A&O Family LLC (Florida), A & O Family LLC (Illinois), and the Doctors are 
necessary parties to the Illinois Divorce Proceeding.  The Doctors have been joined 
as necessary parties, but due to the bankruptcy cases, the Debtors have not been 
joined. 
 
The Illinois Divorce Proceedings have been ongoing for over three years. 
Jeannette argues that the delay is due to Steven’s bad faith and serial litigation 
habits and in support of this argument, attaches to her reply a sanctions order 
entered by the Illinois Divorce Court against Steven (the “Sanctions Order”).8  The 
Sanctions Order sanctioned Steven $420,000 and his counsel $70,000 for 
 
6 The Preliminary Injunction is attached as Exhibit A to the Debtors’ Response in Opposition to 
Motion to Dismiss Count IV (ECF #17-1).  
7 Jeanette filed a Motion for Determination that Automatic Stay Does Not Apply to State Court 
Divorce Proceeding or, Alternatively, for Relief from Automatic Stay to Allow State Court Divorce 
Proceeding to Determine Jeanette Ivankovich’s Domestic Support Obligation Claim Including Any 
Attorney Fees Assessed and to Determine Ownership of Debtors (ECF #123 in the Main Case) (the 
“Stay Relief Motion”) requesting stay relief to allow the Appeal to go forward, which the Debtors 
opposed. The Court denied Jeanette’s request.  
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 4 of 13
--- page 5 ---
 
5 
delaying the proceedings and presenting facts that were not well grounded and 
were blatantly false.  
 
While the Illinois Divorce Proceeding was pending, on November 13, 2023, 
Steven filed an action against Defendants in the Circuit Court of the 11th Judicial 
Circuit of Miami-Dade County, Florida seeking declaratory relief that assets of 
some of the Debtor LLCs were not assets of Steven and a declaration of marital 
rights of Jeanette, if any, to membership interests in the LLCs (the “Florida 
Action”). On December 26, 2023, the Florida Action  was removed to United States 
District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Miami Division, Case Number 
23-cv-24894-FAM. The district court dismissed Steven’s complaint on July 1, 
20249 based in part on the Colorado River10 abstention doctrine finding that the 
Illinois Divorce Court is the proper court to determine whether Steven’s interests 
in the LLCs constitute marital property and if so, to determine what interest 
Jeanette owns in those LLCs.11  
 
On June 10, 2024 (the “Petition Date”), the Debtors filed separate voluntary 
petitions for relief under Chapter 11 of Title 11 of the United States Code (the 
“Bankruptcy Code”); the four bankruptcy cases were subsequently consolidated 
 
8 See Sanctions Order, attached as Exhibit A to Defendants’ Reply (ECF #49). 
9 Ivankovich v. Ivankovich, 2024 WL 3251570 (S.D. Fla. 2024).  
10 The Colorado River abstention doctrine applies in cases that involve substantially the same 
parties and substantially the same issues. Colorado River Water Conservation Dist. v. United States, 
424 U.S. 800 (1976). Upon establishing substantially similar parties and issues, the Court must 
engage in a six-factor analysis to analyze the permissibility of abstention. Ambrosia Coal and 
Const. Co. v. Pages Morales, 368 F.3 1320, 1330 (11th Cir. 2004). Those factors are as follows: (1) 
whether one of the courts has assumed jurisdiction over the property, (2) inconvenience of the 
federal forum, (3) the potential for piecemeal litigation, (4) the order in which the fora obtained 
jurisdiction, (5) whether state or federal law will be applied, and (6) the adequacy of the state court 
to protect the parties’ rights. Id. (internal citations omitted). 
11 Steven appealed the dismissal order on July 31, 2024 (USCA, 24-12480-F), but voluntarily 
dismissed the appeal on September 3, 2024.  
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 5 of 13
--- page 6 ---
 
6 
for joint administration (the “Main Case”).12 Jeanette filed proofs of interest in 
each of the Debtors' bankruptcies for an "unknown" interest "representing a yet to 
be determined share of the equity" of the Debtors as "marital property" (Proof of 
Interest No. 6-1 in Case No. 24-15755-LMI; Proof of Interest No. 8-1 in Case No. 
24-15762-LMI; Proof of Interest No. 6-1 in Case No. 24-15767-LMI; Proof of 
Interest No. 7-1 in Case No. 24-15770-LMI) (the "Disputed Interests"). 
 
On October 17, 2024, the Plaintiffs initiated this adversary proceeding by 
filing the Complaint. On November 25, 2024, Defendants filed a Motion to Dismiss 
Counts II, IV, and VI of Adversary Complaint (ECF #10) (the “Motion to Dismiss”) 
and subsequently filed the Abstention Motion on January 22, 2025. In the 
Abstention Motion, Defendants ask this Court to abstain from adjudicating 
Counts II and VI of the Complaint (the “Counts”). Count II is an objection to the 
Disputed Interests brought by the Doctors against Jeanette and Count VI is 
brought by the Doctors against Jeanette and Steven for declaratory relief as to 
ownership of the Debtors. Defendants argue that mandatory abstention under 28 
U.S.C. §1334(c)(2) applies to the Counts and alternatively, argues that the Court 
should permissively abstain from adjudicating the relief sought in the Counts 
pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1334(c)(1).13  
In their Joint Response, the Plaintiffs argued that the Abstention Motion 
was untimely pursuant to Local Rule 5011-2(A), which provides: “[a] motion to 
 
12 Ivankovich Family LLC 24-15755-LMI; Atlas P 2 Managing Member LLC 24-15770-LMI; A&O 
Family LLC(Florida) 24-15762-LMI; and A&O Family LLC (Illinois) 24-15767-LMI. 
13 As another alternative basis, Defendants argue that the Younger  and Colorado River abstention 
doctrines support abstention. Younger v. Harris, 401 U.S. 37 (1971);  Colorado River, 424 U.S. 800. 
The Court does not need to determine whether either doctrine applies because the Court is 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 6 of 13
--- page 7 ---
 
7 
abstain from an adversary proceeding shall be filed not later than the date set for 
filing a response under Bankruptcy Rule 7012 and these local rules.” The deadline 
for filing a response to the Complaint was November 25, 202414, which 
Defendants timely complied with by filing their Motion to Dismiss on that date. 
The Abstention Motion was not filed until January 22, 2025 and therefore, the 
Court ruled at the January 29 Hearing that the Abstention Motion was untimely.  
However, because the Court has the authority to  permissively abstain sua 
sponte from adjudicating the Counts, the Court continued the hearing to February 
11 to allow the parties to submit further briefing on permissive abstention only.   
ANALYSIS 
A bankruptcy court may abstain “from hearing a particular proceeding 
arising under title 11 or arising in or related to cases under title 11” when to do so 
would be “in the interest of justice, or in the interest of comity with State courts or 
respect for State law.” 28 U.S.C. §1334(c)(1). 
Any factors considered by a court in determining whether to exercise its 
discretion to abstain is governed by the three statutory factors – the interest of 
justice, interest of comity with state courts, and respect for state law. AASI 
Creditor Liquidating Trust v. Peoplesoft, USA (In re All Am. Semiconductor, Inc.), 
2010 WL 2854153, at *2 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2010). 
 
In analyzing these three statutory factors, several courts, including this 
Court, have applied a list of non-exclusive factors a court should consider when 
 
permissively abstaining pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1334(c)(1).  
14 See Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Extend Time to File Response to Adversary 
Complaint (ECF #8).  
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 7 of 13
--- page 8 ---
 
8 
deciding whether permissive abstention is appropriate.  
(1) 
The effect, or lack of effect, on the efficient administration of 
the bankruptcy estate if discretionary abstention is exercised; 
 
(2) 
The extent to which state law issues predominate over 
bankruptcy issues; 
 
(3) 
The difficulty or unsettled nature of the applicable state law; 
 
(4) 
The presence of related proceedings commenced in state court 
or other non-bankruptcy courts; 
 
(5) 
The jurisdictional basis, if any, other than § 1334; 
 
(6) 
The degree of relatedness or remoteness of the proceedings to 
the main bankruptcy case; 
 
(7) 
The substance rather than the form of an asserted “core” 
proceeding; 
 
(8) 
The feasibility of severing state law claims from core 
bankruptcy matters to allow judgments to be entered in state 
court with enforcement left to the bankruptcy court; 
 
(9) 
The burden on the bankruptcy court’s docket; 
 
(10) 
The likelihood that the commencement of the proceedings in 
bankruptcy court involves forum shopping by one of the 
parties; 
 
(11) 
The existence of a right to jury trial; 
 
(12) 
The presence in the proceeding of non-debtor parties; 
 
(13) 
Comity; and 
 
(14) 
The possibility of prejudice to other parties in the action.  
 
Id. (citing E.S. Bankest, LLC v. United Beverage Florida, LLC (In re United Container 
LLC), 284 B.R. 162, 176 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2002)). No particular factor is 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 8 of 13
--- page 9 ---
 
9 
controlling and it is within the discretion of the court how much weight, if any, 
should be given to any particular factor.  Id. (internal citations omitted).   
Plaintiffs first argue that permissive abstention should be denied because 
this Court has “core” jurisdiction and constitutional authority to finally adjudicate 
the disputed ownership interests in the Debtors under 28 U.S.C. §157(b), citing to 
cases that hold that the filing of a proof of interest and the resolution thereof 
constitute core proceedings within the equity jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court. 
See In re AVN Corp., 235 B.R. 417 (W.D. Tenn. 1999); In re Jordan River 
Resources, Inc., 455 B.R. 657 (Bankr. W.D. Mich. 2011). Defendants argue that 
the Counts are non-core, related to, matters because Jeanette’s claims, which 
arise from unpaid support owed by Steven and her claimed equity interests are 
both issues that are squarely before the Illinois Divorce Court, and are state law 
marital issues.  
The Plaintiffs also argue that the Court has core jurisdiction because the 
very structure of the bankruptcy plan that has been filed by the Debtors (the 
“Chapter 11 Plan”)15 hinges on resolution of the ownership of the Debtors, since, 
under the Chapter 11 Plan, the equity interests in the Debtors will be 
extinguished and new equity issued. 
Whether the Counts constitute core matters is not outcome determinative of 
this Court’s decision whether to permissively abstain from adjudicating the 
Counts. See In re 160 Royal Palm, LLC, 2020 WL 4792094 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2020) 
(permissively abstaining from a core matter); In re Best Reception Sys., Inc., 220 
 
15 Debtors’ Joint Plan of Reorganization (ECF #202 in the Main Case). 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 9 of 13
--- page 10 ---
 
10 
B.R. 932, 955 (Bankr. E.D. Tenn. 1998) (“courts may abstain from hearing core 
proceedings under the authority of § 1334(c)(1).”); In re Condra, 212 B.R. 987, 992 
(Bankr. M.D. Ala. 1997) (“Discretionary abstention is available in core and non-
core proceedings. Even if this matter were a civil proceeding which is related to a 
case under Chapter 11, the court should abstain where the case was brought and 
should be timely heard in a state forum.”). Regarding the argument that the 
resolution of the Chapter 11 Plan hinges on resolution of the ownership in the 
Debtors, the Court has already advised the parties that the Court will not set a 
confirmation hearing on the Chapter 11 Plan until the issue of Jeannette’s 
interests in the Debtors has been resolved.  
Applying the three statutory factors, with the overlay of the United Container 
factors, the Court finds that it is appropriate to abstain from adjudicating the 
relief sought in the Counts.  
The first statutory factor is the “interest of justice.” In applying the “interest 
of justice” factor to this case, the Court considers the likelihood that the 
commencement of the proceedings in bankruptcy court involves forum shopping 
by one of the parties.  
In this case, forum shopping with respect to the relief sought in the Counts 
is clear. These issues have been pending in Illinois Divorce Court for over three 
years. On September 14, 2023, the Illinois Divorce Court issued a temporary 
restraining order (the “TRO”) enjoining, with some exceptions the disposition, etc. 
of certain assets held at Celadon.  On November 6, 2023, the Illinois Divorce Court 
ruled that the TRO would stay in place until a final order regarding Jeannette’s 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 10 of 13
--- page 11 ---
 
11 
request for a Preliminary Injunction.  Steven filed the Florida Action on November 
13, 2023, only one week later.  Steven appealed the dismissal of the Florida Action 
to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals but voluntarily dismissed that appeal on 
September 3, 2024.  This adversary proceeding was filed only a month later. 
The second and third statutory factors are “comity” and “respect for state 
law.” When state law issues predominate the proceedings, “[c]omity for the state 
courts and the general principle that cases arising under state law should 
generally be tried in the state court weigh in favor of permissive abstention.” 
United Container LLC, 284 B.R. at 177. None of the parties dispute that the issues 
regarding whether and to what extent Steven has an interest in the Debtors, and 
to what extent Jeanette has a marital interest in Steven’s interest in the Debtors is 
governed entirely by state law, with factors relating to Illinois family law bearing 
weight on that analysis. Thus, both comity and respect for state law warrant 
abstention. 
Turning to some of the other factors outlined in United Container 
underscores the appropriateness of abstention. All of the parties involved in the 
Counts are non-debtors. The Counts are both brought by the Doctors against 
Jeanette and Steven and solely relate to a determination of ownership of the 
Debtors. These exact issues are currently pending in the Illinois Divorce Court in 
which the Doctors, Steven, and Jeanette (that is, all those claiming a legal or 
beneficial interest in the Debtors’ equity) are parties. As the Court reiterated at the 
October 30, 2024 hearing on Jeannette’s Stay Relief Motion, the equity interests in 
the Debtors are not property of the estate and therefore not subject to the 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 11 of 13
--- page 12 ---
 
12 
automatic stay. For those same reasons, a determination of ownership of the 
Debtors bears a limited connection to the Debtors’ bankruptcy case, and only 
because of the provision in the Chapter 11 Plan impacting equity. “When a state 
court proceeding sounds in state law and bears a limited connection to a debtor's 
bankruptcy case, abstention is particularly compelling.” Id.  
Plaintiffs argue that the dispute over ownership of the equity interests in the 
Debtors cannot be timely adjudicated in the Illinois Divorce Proceeding given that 
the case has already been pending for over three years and the Illinois Divorce 
Proceeding was just transferred to a new judge. The Plaintiffs assert that 
interested parties will be prejudiced if this bankruptcy case is effectively put on 
hold while awaiting final adjudication of the ownership issues in the Illinois 
Divorce Proceeding. Defendants counter that the only reason the Illinois Divorce 
Proceeding has been prolonged is due to Steven’s bad faith and serial litigation 
habits, all as outlined in the Sanctions Order. Whether decided by this Court, or 
by the Illinois Divorce Court, the bankruptcy proceedings will be delayed until the 
ownership issue is resolved.  Moreover, there is nothing preventing the Debtors in 
this surplus bankruptcy case from filing an amended bankruptcy plan that does 
not depend on resolution of the equity dispute. 
The Court finds that requiring the parties to start the litigation anew in this 
Court would be a burden on the Court’s docket and prejudice Jeanette who has 
been actively litigating the same issues before the Illinois Divorce Court for several 
years. Moreover, it is unnecessary for this Court to adjudicate the relief sought in 
the Counts when the Illinois Divorce Court has the most familiarity with the law 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 12 of 13
--- page 13 ---
 
13 
impacting the resolution. Both comity and respect for the Illinois Divorce Court 
and Illinois marital law make clear the appropriateness of abstention.  
CONCLUSION 
 
 
Having considered the above relevant factors, the Court concludes that it 
should abstain from adjudicating the Counts pursuant to the permissive 
abstention provision of 28 U.S.C. §1334(c)(1) and that doing so is in the interest of 
justice, in the interest of comity with state courts, and respect for state law. 
Accordingly, it is hereby, 
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED as follows: the Abstention Motion (ECF #31) is 
GRANTED.        
### 
Copies furnished to: 
Patricia A. Redmond, Esq.  
Eyal Berger, Esq.  
David L. Rosendorf Esq.  
 
Attorney Redmond is directed to serve a copy of this Order on interested 
parties who do not receive service by CM/ECF, and file a proof of such service 
within two (2) business days from entry of the Order. 
 
Case 24-01411-LMI    Doc 53    Filed 02/26/25    Page 13 of 13
