Compiled exclusively from public court filings, docket entries, and trial transcripts in Contessa Marine Research LLC v. Starboard Yacht Group LLC, No. 0:23-cv-61696-RNS (S.D. Fla.), and the public Federal Judicial Center biography. Every row carries a docket pin. This page does not allege judicial misconduct, bias, or bribery. Where the public record cannot establish a fact, it is labeled UNMEASURED or ALLEGED. HelmLegal is not a law firm; nothing on this page is legal advice. Corrections are welcome via the corrections page.
A litigant's verified 151-page accounting was filed, raised at trial, and never engaged by the findings of fact — while opposing exhibits were admitted the morning they appeared and the litigant's own filings were stricken and restricted. The docketed pattern is documented below with entry numbers. The purpose of this page is to give the Court a complete public record of what the docket itself shows — including the documented integrity problems in the evidentiary record the Court was asked to decide on — so that any reader, attorney, journalist, or reviewer can verify every line against the public docket.
| Docket pin | What the record shows | Label |
|---|---|---|
| DE 237 | 151-page verified accounting filed 8/27/25 — CFO-certified line-by-line account of $4,504,641.18 received from Contessa, $0.00 unaccounted; spans ~9 vessels / 156 repair orders | VERIFIED-DOC |
| Tr. 62:20–21 | CJS cited the accounting on the stand at trial — "my CFO's declaration of 153 pages" — it was raised, not merely available | VERIFIED-TR |
| DE 337 | Findings of Fact state "$3,027,994.72 unaccounted" — the words DE 237, Kenny, and "declaration" appear zero times in the 40-page order | VERIFIED-DOC |
| DE 341 | Second Rule 59(e) denied — the denial recites an "available before judgment" frame the findings never applied to DE 237 | VERIFIED-DOC |
| Access / process item | CJS / SYG record | Contessa record |
|---|---|---|
| CM/ECF filing access | 2× registrations "processed," no access; helpdesk escalations unresolved | Full e-filing throughout |
| Evidence filings | DE 315 filed → restricted same day → stricken (DE 318); unseal denied (DE 333) | Exhibits D-1/D-7/D-8 filed trial morning, admitted |
| Strike motions | CJS's strike/seal/sanction filings attacked and stricken (DE 317/318) | CJS's motion to strike Contessa's jury demand GRANTED (DE 224) |
| Post-judgment relief | 60(b)/(d) denied on LLC-capacity (DE 334); 59(e) denied (DE 341) | — |
| Forensic examination | DE 122 ordered forensic accountant → DE 143 abeyance → DE 232 ordered joint examiner notice → never docketed, never appointed | — |
| Depositions | Zero depositions by any party across 341 docket entries and ~29 months of discovery — Ivankovich and Gomulinski testified un-deposed | |
The asymmetry is the verified fact. What caused it is not established by the docket — see Analysis below.
| Item | Amount | Pin |
|---|---|---|
| Chargebacks included inside the four-category total AND added again as damages item (3) | $226,502.19 double-counted | VERIFIED arithmetic |
| Personal award as entered | $4,270,739.41 | DE 337 fn.21 |
| Award corrected for the double-count | $4,044,237.22 | ANALYSIS — arithmetic correction only |
| Same $226,502.19 reported inside SHM LMC's separate DE 268 judgment | potential duplicate recovery across judgments | ANALYSIS — not adjudicated |
The docket establishes that the evidentiary record before the Court was structurally narrowed at the admission layer: the verified multi-vessel accounting and the stricken filings existed in the case for months, while the exhibits actually admitted and tried were Octopussy-scoped composites. A trial transcript admission — Ivankovich's own "additional wires paid to Starboard and Mr. Stratmann for other boats" (Tr. 72–73) — confirms the multi-vessel scope was never genuinely disputed, only narrowed in presentation.
If a litigant's exhibits were curated, its filings stricken, and the opposing accounting never engaged, the resulting judgment can be wrong without anyone at the Court intending it. The public record is consistent with the Court having decided on an evidentiary picture that did not include the verified ledger — a pattern that would constitute fraud on the court if knowing. The public record does not establish the Court's knowledge. What it establishes is narrower and fully verifiable: the findings never engaged the sworn accounting, and the record was filtered before it arrived.
This is the "out" the record itself provides: every defect above is a defect in the record, remediable on appeal or Rule 59(e) on manifest-error grounds — the same grounds this judge's own published grant-pattern recognizes (manifest error of fact or law tied to a docket pin; internal arithmetic contradiction). No claim about the judge's state of mind is required to correct the judgment.
| Judicial bribery or corruption | UNMEASURED — no public record located; financial-disclosure review remains pending (see below) |
| Judge's knowledge of any evidence manipulation | UNMEASURED — unknowable from the public docket |
| Steven Ivankovich's credibility | ALLEGED — adverse findings exist in N.D. Ill. (Schenkier/Coleman), 7th Cir., and Cook County per filed pleadings; those are party-recorded allegations, not findings by this Court |
| Causation for the asymmetry | ANALYSIS — structural explanations (LLC-representation rule, counsel-channel deference, admission-layer narrowing) account for most of the pattern without any improper motive |
Federal judges file annual financial disclosure reports under the Ethics in Government Act (5 U.S.C. §§ 13101–13111), publicly searchable at pub.jefs.uscourts.gov. Reports filed 2022–present are downloadable; earlier years require Form AO-10A. Compensated outside income is reported by source. Status: UNMEASURED — measured 2026-11-19: CourtListener’s financial-disclosure collection holds no reports for this judge; periodic transaction reports are publicly visible via third-party aggregators, but the underlying reports are JEF-gated (registration required). Review remains pending. While a judge serves, these reports carry 18 U.S.C. § 1001 exposure for material false statements. This page will be updated if the review produces reportable findings; absence of a listed income source is not itself evidence of anything.